Scan barcode
davorfyi's review against another edition
4.0
The story opening seemed a little bit confusing, but it started to make sense not too many pages later. Once the story had developed, it was excellent. The only bit I found lacking was that chapter intros, typically consisting of long(er) descriptions, as well as some dialogues, suffered from dryness. Sometimes it felt too flat and technical, but far from bringing the whole experience down. This is a must read, especially if you liked "Old Man's War, #1".
amandarose816's review against another edition
5.0
4.75 - I got a little lost along the way and ended up supplementing with the audiobook. That said, still very much enjoyed this read!
peripatetic13's review against another edition
adventurous
reflective
fast-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? A mix
- Strong character development? Yes
- Loveable characters? Yes
- Diverse cast of characters? It's complicated
- Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes
4.0
elheffe35's review against another edition
adventurous
dark
emotional
medium-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? Plot
- Strong character development? Yes
- Loveable characters? Yes
- Diverse cast of characters? Yes
- Flaws of characters a main focus? No
4.25
olivetree96's review against another edition
adventurous
emotional
hopeful
medium-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? A mix
- Strong character development? Yes
- Loveable characters? Yes
- Diverse cast of characters? Yes
- Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes
4.0
aisaacson7's review against another edition
5.0
This universe is very neat. Connected storyline to first book, but different focal point. Can’t wait for third
snailsarereading's review against another edition
3.0
Much harder to get into this book than the others in the series.
obsidian_blue's review against another edition
4.0
The Ghost Brigades" took a while to get going for me. I was honestly worried about getting into a DNF situation because the first part is typical Scalzi-disease. He starts trying to over explain the world and the science behind everything at the same time. Usually I am just confused and then go, wait, I don't think that works. This time I was just 100 percent bored. After a while, I started to skim because reading about DNA is not fascinating. At least to me. But once we got past that, the book really started to hum and I found myself reading as fast as I could because I got worried about the characters we started to follow, and what would become of them.
As readers found out in book #1, "Old Man's War" the Colonial Defence Forces (CDF) have been taking volunteers in order to fight battles across the galaxy. If you can survive two years, you can then be given a homestead on a colony. We followed main character, John Perry, as he volunteers to be part of the army and at the age of 75 has his consciousness transferred to a stronger and faster body (that is green) and through his journeys finds out that the CDF took the DNA of his dead wife and she is now Jane Sagan.
Book #2 doesn't have John Perry (he is mentioned) but instead we focus on a scientist who turned against the CDF, Charles Boutin. The CDF in a computer finds a copy of Boutin's consciousness and then decides to download it into a new brain in order to find out more information about Boutin's plans.
The person that I would consider the main character is Jared Dirac (who has Boutin's consciousness alongside his own) that has no idea that he has another person's consciousness sitting alongside his own. As CDF waits to see if their experiment works, they send Dirac off to the Ghost Brigades and he finds himself under a platoon under the leadership of Jane Sagan.
You really do need to read book #1 in order to understand some lines here and there. Some other characters note a change in Jane that happened years ago after she almost died and readers of course realize that is because of what she found out about her former life she doesn't remember due to John Perry. Also, we get to see how others view the Ghost Brigades (not real since they don't have a soul). Unlike with John, Jared is more serious, thoughtful and you start to think more and more about the concepts of a person's soul. Or at least I did.
There are a lot of characters in this one, but I thought it was easy to keep everyone straight. The dialogue at times was funny and I did think the writing was good. The flow was good once we got past the whole this is what DNA does pieces in this book too.
I thought ultimately this book really was about the choices that people make. We start to realize that everyone's choices pushed them to where we get to in this book. That some of these choices may have been morally wrong at times and you can see some of the characters struggling with the weight of those decisions. In the end I loved that we get to see Jared and Jane both evolve a lot further and instead of just taking orders, making sure that they were making choices that they can live with.
I don't know if I will read the third book in this series or not. I don't think that the CDF is full of bad guys, but they are doing some questionable things. I think that some of those things are going to bite them in the butt eventually. I do like the ethical questions that Scalzi brings up as you read this book. You get into the concept of torture, murder, what makes a person real to you and to me, etc.
As readers found out in book #1, "Old Man's War" the Colonial Defence Forces (CDF) have been taking volunteers in order to fight battles across the galaxy. If you can survive two years, you can then be given a homestead on a colony. We followed main character, John Perry, as he volunteers to be part of the army and at the age of 75 has his consciousness transferred to a stronger and faster body (that is green) and through his journeys finds out that the CDF took the DNA of his dead wife and she is now Jane Sagan.
Book #2 doesn't have John Perry (he is mentioned) but instead we focus on a scientist who turned against the CDF, Charles Boutin. The CDF in a computer finds a copy of Boutin's consciousness and then decides to download it into a new brain in order to find out more information about Boutin's plans.
The person that I would consider the main character is Jared Dirac (who has Boutin's consciousness alongside his own) that has no idea that he has another person's consciousness sitting alongside his own. As CDF waits to see if their experiment works, they send Dirac off to the Ghost Brigades and he finds himself under a platoon under the leadership of Jane Sagan.
You really do need to read book #1 in order to understand some lines here and there. Some other characters note a change in Jane that happened years ago after she almost died and readers of course realize that is because of what she found out about her former life she doesn't remember due to John Perry. Also, we get to see how others view the Ghost Brigades (not real since they don't have a soul). Unlike with John, Jared is more serious, thoughtful and you start to think more and more about the concepts of a person's soul. Or at least I did.
There are a lot of characters in this one, but I thought it was easy to keep everyone straight. The dialogue at times was funny and I did think the writing was good. The flow was good once we got past the whole this is what DNA does pieces in this book too.
I thought ultimately this book really was about the choices that people make. We start to realize that everyone's choices pushed them to where we get to in this book. That some of these choices may have been morally wrong at times and you can see some of the characters struggling with the weight of those decisions. In the end I loved that we get to see Jared and Jane both evolve a lot further and instead of just taking orders, making sure that they were making choices that they can live with.
I don't know if I will read the third book in this series or not. I don't think that the CDF is full of bad guys, but they are doing some questionable things. I think that some of those things are going to bite them in the butt eventually. I do like the ethical questions that Scalzi brings up as you read this book. You get into the concept of torture, murder, what makes a person real to you and to me, etc.
mick_c's review against another edition
5.0
This is a great read. It also has a lot for those interested in military tech and ethics. This series is going straight to the pool room. Worth your time.
lafatm3's review against another edition
4.0
John Scalzi is my favorite sci-fi writer.
His books are quirky, fast-paced, and humorous and The Ghost Brigades is no exception. The book is the second book in the Old Man's War series, the series that put Scalzi on the sci-fi map. It's a worthy sequel that follows one of the minor characters in the first book but also adds depth to the expanded universe in which the action unfolds. The premise for this book is that the Colonial Defense Force (CDF) has a rogue scientist who is apparently aiding alien enemies. In order to try and find this scientist, the CDF finds a clone that this scientist created and are able to insert his consciousness into a genetically-engineered soldier in hopes that as his conscious emerges, it will reveal clues as to why the scientist went rogue in the first place. The book then proceeds to follow the soldier as this conscious slowly reveals itself and helps lead to the scientist in question.
Overall, The Ghost Brigades is a worthy sequel and well worth the time of any sci-fi fan.
His books are quirky, fast-paced, and humorous and The Ghost Brigades is no exception. The book is the second book in the Old Man's War series, the series that put Scalzi on the sci-fi map. It's a worthy sequel that follows one of the minor characters in the first book but also adds depth to the expanded universe in which the action unfolds. The premise for this book is that the Colonial Defense Force (CDF) has a rogue scientist who is apparently aiding alien enemies. In order to try and find this scientist, the CDF finds a clone that this scientist created and are able to insert his consciousness into a genetically-engineered soldier in hopes that as his conscious emerges, it will reveal clues as to why the scientist went rogue in the first place. The book then proceeds to follow the soldier as this conscious slowly reveals itself and helps lead to the scientist in question.
Overall, The Ghost Brigades is a worthy sequel and well worth the time of any sci-fi fan.