thisbookaffair's review against another edition
4.0
Reseña completa en thisbookaffair.tumblr.com
*Hay una parte de mi que ama mucho esta historia y otra que cuestiona algunas aspectos de ella. Trataré de balancear ambos.
Cuando comencé esta lectura me dio la impresión de que no iba a cumplir con mis expectativas, pero ni 50 páginas después ya era fan de Samantha. Nuestra protagonista tiene TOC (trastorno obsesivo-compulsivo), un desorden de ansiedad. En su caso, se manifiesta como insomnio, mucha ansiedad, una obsesión con el número 3, y una mentalidad que siempre la lleva pensar que va a ocurrir lo peor. Digamos que estar en el cerebro de Sam es un puro y verdadero caos. Está bajo medicación y se las arregla para ocultarlo de su grupo de amigas, pero no siempre es tan fácil.
El desarollo del argumento estuvo bien ejecutado. Te mantiene inmersa por completo en lo que está pasando. Cada vez vamos descubriendo distintos aspectos de la mente de Sam, de como lidia con esto, de sus tácticas para no dejar que su cerebro gane cada batalla. Vemos crecimiento, verdadero crecimiento en ella y una parte muy importante de todo es la terapia. La siquiatra de Samantha, Sue, es excelente. La relación que tienen está bien construida y es bueno ver que Sam confía en ella y es una parte activa de su tratamiento.
“Ahora que lo pienso, estoy bien. Los pensamientos han desaparecido, y hasta donde sé, no están aguardando tranquilamente entre bastidores, susurrando y preparándose para atacar de nuevo. Han desaparecido por completo.”
El grupo que conforma el Rincón de los Poetas se robó mi corazón por completo y una parte (gran parte) de mí desearía haber contado con algo así en mis años de estudiante. Es en esa época de tu vida donde más te enfrentas a la crítica y frustración por no poder encajar como todos los demás. Encontré espectacular (y un tanto “mundo ideal”) el contar con un lugar donde puedas expresar tus sentimientos sin miedo a ser criticado por ello. Por otro lado, el grupo de las ocho, las amigas de la infancia de Sam, son de lo peor. Tienen sus momentos, pero en general está todo basado en la apariencia y una amistad que hace rato dejó de existir. No entiendo como Sam pudo aguantar tanto.
*Hay una parte de mi que ama mucho esta historia y otra que cuestiona algunas aspectos de ella. Trataré de balancear ambos.
Cuando comencé esta lectura me dio la impresión de que no iba a cumplir con mis expectativas, pero ni 50 páginas después ya era fan de Samantha. Nuestra protagonista tiene TOC (trastorno obsesivo-compulsivo), un desorden de ansiedad. En su caso, se manifiesta como insomnio, mucha ansiedad, una obsesión con el número 3, y una mentalidad que siempre la lleva pensar que va a ocurrir lo peor. Digamos que estar en el cerebro de Sam es un puro y verdadero caos. Está bajo medicación y se las arregla para ocultarlo de su grupo de amigas, pero no siempre es tan fácil.
El desarollo del argumento estuvo bien ejecutado. Te mantiene inmersa por completo en lo que está pasando. Cada vez vamos descubriendo distintos aspectos de la mente de Sam, de como lidia con esto, de sus tácticas para no dejar que su cerebro gane cada batalla. Vemos crecimiento, verdadero crecimiento en ella y una parte muy importante de todo es la terapia. La siquiatra de Samantha, Sue, es excelente. La relación que tienen está bien construida y es bueno ver que Sam confía en ella y es una parte activa de su tratamiento.
“Ahora que lo pienso, estoy bien. Los pensamientos han desaparecido, y hasta donde sé, no están aguardando tranquilamente entre bastidores, susurrando y preparándose para atacar de nuevo. Han desaparecido por completo.”
El grupo que conforma el Rincón de los Poetas se robó mi corazón por completo y una parte (gran parte) de mí desearía haber contado con algo así en mis años de estudiante. Es en esa época de tu vida donde más te enfrentas a la crítica y frustración por no poder encajar como todos los demás. Encontré espectacular (y un tanto “mundo ideal”) el contar con un lugar donde puedas expresar tus sentimientos sin miedo a ser criticado por ello. Por otro lado, el grupo de las ocho, las amigas de la infancia de Sam, son de lo peor. Tienen sus momentos, pero en general está todo basado en la apariencia y una amistad que hace rato dejó de existir. No entiendo como Sam pudo aguantar tanto.
monicaokta's review
5.0
Beautiful story. Cried during the last few chapters because it was so sad. The character growth in this book is phenomenal.
lilacfairies's review
emotional
inspiring
medium-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? Character
- Strong character development? Yes
- Loveable characters? Yes
- Diverse cast of characters? Yes
- Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes
5.0
mehsi's review
5.0
I have read some amazing books this past year, but none can top this one. This one broke my heart, taped it together again, broke it again, it made me cry, it made me sniffle, it made me want to hug Sam, it made me feel all kinds of stuff, and if I could I would give this book 6 stars, because it is just that amazing, just that gorgeous and it is a book that EVERYONE should read.
I have to be honest, I was quite a bit worried about this book. I have read several books about mental illnesses this year (it seems that there are a lot this year), but none spoke to me like this one did. The others all felt slightly fake, while this one was just so real, so touching, so heartbreaking. So yeah, I started with hesitation, and slowly I opened up to the book, couldn't put it down, it was just pulling me into the world of Sam, Sam and her OCD and how she survives the world with her brain that does scary stuff, that changes her thoughts to whirling storms of doom and pain. A brain that makes her obsessed with the number 3, a brain that makes her anxious, a brain that just doesn't shut down. A brain that just doesn't seem to stop, of course she has medication, of course she has help, but it still is a life that isn't always easy, a life that sucks at times, a life you won't just share with the world.
Sam is a totally amazing character and she truly felt real to me, she wasn't just a character any more when I got to 1/4 of the book. I wanted to cheer for her, to tell her it would all end up to be fine, that she would be ok, that she will make friends, new ones, ones that she can share her craziness (as she so often called it) with. Friends that accepted her and loved her.
Not once was I frustrated with her, not once did I want to shake her around to get some sense in her. I could just understand her so well, I can understand it isn't easy to drop friends you have known for so long, I can imagine that she is afraid to spill her OCD to people (I know from experience how people will react when you tell them you have something, something people might find scary), and many other scenarios made me just nod a long, made me just want to reach out and help her out. Luckily Sam has found some great friends. Caroline, AJ, Sydney, Emily to just name a few of her new friends. She also has a sport that she is dedicated to. I loved her while she was swimming, it was really fun to see her swim to either songs or poetry and how that propelled her forward.
Her relationship with AJ was just perfection, I will discuss that in a bit.
Of course Sam's life isn't the easiest, and while you can see her grow and make a progress, there are things happening that will cause her to fall back again. But Sam is a very strong girl and with the help of Sue (her wonderful, amazing psychiatrist) she forms plans and talks with her about (almost) everything. And it truly helps, I love that the author added these parts to the book, it gave extra dimension to the story. Showing that Sam is able to talk to someone about what goes on in her life. Someone who understands her, and someone who will also do anything (as evidenced from the latter parts) for her. Even outside of the office.
I loved Sam and her poems, they were gorgeous, but also so heartbreaking. Some were a bit happier, but in general they really tugged my heartstrings. It was amazing. I am normally not a big poetry fan, but I loved the poems in this book.
Phew, I am sure that I haven't gotten everything that I love about Sam, but I think this says enough about my love for that character, how she made me feel, and how I wish I could just cheer her up when she is having a bad day.
AJ, ah, sweet and dear AJ. At first I didn't like him, but then we find out what past Sam and he had. That one shocked me quite a bit, I didn't expect Sam to be one of those girls. Sure she was with the popular posse, but I didn't expect her to stoop so low. I won't say what she did, read the book to find out.
I was just delighted when forgiveness happened and when Sam and AJ moved closer and closer. AJ is a great character when you truly get to see him. When you see him making the music, when you see him heartbroken, and I loved him and how he was with Sam. Always trying to help her out, always there for her, always silencing her churning thoughts. Not every guy would understand it, but he can spot that Sam is overthinking things again and he will help her out, kissing her or holding her tight. And when some stuff happened near the end (again no spoilers) he was still there for her, even when she was avoiding him. Of course he was shocked at first (which is logical), but soon after that he would try to be there for Sam, try to talk to her. It was amazing. He saw that, and he didn't run away, like so many others would have done. Seriously, that guy is amazing.
Then we have a whole slew of other characters. We have Sydney, whose food poetry is amazing and also super fun. Emily who is losing her mom due to cancer, and we have several other characters, they kind of fade away to the background, but they are still around and support Sam.
I didn't particularly like the Crazy Eights. Well I did like Hailey, she was the only one who seemed nice, the others seemed a bit too bitchy and too stereotypical popular mean girls. It was a shame, I could see why they were together, once they were great friends, but when we get in the book, I just saw that the relationship they have isn't healthy. You should be free to wear what you want, say what you want, not to have it controlled by others, or being worried you might get kicked out if you do something wrong. You should never feel threatened by your friends. Knowing that if you get out of the group you might be shunned, that they will start rumours. That isn't friendship, that is just toxic. And it is a topic that keeps coming up during the book. We see what it does with Sam, we see what she tries to do about things. I was worried that it might end up badly, so I am delighted with how the author dealt with it near the ending. That was just perfection, good job!
Caroline, my favourite character next to Sam and AJ. I loved her and how she was always there for Sam. I loved how she motivated Sam, how she listened to Sam, how she helped out.
Now this part I will put under spoiler tags, normally I try to keep my reviews spoiler free, but I JUST have to talk about this. So be warned, only read if you read the book. This is a huge twist, so really, don't read it until you read the book!!!!!!!!!
Poor Caroline, we find out that the real Caroline founded the Poet's Corner, that she committed suicide 8 years ago due to depression and bullying. I just was crying for that Caroline, that no one was able to help her out during those terribly difficult times. That she had to die so alone. :(
Back to the happier things. Let's talk about AJ and Sam. I just have to discuss it, and since I am not entirely sure it is spoilers or not, I will just hide them under spoilers to be sure.
AJ and Sam were just adorable together, how they hugged, held hands, how they whispered soft words of love in each others ears. How they seemed to just understand each other, that they could talk about anything.
I loved how they revealed their relationship to the Poet's corner. How they hinted it with a poem, looked at each other and how the others in the room just connected the dots and then the cheering started.
It took Sam a long time to finally confess about her OCD to AJ, but I felt that it was done right. Now it was just the perfect moment, now was just right. I feel if the author had done it at the beginning then it would have ruined the book and make AJ and Sam's relationship seem different. Now it was exciting, and it was also interesting to see how Sam tried to tell him, but couldn't, how she tried to hide it, how she felt so normal with him. Her fears also seemed so real. And so when she finally tells him after all that it is just amazing.
The ending, where AJ brings Sam to the psychiatrist is also beautiful, it shows he is ok with her OCD, that he tries to understand her more, that he is willing to be there for her whenever she needs him. I am sure these 2 will be together for a long long time.
Like I said the poems were amazing, I am really normally not such a poet fanatic, but the poems that get recited in this one? They were beautiful, broke my heart and at times hit close to home for me. And I just have to share one part of a poem with you all.
You're still here
stitched into me, like threads in a
sweater.
Feeding me words
that break down and piece me
back together, all at once
Truly this book is the best one I ever read about mental illnesses (and I read quite a few books about them), maybe one day I will meet another book that is as amazing about this topic as this one, but for now I will have to give this book its #1 crown that it so deserves.
I would highly, really highly recommend this book to everyone. You all need to read this. You will be amazed at the beauty that this book is. Read it!
Review first posted at http://twirlingbookprincess.com/
I have to be honest, I was quite a bit worried about this book. I have read several books about mental illnesses this year (it seems that there are a lot this year), but none spoke to me like this one did. The others all felt slightly fake, while this one was just so real, so touching, so heartbreaking. So yeah, I started with hesitation, and slowly I opened up to the book, couldn't put it down, it was just pulling me into the world of Sam, Sam and her OCD and how she survives the world with her brain that does scary stuff, that changes her thoughts to whirling storms of doom and pain. A brain that makes her obsessed with the number 3, a brain that makes her anxious, a brain that just doesn't shut down. A brain that just doesn't seem to stop, of course she has medication, of course she has help, but it still is a life that isn't always easy, a life that sucks at times, a life you won't just share with the world.
Sam is a totally amazing character and she truly felt real to me, she wasn't just a character any more when I got to 1/4 of the book. I wanted to cheer for her, to tell her it would all end up to be fine, that she would be ok, that she will make friends, new ones, ones that she can share her craziness (as she so often called it) with. Friends that accepted her and loved her.
Not once was I frustrated with her, not once did I want to shake her around to get some sense in her. I could just understand her so well, I can understand it isn't easy to drop friends you have known for so long, I can imagine that she is afraid to spill her OCD to people (I know from experience how people will react when you tell them you have something, something people might find scary), and many other scenarios made me just nod a long, made me just want to reach out and help her out. Luckily Sam has found some great friends. Caroline, AJ, Sydney, Emily to just name a few of her new friends. She also has a sport that she is dedicated to. I loved her while she was swimming, it was really fun to see her swim to either songs or poetry and how that propelled her forward.
Her relationship with AJ was just perfection, I will discuss that in a bit.
Of course Sam's life isn't the easiest, and while you can see her grow and make a progress, there are things happening that will cause her to fall back again. But Sam is a very strong girl and with the help of Sue (her wonderful, amazing psychiatrist) she forms plans and talks with her about (almost) everything. And it truly helps, I love that the author added these parts to the book, it gave extra dimension to the story. Showing that Sam is able to talk to someone about what goes on in her life. Someone who understands her, and someone who will also do anything (as evidenced from the latter parts) for her. Even outside of the office.
I loved Sam and her poems, they were gorgeous, but also so heartbreaking. Some were a bit happier, but in general they really tugged my heartstrings. It was amazing. I am normally not a big poetry fan, but I loved the poems in this book.
Phew, I am sure that I haven't gotten everything that I love about Sam, but I think this says enough about my love for that character, how she made me feel, and how I wish I could just cheer her up when she is having a bad day.
AJ, ah, sweet and dear AJ. At first I didn't like him, but then we find out what past Sam and he had. That one shocked me quite a bit, I didn't expect Sam to be one of those girls. Sure she was with the popular posse, but I didn't expect her to stoop so low. I won't say what she did, read the book to find out.
I was just delighted when forgiveness happened and when Sam and AJ moved closer and closer. AJ is a great character when you truly get to see him. When you see him making the music, when you see him heartbroken, and I loved him and how he was with Sam. Always trying to help her out, always there for her, always silencing her churning thoughts. Not every guy would understand it, but he can spot that Sam is overthinking things again and he will help her out, kissing her or holding her tight. And when some stuff happened near the end (again no spoilers) he was still there for her, even when she was avoiding him. Of course he was shocked at first (which is logical), but soon after that he would try to be there for Sam, try to talk to her. It was amazing. He saw that, and he didn't run away, like so many others would have done. Seriously, that guy is amazing.
Then we have a whole slew of other characters. We have Sydney, whose food poetry is amazing and also super fun. Emily who is losing her mom due to cancer, and we have several other characters, they kind of fade away to the background, but they are still around and support Sam.
I didn't particularly like the Crazy Eights. Well I did like Hailey, she was the only one who seemed nice, the others seemed a bit too bitchy and too stereotypical popular mean girls. It was a shame, I could see why they were together, once they were great friends, but when we get in the book, I just saw that the relationship they have isn't healthy. You should be free to wear what you want, say what you want, not to have it controlled by others, or being worried you might get kicked out if you do something wrong. You should never feel threatened by your friends. Knowing that if you get out of the group you might be shunned, that they will start rumours. That isn't friendship, that is just toxic. And it is a topic that keeps coming up during the book. We see what it does with Sam, we see what she tries to do about things. I was worried that it might end up badly, so I am delighted with how the author dealt with it near the ending. That was just perfection, good job!
Caroline, my favourite character next to Sam and AJ. I loved her and how she was always there for Sam. I loved how she motivated Sam, how she listened to Sam, how she helped out.
Now this part I will put under spoiler tags, normally I try to keep my reviews spoiler free, but I JUST have to talk about this. So be warned, only read if you read the book. This is a huge twist, so really, don't read it until you read the book!!!!!!!!!
Spoiler
I never expected Caroline to be a fictional character, only existing in Sam's brain. It was an amazing twist and I didn't see it coming. I was really shocked and I also cried a bit, as it meant that Sam's brain was doing stuff again that it wasn't supposed to do. I also cried because, it meant that all those interactions, all that friendship, it was just fake in a way. And that broke me. And it also broke Sam. She thought she had a great friend, that she finally had someone to confide in, and then she finds out that her brain fucked with her again. And that hurt her so much. She thought she was doing better, and instead she finds out that she made up someone from something that she read a year ago. That she gave it all kinds of characteristics that she would love to have. I just wanted to hold Sam during these parts. Poor her. Finding out about Caroline through AJ when she said Caroline's full name. The shock and the embarrassment that coursed through her.Poor Caroline, we find out that the real Caroline founded the Poet's Corner, that she committed suicide 8 years ago due to depression and bullying. I just was crying for that Caroline, that no one was able to help her out during those terribly difficult times. That she had to die so alone. :(
Back to the happier things. Let's talk about AJ and Sam. I just have to discuss it, and since I am not entirely sure it is spoilers or not, I will just hide them under spoilers to be sure.
Spoiler
Wow, wow and wow, I just loved the tension, the sparks that flew between them, they make a wonderful couple and I loved when they kissed and hugged, it was just so beautiful and the way it was written was gorgeous. This author truly knows how the write delicious romantic scenes.AJ and Sam were just adorable together, how they hugged, held hands, how they whispered soft words of love in each others ears. How they seemed to just understand each other, that they could talk about anything.
I loved how they revealed their relationship to the Poet's corner. How they hinted it with a poem, looked at each other and how the others in the room just connected the dots and then the cheering started.
It took Sam a long time to finally confess about her OCD to AJ, but I felt that it was done right. Now it was just the perfect moment, now was just right. I feel if the author had done it at the beginning then it would have ruined the book and make AJ and Sam's relationship seem different. Now it was exciting, and it was also interesting to see how Sam tried to tell him, but couldn't, how she tried to hide it, how she felt so normal with him. Her fears also seemed so real. And so when she finally tells him after all that it is just amazing.
The ending, where AJ brings Sam to the psychiatrist is also beautiful, it shows he is ok with her OCD, that he tries to understand her more, that he is willing to be there for her whenever she needs him. I am sure these 2 will be together for a long long time.
Like I said the poems were amazing, I am really normally not such a poet fanatic, but the poems that get recited in this one? They were beautiful, broke my heart and at times hit close to home for me. And I just have to share one part of a poem with you all.
You're still here
stitched into me, like threads in a
sweater.
Feeding me words
that break down and piece me
back together, all at once
Truly this book is the best one I ever read about mental illnesses (and I read quite a few books about them), maybe one day I will meet another book that is as amazing about this topic as this one, but for now I will have to give this book its #1 crown that it so deserves.
I would highly, really highly recommend this book to everyone. You all need to read this. You will be amazed at the beauty that this book is. Read it!
Review first posted at http://twirlingbookprincess.com/
theyloveedina's review
emotional
funny
inspiring
fast-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? Character
- Strong character development? Yes
- Loveable characters? It's complicated
- Diverse cast of characters? Yes
- Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes
3.0
I liked this book. It was one of the first that I had ever read. I also read it in my Englisch competition about a year ago
purple_clouds's review
challenging
emotional
medium-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? Character
- Strong character development? Yes
- Loveable characters? Yes
- Diverse cast of characters? Yes
- Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes
3.75
camreadss's review against another edition
3.0
i think this works as an introduction to understanding ocd. while i think it should be said that for many people the illness can be much more debilitating and dark than what is shown, i wouldn’t say that samantha’s experience with ocd is an inaccurate representation. however i feel that some may walk away from this book with the idea that ocd is basically the same as samatha’s for everyone who has it, when this is not true. intrusive thoughts are often much more disturbing than what samatha deals with (of course it’s bothersome, but cutting someone’s hair is definitely not the worst intrusive thought you can get). my main point is that ocd is a very complex mental illness with many manifestations, so please be aware that this book only shows one type of ocd (and this type of ocd is still very different for many people).
moon_rose's review
emotional
mysterious
reflective
medium-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? Plot
- Strong character development? Yes
- Loveable characters? Yes
- Diverse cast of characters? Yes
- Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes
3.5