rltinha's review against another edition
4.0
Uma belíssima adaptação de «Um Conto de Natal» de Charles Dickens que, não obstante pegar numa narrativa mais que conhecida, faz dela uma fábula de Natal original e cativante.
Lee Bermejo faz um trabalho notável e a coloração não lhe fica atrás. Quanto ao lettering é que não acompanho as opiniões favoráveis. Eu sou míope, estou-me tão nas tintas para as belezas como a minha visão para o que fica mais distante, se a legibilidade for afectada o trabalho é mau.
Lee Bermejo faz um trabalho notável e a coloração não lhe fica atrás. Quanto ao lettering é que não acompanho as opiniões favoráveis. Eu sou míope, estou-me tão nas tintas para as belezas como a minha visão para o que fica mais distante, se a legibilidade for afectada o trabalho é mau.
ugmug's review against another edition
3.0
Well, I'm not sure how I feel about Batman: Damned. On one hand, it's appropriately dark, gritty, and beautiful. On the other, it's a try hard effort from perpetual edge-lord, Brian Azzarello. Plot-wise, Damned is intentionally abstract and open for interpretation.
It has all of the elements of a good Batman story, but how they fit together is a little different. I don't know if that's good or bad, but I was mostly satisfied by the final pages. This is not an essential read and I imagine most Bat fans will hate this. That said, this is worth a look if only for the gorgeous Lee Bermejo art.
It has all of the elements of a good Batman story, but how they fit together is a little different. I don't know if that's good or bad, but I was mostly satisfied by the final pages. This is not an essential read and I imagine most Bat fans will hate this. That said, this is worth a look if only for the gorgeous Lee Bermejo art.
cara_selene's review against another edition
3.0
I can't say this graphic novel will remain with me the way its predecessor, Joker, will, but I still enjoyed it. I love that it uses A Christmas Carol to explore Batman's past, present, and future and I liked the idea of connecting Batman with Scrooge. Unfortunately it's nowhere near as haunting as Joker (I know, I shouldn't compare, and I hate doing that, but in this instance I just can't help it). Thankfully, the artwork is perfect, as always. Realistic, gritty, disturbing yet beautiful. Lee Bermejo remains one of my favourite comic book artists today.
some_okie_dude27's review against another edition
An edited review of this book will come sooner or later, this last one was pretty bad.
shibosan's review against another edition
3.0
Историей не слишком впечатлен (комикс больше запомнится всей дурацкой шумихой вокруг члена Бэтмена, чем своим сюжетом), но арт Ли Бермехо просто шедевральный - одна звезда накинута исключительно за него.
shibosan's review against another edition
4.0
Идеальное чтение на зимние праздники, которое стоит взять и прочитать уже ради шикарнейшего арта Ли Бермехо (дополнительный балл только за него). Но и содержимое не подкачало, как оказалось Бермехо и тут хорош - очень симпатичное и драматичное переложение Christmas Carol в декорациях Готэма.
В русском издании (как всегда у Азбуки -просто отличном) добавили "для весу" и оригинальную Диккенсовскую историю, которую, несмотря на то, что она знакома по десяткам экранизаций, также было интересно перечитать (отметив попутно, что в описаниях молоденьких девушек автор был криповат).
4,5 звезды. Рекомендуется для приобретения и перечитывания в праздники.
В русском издании (как всегда у Азбуки -просто отличном) добавили "для весу" и оригинальную Диккенсовскую историю, которую, несмотря на то, что она знакома по десяткам экранизаций, также было интересно перечитать (отметив попутно, что в описаниях молоденьких девушек автор был криповат).
4,5 звезды. Рекомендуется для приобретения и перечитывания в праздники.
alcame's review against another edition
adventurous
dark
medium-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? A mix
- Strong character development? No
- Loveable characters? It's complicated
- Diverse cast of characters? No
- Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes
2.0