manuelte's review against another edition
3.0
It's always entertaining when the Justice League's big guns are shelved and we get to see the rest of the DC Universe step into the spotlight, however I'm not a big fan of the Metal men and this book is mostly a way to present the new 52 metal men to the reader. On the other hand the focus on Cyborg was nice and I do like his redesign, much closer to the old Teen Titans design.
johnawickline's review against another edition
adventurous
dark
fast-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? Character
- Strong character development? No
- Loveable characters? No
- Diverse cast of characters? Yes
- Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes
4.0
cultneophyte's review against another edition
I know I said I wasn't going to read another volume, but well, fuck it. The crime syndicate looked just too good to ignore. Best volume till now, imo. (I didn't read Forever Evil and Trinity War)
zfrey117's review against another edition
4.0
7.5/10
Justice League continues to be one of the strongest series in the New 52 lineup. As a direct tie-in to Forever Evil, it is best paired with that trade collection. We get a redesign of Cyborg, and his defeat of Grid. We get the New 52 iteration of the Metal Men, which instantly had me wishing for their own standalone series, and we see the fallout of Forever Evil, with the public opinion of the League in shambles, while villains like Lex Luthor are hailed as heroes. Lex now knows Bruce's identity, has supplied the league with a new watchtower, and inserted Shazam into the league.
Justice League continues to be one of the strongest series in the New 52 lineup. As a direct tie-in to Forever Evil, it is best paired with that trade collection. We get a redesign of Cyborg, and his defeat of Grid. We get the New 52 iteration of the Metal Men, which instantly had me wishing for their own standalone series, and we see the fallout of Forever Evil, with the public opinion of the League in shambles, while villains like Lex Luthor are hailed as heroes. Lex now knows Bruce's identity, has supplied the league with a new watchtower, and inserted Shazam into the league.
apageinthestacks's review against another edition
3.0
3.5/5.
The last two chapters cemented it at a 3.5 rather than 3 or lower. The first four chapters weren't all that interesting to me, but I really enjoyed Cyborg and the metal men in the last two. Even so, I really wish this was a side series or something, rather than the Justice League title, since none of the League besides Cyborg really make an appearance; it'd be great to see the metal men and Cyborg have their own series or miniseries, but for the Justice League title, I kinda just wanted the League.
The last two chapters cemented it at a 3.5 rather than 3 or lower. The first four chapters weren't all that interesting to me, but I really enjoyed Cyborg and the metal men in the last two. Even so, I really wish this was a side series or something, rather than the Justice League title, since none of the League besides Cyborg really make an appearance; it'd be great to see the metal men and Cyborg have their own series or miniseries, but for the Justice League title, I kinda just wanted the League.
19lindsey89's review against another edition
3.0
This volume didn't add much to what was already happening in Forever Evil. There was some good-ish background information of the Crime Syndicate, but some of it left me with more questions than it actually answered. Mostly, how did Lois Lane become Superwoman? If Superwoman is supposed to be the evil Wonder Woman, how did Wonder Woman turn from Dianna to Lois Lane? Maybe I'm just overthinking it.
I'm also not invested enough to care about the Metal Men, so that part dragged for me and didn't contribute to the main action.
Overall, it feels like the Justice League series has been taken over by the cross over issues like Trinity War and Forever Evil. These didn't serve a purpose.
I'm also not invested enough to care about the Metal Men, so that part dragged for me and didn't contribute to the main action.
Overall, it feels like the Justice League series has been taken over by the cross over issues like Trinity War and Forever Evil. These didn't serve a purpose.
subhamroxx's review against another edition
4.0
This was so epic.
It ties in with the Forever Evil event as we find the origins of Ultraman, Owl Man, Johnny Quick, Power ring and others over here and hints as to Luthor and Anti-monitor and its perfectly done and it flows so naturally and its awesome. Plus we come to find out whatever their plans are and watch them battle heroes particularly Johnny and then we have the story with Cyborg and him coming back and the origins and coming back of Metal-Men which I absolutely love and how they team up and take the battle to Grid!
Its an awesome volume and allows Johns to flesh out the threats and also give the metal men some spotlight and I love the way he does that, its so natural and it feels epic and their battle with Grid makes him a sympathetic villain and also allows for the evolution of the character of Cyborg which is genius plus the art of Reis here is so good, part of the reason why the book looks so good is a testament to him and his great ability. Its a must must read book for sure.
It ties in with the Forever Evil event as we find the origins of Ultraman, Owl Man, Johnny Quick, Power ring and others over here and hints as to Luthor and Anti-monitor and its perfectly done and it flows so naturally and its awesome. Plus we come to find out whatever their plans are and watch them battle heroes particularly Johnny and then we have the story with Cyborg and him coming back and the origins and coming back of Metal-Men which I absolutely love and how they team up and take the battle to Grid!
Its an awesome volume and allows Johns to flesh out the threats and also give the metal men some spotlight and I love the way he does that, its so natural and it feels epic and their battle with Grid makes him a sympathetic villain and also allows for the evolution of the character of Cyborg which is genius plus the art of Reis here is so good, part of the reason why the book looks so good is a testament to him and his great ability. Its a must must read book for sure.
lukeisthename34's review against another edition
3.0
Starts out really interestingly, then falls apart. I am assuming I need to read the whole crossover to get all of this nonsense? Boo.
majorrawne's review
adventurous
dark
inspiring
medium-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? A mix
- Strong character development? It's complicated
- Loveable characters? Yes
- Diverse cast of characters? Yes
- Flaws of characters a main focus? It's complicated
4.0
calistareads's review against another edition
2.0
What in the world was this. All the sudden there were bad mirrors of our superheroes that were villains and evil. I really like Geoff Johns and he does great stuff, but this was a mess. It came out of nowhere and didn't relate to the 4th volume in any way. This might as well been a whole different story from the rest. I don't understand. Plus, our favorite heroes on in this one and it's really not a whole lot of fun without them.
The art is good with lots of energy in the pages. We don't figure out what's going on even a little until the very end and then cliff hanger.
I'm not a fan of this.
The art is good with lots of energy in the pages. We don't figure out what's going on even a little until the very end and then cliff hanger.
I'm not a fan of this.