Reviews

Autumn's Secret Gift by Halle Stanford, Elise Allen

sean67's review against another edition

Go to review page

3.0

First tale of enchanted sister, each one a season, and well you see where it is going.
Pretty average and forgettable stuff, it would be difficult to get kids excited over this I think, but stranger things have happened.

debnanceatreaderbuzz's review against another edition

Go to review page

4.0

Mixed feelings about this one. For starters why are all the good people in the story girls and why are all the bad people boys? I liked, though, how the girls used the boys' tendency to fight among themselves to their advantage. I also liked how the plot was cleverly resolved by having all the girls and boys come together in the end in a way that was quite possible. And I liked it that Mother Nature saw a need for the bad boys in her scheme. But the girls and their love of sparkle was a bit too much.
More...