heleneintheclouds's review against another edition
4.5
4.5 stars
At times like these I need half stars, because 4 stars is too low for this funny, cute and heartfelt tale, and it's not perfect enough for 5 stars.
The story is narrated by Stella, who is speaking to her dead father. I immediately loved the sarcastic humour. An example:
"Who's there?" I asked. No one answered. Has anyone in a scary movie ever answered that question?
Oh, glad you asked, it's me the axe murderer. Dang it! That was actually supposed to be a surprise...
Chapter eleven
...
Chapter eleven has been eaten by a black hole. Please proceed to Chapter Twelve.
See what I mean? I could not count all the times the sassy narration made me smile.
Well, Stella ends up with a black hole as pet and she feeds him all the things she dislikes or remind her of her dead father, hoping they will disappear and she will feel less sad.
Eventually she herself enters the black hole to retrieve her dog. With a bunch of companions, she navigates the crazy inside of the black hole with a bathtub as vessel.
This was one of the things I liked less about the story. The world inside the black hole was weird, but not in a beautiful way, and there was less humour.
There were little illustrations throughout the book and the pages inside the black whole were actually black, some empty, some with words randomly draped around the pages. It made the book a very quirky and unique read.
Five chapters into the story I found myself comparing this book to Cressida Cowell's work. Sarcastic humour, crazy hilarious situations, pages coloured to match the situation in the book and sometimes beautiful quotes.
At times like these I need half stars, because 4 stars is too low for this funny, cute and heartfelt tale, and it's not perfect enough for 5 stars.
The story is narrated by Stella, who is speaking to her dead father. I immediately loved the sarcastic humour. An example:
"Who's there?" I asked. No one answered. Has anyone in a scary movie ever answered that question?
Oh, glad you asked, it's me the axe murderer. Dang it! That was actually supposed to be a surprise...
Chapter eleven
...
Chapter eleven has been eaten by a black hole. Please proceed to Chapter Twelve.
See what I mean? I could not count all the times the sassy narration made me smile.
Well, Stella ends up with a black hole as pet and she feeds him all the things she dislikes or remind her of her dead father, hoping they will disappear and she will feel less sad.
Eventually she herself enters the black hole to retrieve her dog. With a bunch of companions, she navigates the crazy inside of the black hole with a bathtub as vessel.
This was one of the things I liked less about the story. The world inside the black hole was weird, but not in a beautiful way, and there was less humour.
There were little illustrations throughout the book and the pages inside the black whole were actually black, some empty, some with words randomly draped around the pages. It made the book a very quirky and unique read.
Five chapters into the story I found myself comparing this book to Cressida Cowell's work. Sarcastic humour, crazy hilarious situations, pages coloured to match the situation in the book and sometimes beautiful quotes.
shksprsis's review
emotional
funny
sad
fast-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? A mix
- Strong character development? Yes
- Loveable characters? Yes
- Diverse cast of characters? Yes
- Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes
4.5
whitneydrew's review against another edition
3.0
This was a sweet funny read that deals with grief. Not what I was looking for (searching for a book club pick for my kids), but I enjoyed it.
stephsj's review
5.0
I'm trying to read more middle grade and children's fiction this year! I've been working as a children's librarian, which is amazing, but I've realized that I'm really not "with it" anymore. Kids come in asking for suggestions and it takes me a good twenty minutes to pinpoint a book in their reading level that fits their description. I know it's partly because kids can be picky and weirdly specific, and because programs like Accelerated Reader are slowly prying all the magic and discovery out of reading by pigeonholing kids into a very narrow "reading level" range from which they can pick from and earn points on books they're not really into in exchange for paltry rewards like a holographic bookmark or the prestige of being the principal, who instituted the heinous Accelerated Reader program in the first place, for a day. Has any child used their chance at being principal for the day to abolish the Accelerated Reader system? Anyway, I've realized I need to be better informed so that when a kid tells me they can't read a book that really looks amazing because it's .01 points below their assigned reading level, I can tell them exactly what they're missing, thereby sowing the seeds of discontent in a new generation.
The Care and Feeding of a Pet Black Hole is a book I'll proudly dangle in front of the reading level-bound masses. It took me a few chapters to get into it - our main character, Stella, is sarcastic and the whole book is just a tad tongue-in-cheek, which was jarring as I had already wrongly typecast this as being a sad book only (Stella is dealing with the loss of her dad); it takes place in the 1970s and I realized that way too late and after too many Carl Sagan references; and everyone has weird space names (Cosmo, Tony Luna, Stella, etc).
But, once I got in the groove, I grew to love this book. It features a funny, sarcastic girl who loves science and dreams of working at NASA someday. She's strong and brave and isn't embarrassed to love her stinky, weird brother. Her father recently passed away and she's struggling with her emotions, but that's okay! It doesn't make her weak or girly - it makes her human.
What I loved most about this book was the way Stella dealt with her sadness (believe it or not, the pet black hole who follows her home is actually a big gaping symbol for the black hole inside of Stella). She cares for it, she gives it what it needs, because it's a part of her, and she cares about herself. One of my favorite lines comes at the end of the novel:
"They say that a black hole lives at the center of every galaxy. And I believe that now. There would always be a black hole at the center of me, my galaxy, my life. But it's mine. It's part of me. I faced it. I trained it. I tamed it. And finally, I set it free. There's a hole at the center, but that's okay, because it's full of such beautiful, beautiful things."
I've been continually surprised by how many parents come to the library asking for suggestions for their children only to look at me in horror when I mention that a book is sad. "We don't read sad things," they say. Uh, I only read sad things, so... I try to explain to them that sadness is an emotion that must be explored, confronted, maybe even stewed in for a while, and that books are the perfect practice range for this type of thing, and that their children will be better equipped for having already dwelt there, but no. "We're trying to avoid that particular emotion," said one. I get it if you've just gone through a trauma, but to deny sadness forever is to deny a great swath of being human and it just pisses me off so much. And how boring are books that feature like, no stinging conflict, no risk, no growth? Enjoy your novelization of the Minions movie, kid. Stella herself says it best:
"I felt less alone, that was for sure. I realized how much my brother and I needed each other. I realized how much I took Mom for granted, and how much I missed her while we were gone. I guess that's what pain can do if you allow it: crack you open, let light in, and show you what's on the inside. Our adventure through the dark had shown me shades and hues of myself that I couldn't have otherwise seen."
All of that for a whopping 5 Accelerated Reader points!!!!!!
www.bookpuke.com
The Care and Feeding of a Pet Black Hole is a book I'll proudly dangle in front of the reading level-bound masses. It took me a few chapters to get into it - our main character, Stella, is sarcastic and the whole book is just a tad tongue-in-cheek, which was jarring as I had already wrongly typecast this as being a sad book only (Stella is dealing with the loss of her dad); it takes place in the 1970s and I realized that way too late and after too many Carl Sagan references; and everyone has weird space names (Cosmo, Tony Luna, Stella, etc).
But, once I got in the groove, I grew to love this book. It features a funny, sarcastic girl who loves science and dreams of working at NASA someday. She's strong and brave and isn't embarrassed to love her stinky, weird brother. Her father recently passed away and she's struggling with her emotions, but that's okay! It doesn't make her weak or girly - it makes her human.
What I loved most about this book was the way Stella dealt with her sadness (believe it or not, the pet black hole who follows her home is actually a big gaping symbol for the black hole inside of Stella). She cares for it, she gives it what it needs, because it's a part of her, and she cares about herself. One of my favorite lines comes at the end of the novel:
"They say that a black hole lives at the center of every galaxy. And I believe that now. There would always be a black hole at the center of me, my galaxy, my life. But it's mine. It's part of me. I faced it. I trained it. I tamed it. And finally, I set it free. There's a hole at the center, but that's okay, because it's full of such beautiful, beautiful things."
I've been continually surprised by how many parents come to the library asking for suggestions for their children only to look at me in horror when I mention that a book is sad. "We don't read sad things," they say. Uh, I only read sad things, so... I try to explain to them that sadness is an emotion that must be explored, confronted, maybe even stewed in for a while, and that books are the perfect practice range for this type of thing, and that their children will be better equipped for having already dwelt there, but no. "We're trying to avoid that particular emotion," said one. I get it if you've just gone through a trauma, but to deny sadness forever is to deny a great swath of being human and it just pisses me off so much. And how boring are books that feature like, no stinging conflict, no risk, no growth? Enjoy your novelization of the Minions movie, kid. Stella herself says it best:
"I felt less alone, that was for sure. I realized how much my brother and I needed each other. I realized how much I took Mom for granted, and how much I missed her while we were gone. I guess that's what pain can do if you allow it: crack you open, let light in, and show you what's on the inside. Our adventure through the dark had shown me shades and hues of myself that I couldn't have otherwise seen."
All of that for a whopping 5 Accelerated Reader points!!!!!!
www.bookpuke.com
amuncy's review
emotional
funny
hopeful
mysterious
sad
medium-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? Character
- Strong character development? Yes
- Loveable characters? Yes
- Diverse cast of characters? No
- Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes
5.0
jandals's review
adventurous
funny
lighthearted
- Plot- or character-driven? Plot
- Strong character development? No
- Loveable characters? Yes
4.0
cedardleland's review
adventurous
emotional
funny
lighthearted
fast-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? Plot
- Strong character development? Yes
- Loveable characters? Yes
- Diverse cast of characters? No
- Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes
3.0
arantzazureads's review against another edition
5.0
This is one of those few delightful children's books that manages to, through the magic of excellent writing, portray a child character who is astute, yet not pretentious, witty, yet not bratty, introspective, yet not whiny, and gets involved in a storyline that is silly, fun, and ridiculous, AND serious, sad, and thought-provoking all at once. In short, this thin volume has everything either a child or an adult could possibly want in a great book. I'm a fan for life, Michelle Cuevas!
PS- Highly recommend reading this at the same time as [b:Astrophysics for People in a Hurry|32191710|Astrophysics for People in a Hurry|Neil deGrasse Tyson|https://images.gr-assets.com/books/1479535337s/32191710.jpg|52832605]. Cuevas did her research and the parallels are wonderful!
PS- Highly recommend reading this at the same time as [b:Astrophysics for People in a Hurry|32191710|Astrophysics for People in a Hurry|Neil deGrasse Tyson|https://images.gr-assets.com/books/1479535337s/32191710.jpg|52832605]. Cuevas did her research and the parallels are wonderful!
cvt's review
adventurous
reflective
slow-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? A mix
- Strong character development? Yes
- Loveable characters? Yes
- Diverse cast of characters? No
- Flaws of characters a main focus? It's complicated
3.5