derlele's review against another edition
adventurous
emotional
tense
medium-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? Character
- Strong character development? It's complicated
- Loveable characters? Yes
- Diverse cast of characters? No
- Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes
3.75
abrswf's review against another edition
5.0
Fast informative read about Trafalgar, with a compelling romance for Sharpe included. Onward to Sharpe's Prey!
binstonbirchill's review against another edition
3.0
More about Sharpe than Trafalgar and I was looking for more about Trafalgar than Sharp considering it's my first Sharpe book, which made it a bit of a slog. Not sure if I will read more Sharp books or not, but since I own two of them, probably, eventually.
klio's review against another edition
tense
medium-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? Plot
- Strong character development? No
- Loveable characters? It's complicated
- Diverse cast of characters? No
- Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes
3.0
ariaslibrary's review against another edition
3.0
Military fiction on the sea? Recipe for a favourite. If it weren't for the romance.
The romances in this series are usually bad, but this had the misfortune of being both bad and irritating. I want blood and violence, not insta-love, insta-lust, damsel in distress to be saved by Sharpe. And with the track record from the previous books, she's probably going to leave him at the beginning of the next one
The romances in this series are usually bad, but this had the misfortune of being both bad and irritating. I want blood and violence, not insta-love, insta-lust, damsel in distress to be saved by Sharpe. And with the track record from the previous books, she's probably going to leave him at the beginning of the next one
caroparr's review against another edition
4.0
Such a good read! Since Sharpe is a soldier and knows nothing about ships, the reader learns (just exactly enough) along with him. Cornwell paces the battle perfectly - the ships move slowly, but when the weapons fire, it's fast and bloody. The romance is nicely done, too.
usbsticky's review against another edition
4.0
I'm reading Sharpe in chronological order. Cornwell did say somewhere that he'd gotten the idea of Sharpe from Hornblower and he wanted to do a land version of it. And this is the book where he gets to indulge in the sea version.
Spoilers ahead:
The first few chronological Sharpe books were written when Sharpe was already famous to add on the beginning of his career. In this 4th book, Sharpe goes back to England and experiences Britain's most famous naval victory.
Sharp starts as a ranker, gets promoted to Sergeant then to ensign after he saves Wellington's life. He's put in a Scottish regiment but doesn't fit in (that parts a little forced) and is reassigned to the 85th Rifles. He goes back to England on an East India Company ship but that ship is purposely surrendered to the French by the cowardly captain.
Meanwhile his jewels (that he took off the Tiger of Mysore) are stolen and he has an affair with an aristocratic married lady. However the ship is recaptured by a British 74. Sharpe had previously met the captain of that ship (Pucelle) in India and helped him out of a bad situation. So the Captain takes him as well as the lady and her husband on board and go back to England. They are also chasing the French ship (Revenant).
On the way back to England they meet Nelson's fleet and is ordered to join the upcoming battle. I have to say that Cornwell did a very good job of portraying the battle, better than most of the Hornblower clones. After the battle is done, Sharpe is taken back to England to begin the next chapter in his life.
I like the book because the writing is very easy to read and get into. Cornwell does a great job of writing the character vignettes making them fun to read. Forester is a master of that and that is one of the things that makes Hornblower such a pleasure to read. Forester still does it better though and Cornwell's characters are a little bit cliched.
There is a lot of vigilante justice and a lot of action. The action is fast and furious, there are very few slow parts and there is a lot of satisfaction is seeing justice done. The only thing I'm not really a fan of is the element of conflict that Sharpe has to suffer through in each book. Sometimes it's a recurring character that Sharpe fails to dispatch or something bad always happens to him. As most readers live Sharpe vicariously through the book, it brings moments of discomfort when that happens to him and them.
The books really are quick reads and I'm finishing one book every 2 days or so. I'm now on the next one.
Spoilers ahead:
The first few chronological Sharpe books were written when Sharpe was already famous to add on the beginning of his career. In this 4th book, Sharpe goes back to England and experiences Britain's most famous naval victory.
Sharp starts as a ranker, gets promoted to Sergeant then to ensign after he saves Wellington's life. He's put in a Scottish regiment but doesn't fit in (that parts a little forced) and is reassigned to the 85th Rifles. He goes back to England on an East India Company ship but that ship is purposely surrendered to the French by the cowardly captain.
Meanwhile his jewels (that he took off the Tiger of Mysore) are stolen and he has an affair with an aristocratic married lady. However the ship is recaptured by a British 74. Sharpe had previously met the captain of that ship (Pucelle) in India and helped him out of a bad situation. So the Captain takes him as well as the lady and her husband on board and go back to England. They are also chasing the French ship (Revenant).
On the way back to England they meet Nelson's fleet and is ordered to join the upcoming battle. I have to say that Cornwell did a very good job of portraying the battle, better than most of the Hornblower clones. After the battle is done, Sharpe is taken back to England to begin the next chapter in his life.
I like the book because the writing is very easy to read and get into. Cornwell does a great job of writing the character vignettes making them fun to read. Forester is a master of that and that is one of the things that makes Hornblower such a pleasure to read. Forester still does it better though and Cornwell's characters are a little bit cliched.
There is a lot of vigilante justice and a lot of action. The action is fast and furious, there are very few slow parts and there is a lot of satisfaction is seeing justice done. The only thing I'm not really a fan of is the element of conflict that Sharpe has to suffer through in each book. Sometimes it's a recurring character that Sharpe fails to dispatch or something bad always happens to him. As most readers live Sharpe vicariously through the book, it brings moments of discomfort when that happens to him and them.
The books really are quick reads and I'm finishing one book every 2 days or so. I'm now on the next one.
siria's review against another edition
2.0
This was the first of the Sharpe books that I've read. I picked it up largely because of the nautical theme, being fond of what I've seen of the Sharpe TV movies, though not overly enamoured.
I enjoyed it, for the most part. It's like an extended Boy's Own adventure, set on a ship full of men being manly bastards and the French being perfidious. The plotline wasn't much to write home about, frankly; apart from the opening sequence, and the climactic battle of Trafalgar, I thought the whole thing dragged rather a little, and too much attention was paid to the romance. The attraction between Sharpe and Lady Grace felt much too cliched, too painted by numbers, for me to ever be interested in it. Aristocratic lady falling for a hot bit of rough has been done so many times that there needed to be something more to the thing to make me warm to the pairing; as it was, I couldn't even believe it to be plausible.
Everything picked up in the last third of the book, once the great battle actually began, but everything before that really felt like an extended contrivance to get Sharpe to be there.
Most of the period details felt right, which is always a huge, huge plus for me; the stink and piss and sweat of six hundred odd men crammed onto a third-rate was well conveyed, and any lack of greater detail about the actual mechanics of sailing the thing can be more than adequately explained by the fact that Sharpe is a soldier, not a sailor. It never felt as true to me as in the Aubrey-Maturin books, though, or even the Hornblower ones.
Sharpe mostly came across as a stock hero type, someone who has pulled himself up from the gutter by his bootstraps and is going to show those aristocrats just how much hell a lad from Yorkshire can give them. Or summat. The only times he really came alive for me was when he murdered Braithwaite in cold blood - not something a hero usually does, and different enough to really catch my attention - and in the final portion of the book where he finally goes into battle as part of the Pucelle's boarding party.
He was ashamed when he remembered the joy of it, but there was a joy there. It was the happiness of being released to the slaughter, of having every bond of civilization removed. It was also what Richard Sharpe was good at. It was why he wore an officer's sash instead of a private's belt, because in almost every battle the moment came when the disciplined ranks dissolved and a man simply had to claw and scratch and kill like a beast.
That was the part where his character first grabbed my attention, first spoke to me and really made me believe that this was part of the life story of someone who had lived through the Napoleonic Wars. Unfortunately, there were only about thirty pages or so left in the book by this stage.
If you do pick it up, skip straight to the last eighty pages or so; I'd recommend Patrick O' Brian over Cornwell any day, though
I enjoyed it, for the most part. It's like an extended Boy's Own adventure, set on a ship full of men being manly bastards and the French being perfidious. The plotline wasn't much to write home about, frankly; apart from the opening sequence, and the climactic battle of Trafalgar, I thought the whole thing dragged rather a little, and too much attention was paid to the romance. The attraction between Sharpe and Lady Grace felt much too cliched, too painted by numbers, for me to ever be interested in it. Aristocratic lady falling for a hot bit of rough has been done so many times that there needed to be something more to the thing to make me warm to the pairing; as it was, I couldn't even believe it to be plausible.
Everything picked up in the last third of the book, once the great battle actually began, but everything before that really felt like an extended contrivance to get Sharpe to be there.
Most of the period details felt right, which is always a huge, huge plus for me; the stink and piss and sweat of six hundred odd men crammed onto a third-rate was well conveyed, and any lack of greater detail about the actual mechanics of sailing the thing can be more than adequately explained by the fact that Sharpe is a soldier, not a sailor. It never felt as true to me as in the Aubrey-Maturin books, though, or even the Hornblower ones.
Sharpe mostly came across as a stock hero type, someone who has pulled himself up from the gutter by his bootstraps and is going to show those aristocrats just how much hell a lad from Yorkshire can give them. Or summat. The only times he really came alive for me was when he murdered Braithwaite in cold blood - not something a hero usually does, and different enough to really catch my attention - and in the final portion of the book where he finally goes into battle as part of the Pucelle's boarding party.
He was ashamed when he remembered the joy of it, but there was a joy there. It was the happiness of being released to the slaughter, of having every bond of civilization removed. It was also what Richard Sharpe was good at. It was why he wore an officer's sash instead of a private's belt, because in almost every battle the moment came when the disciplined ranks dissolved and a man simply had to claw and scratch and kill like a beast.
That was the part where his character first grabbed my attention, first spoke to me and really made me believe that this was part of the life story of someone who had lived through the Napoleonic Wars. Unfortunately, there were only about thirty pages or so left in the book by this stage.
If you do pick it up, skip straight to the last eighty pages or so; I'd recommend Patrick O' Brian over Cornwell any day, though
isoney's review against another edition
adventurous
fast-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? A mix
- Strong character development? No
- Loveable characters? Yes
- Diverse cast of characters? No
- Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes
3.75