arielx's review against another edition
3.0
Noteworthy/memorable:
Under the Pitons by Robert Stone is possibly the best short story I've ever read. Stone has said that he learned not to throw the conflict in the plot in too early or too late, but in this work he weaves it in masterfully until, like the characters, paranoia sets in and you don't know where the true threat is until it's too late. The emotion is palpable, as is the pessimistic and wry despair of the main character, whose ultimate resignation to his fate smacks of the black humor which comes of events too stark and terrible to be fathomed rationally. Whew.
Killing Babies is also a worthwhile look into a flawed character interacting with a flawed world.
Honorable mentions:
Eternal Love, 'Fiesta, 1980', Missing Women
Take-home message:
Apart from a couple gems, this year was just average.
Under the Pitons by Robert Stone is possibly the best short story I've ever read. Stone has said that he learned not to throw the conflict in the plot in too early or too late, but in this work he weaves it in masterfully until, like the characters, paranoia sets in and you don't know where the true threat is until it's too late. The emotion is palpable, as is the pessimistic and wry despair of the main character, whose ultimate resignation to his fate smacks of the black humor which comes of events too stark and terrible to be fathomed rationally. Whew.
Killing Babies is also a worthwhile look into a flawed character interacting with a flawed world.
Honorable mentions:
Eternal Love, 'Fiesta, 1980', Missing Women
Take-home message:
Apart from a couple gems, this year was just average.
antrapp1026's review
3.0
It ended on a very high note with Tim Gautreux’s funny and sad and keenly observed “Little Frogs in a Ditch,” but too many of these stories sunk under the weight of their authors’ pretensions for me to get really excited about them.
I read 2/3 of these stories way back when, in 2002, and the rest over the last couple of months. It seems like this edition’s editor, E. Annie Proulx, and I have slightly different taste.
I read 2/3 of these stories way back when, in 2002, and the rest over the last couple of months. It seems like this edition’s editor, E. Annie Proulx, and I have slightly different taste.
More...