djlanatron's review against another edition
5.0
I LOVED this interpretation. I want to know more about the Holmes brothers - which as this series is ongoing, will probably happen. This definitely started more as Watson's story, which I am fine with. There are a few typos, especially early on, but once everything got moving, I didn't really care.
hauntedboi's review against another edition
4.0
A cool modern reinvention of a classic. It’s great to see these characters represented in a different cultural atmosphere, and while the beats of this book will be familiar to Holmes fans, the dialogue and art breath fresh air into the story.
mmelibertine's review against another edition
3.0
This is a solid introduction to a really fresh Sherlock. The plot was interesting but imo took a backseat to the character development. The diverse cast, Black leads, and lady Lieutenant are welcome changes from the typical comic fare. Watson is a more fully fleshed out character here than in many adaptations, and that's really exciting to me.
I hope to see more of Holmes's Irregulars in the next volume!
I hope to see more of Holmes's Irregulars in the next volume!
More...