ginnikin's review against another edition
4.0
I just re-read this (first read about a year ago) and was surprised and delighted at the whimsy and magic in the story.
Nicole's just a little bit obsessed with fancy, particularly a story she's dreaming and writing. She doesn't have time for or interest in anything else; it's all just noise that distracts her from the real story. Josh is a collector of girls' phone numbers who can't quite get Nicole out of his head even though she never sought his company, and he's moved out of her building. It's an interesting beginning to the story of these two moving closer together.
I hope the second volume will be as lovely and magical.
I do have to point out that Josh is a bit of a jerk about women. He's never shown actually seeking their phone numbers, and they're quite unrealistically shown throwing themselves at him. Still, he keeps a jar of their numbers. His roommate (not going to look up his name) is a world-class slimeball about romance. I hope he gets a metaphorical (or literal, that'd be fine, too) kick in the balls in the second volume.
Nicole's just a little bit obsessed with fancy, particularly a story she's dreaming and writing. She doesn't have time for or interest in anything else; it's all just noise that distracts her from the real story. Josh is a collector of girls' phone numbers who can't quite get Nicole out of his head even though she never sought his company, and he's moved out of her building. It's an interesting beginning to the story of these two moving closer together.
I hope the second volume will be as lovely and magical.
I do have to point out that Josh is a bit of a jerk about women. He's never shown actually seeking their phone numbers, and they're quite unrealistically shown throwing themselves at him. Still, he keeps a jar of their numbers. His roommate (not going to look up his name) is a world-class slimeball about romance. I hope he gets a metaphorical (or literal, that'd be fine, too) kick in the balls in the second volume.
jkenna90's review against another edition
5.0
This was so cute! Really excited to read the second volume
lemonjade's review
funny
lighthearted
medium-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? Character
- Strong character development? No
- Loveable characters? It's complicated
- Diverse cast of characters? No
- Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes
3.0
theybedax's review against another edition
4.0
I honestly loved everything about this. The switch between the real world and showcasing Nicole's loneliness to a fantastical world full of adventure. I appreciate the fact that the potential romance is one in the real world and not her fantastical one, if she will just give it a chance. Prepare for adorable art and a story that touches your heart!
readingrainbill's review against another edition
medium-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? Character
- Strong character development? No
- Loveable characters? No
- Diverse cast of characters? No
- Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes
2.0
First off I almost DNFd it as soon as Nicole stepped out the door with a piece of toast in her mouth like a cringy anime cliche.
Very mediocre. The art style is like if Cathy Guisewite (who writes the Cathy comic strip) tried to draw a more serious comic.
The story was bland. Josh felt like a horrid creep until his back story was explained and then he was just a moron. Nicole is just boring.
While the story does have promise it just doesn't seem like it's going to go anywhere good in the 2nd and final volume. I just don't care.
Very mediocre. The art style is like if Cathy Guisewite (who writes the Cathy comic strip) tried to draw a more serious comic.
The story was bland. Josh felt like a horrid creep until his back story was explained and then he was just a moron. Nicole is just boring.
While the story does have promise it just doesn't seem like it's going to go anywhere good in the 2nd and final volume. I just don't care.
couchnest's review against another edition
4.0
I enjoyed the illustrations in this graphic novel, and thought the story was kind of cute, although it felt like it moved too slow and before I knew it, the book was over. In this story, Josh has a crush on Nicole, and she fights her crush on him. He comes off as a player, which turns her off and makes her hesitant to get involved with him. However, he genuinely likes her and it's not just about adding her number to the rest of his stash. The whole book seems to revolve around him chasing her and trying to get her to spend time with him and let him be her boyfriend. Interspersed in the story is a fantasy story that she is writing in her dreamlog. She kind of hides her story from other people, and hides the fact that she still enjoys reading fairy tales and using fantasy and fairy tales as an escape.
There's only one other book in this "series" and from what I have read about it, it seems to flip flop the story some on the romantic angle, and focus more on Nicole's writing.
There's only one other book in this "series" and from what I have read about it, it seems to flip flop the story some on the romantic angle, and focus more on Nicole's writing.
notwaverly's review against another edition
4.0
Running far behind on my Goodreads challenge and picked this up on Scribd to play some catch up without knowing what it was about. I'm surprisingly pleased! It was fluffy and not especially complicated, but cute. I liked that she's a writer, and I'm interested to see the progression of the story in the second volume. :)
familiar_diversions's review
2.0
Nicole has extremely vivid dreams and daydreams about a lonely sorcerer named Ellon who was betrayed by his familiar and only friend, Sonneth. She writes these vivid dreams into her dreamlog, paying only the most minimal attention necessary to things like her business classes and her friend Susan. At night she works as a secretary.
Josh is a bookstore employee who's gotten all his tips about interacting with women from Riley, a pickup artist who happens to be his roommate. Female customers practically fall over themselves to give Josh their number, which he always deposits in a jar. The person he's really interested in is Nicole, who he was never able to charm. When Nicole enters his store, Josh figures he'll give it another shot, but he doesn't realize that he's competing against Nicole's daydreams about Ellon.
I wanted to like this more than I actually did. A big part of the problem was that I was not on board with what appeared to be the central romance, between Nicole and Josh. I think readers were supposed to view Josh as a nice guy who just had unfortunate taste in friends. He didn't see anything wrong with collecting girls' phone numbers like trophies - weirdly, the only person who had any problems with it was Nicole. I'd have thought he'd have at least one regular customer who got fed up with or annoyed at his constant flirting. It certainly irked me.
I could sympathize with Nicole's annoyance at Josh's behavior, especially considering the flashbacks to the time when he lived a floor below her and would literally bang the ceiling with a broom and cheerfully call her up to let her know that he was causing that noise (was that supposed to be cute??). And the fact that he wouldn't leave her alone, even though he noticed she was trying to avoid him. And when she asked him to quit all the constant flirting, his response was: "I wouldn't be flirting with you if you didn't make me feel like it was working! So, whose fault is this?" Ugh. Josh, you're responsible for your own behavior, and Nicole asked you to stop, so just stop. Unfortunately, considering all the blushing, I'm pretty sure readers were supposed to view that moment as romantic or something.
I've written a lot about Josh, but I wasn't really wild about Nicole either. I could understand her tendency to escape into daydreams, since she didn't seem too excited about the direction her life was taking and appeared to mostly be doing whatever would make her mother happy. However, her daydreaming was so constant that she barely paid any attention to the people in her life. Granted, she didn't seem to care much about any of those people - she had nothing in common with Susan, her supposed friend, and her feelings for Josh were a muddled mess.
This is a short series - just one more volume to go. Let's see if it improves.
(Original review posted on A Library Girl's Familiar Diversions.)
Josh is a bookstore employee who's gotten all his tips about interacting with women from Riley, a pickup artist who happens to be his roommate. Female customers practically fall over themselves to give Josh their number, which he always deposits in a jar. The person he's really interested in is Nicole, who he was never able to charm. When Nicole enters his store, Josh figures he'll give it another shot, but he doesn't realize that he's competing against Nicole's daydreams about Ellon.
I wanted to like this more than I actually did. A big part of the problem was that I was not on board with what appeared to be the central romance, between Nicole and Josh. I think readers were supposed to view Josh as a nice guy who just had unfortunate taste in friends. He didn't see anything wrong with collecting girls' phone numbers like trophies - weirdly, the only person who had any problems with it was Nicole. I'd have thought he'd have at least one regular customer who got fed up with or annoyed at his constant flirting. It certainly irked me.
I could sympathize with Nicole's annoyance at Josh's behavior, especially considering the flashbacks to the time when he lived a floor below her and would literally bang the ceiling with a broom and cheerfully call her up to let her know that he was causing that noise (was that supposed to be cute??). And the fact that he wouldn't leave her alone, even though he noticed she was trying to avoid him. And when she asked him to quit all the constant flirting, his response was: "I wouldn't be flirting with you if you didn't make me feel like it was working! So, whose fault is this?" Ugh. Josh, you're responsible for your own behavior, and Nicole asked you to stop, so just stop. Unfortunately, considering all the blushing, I'm pretty sure readers were supposed to view that moment as romantic or something.
I've written a lot about Josh, but I wasn't really wild about Nicole either. I could understand her tendency to escape into daydreams, since she didn't seem too excited about the direction her life was taking and appeared to mostly be doing whatever would make her mother happy. However, her daydreaming was so constant that she barely paid any attention to the people in her life. Granted, she didn't seem to care much about any of those people - she had nothing in common with Susan, her supposed friend, and her feelings for Josh were a muddled mess.
This is a short series - just one more volume to go. Let's see if it improves.
(Original review posted on A Library Girl's Familiar Diversions.)
hailareads's review
5.0
The most light, beautiful series I've read. Can't wait to read the next volume!