itaby's review against another edition
challenging
dark
emotional
medium-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? A mix
- Strong character development? Yes
- Loveable characters? Yes
- Diverse cast of characters? Yes
- Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes
4.5
bibliotequeish's review
I started reading the comics after I had watched the show, and while they were quite similar, the show definitely takes some liberties, the same thing will happen, but maybe to a different character, or in a different timeline.
I stopped watching the show a long time ago, but I would still be interested in finishing the comics.
I definitely enjoyed the comic more than the show, the show was often slow, while the comics are fast paced and a really easy read.
I stopped watching the show a long time ago, but I would still be interested in finishing the comics.
I definitely enjoyed the comic more than the show, the show was often slow, while the comics are fast paced and a really easy read.
sangd's review
3.0
There was less action in this Walking Dead, but I still enjoyed reading it. It was more relaxed and it read very well. Some passages have been very hard to read because I'm a person close to my emotions and some characters just doesn't care more about their emotions. Rick is terribly hard to follow. I start slowly to appreciate some character more than Rick and I find it a pity, because in the series I love him. He takes what it takes to keep his family living without thinking and I love this side of him.
Il y avait moins d'action dans ce Walking dead, mais j'ai tout de même apprécié en faire la lecture. Il était plus relaxe est ce lisait très bien. Certains passages ont été très dur à lire, car je suis une personne proche de mes émotions et certains personnages ne se préoccupe tout simplement plus de leurs émotions. Rick est terriblement dur à suivre. Je commence tranquillement à apprécier certain personnage plus que Rick et je trouve ça dommage, car dans la série je l'adore. Il faut se qu'il faut pour garder sa famille en vit sans réfléchir et j'aime ce côté de lui.
Il y avait moins d'action dans ce Walking dead, mais j'ai tout de même apprécié en faire la lecture. Il était plus relaxe est ce lisait très bien. Certains passages ont été très dur à lire, car je suis une personne proche de mes émotions et certains personnages ne se préoccupe tout simplement plus de leurs émotions. Rick est terriblement dur à suivre. Je commence tranquillement à apprécier certain personnage plus que Rick et je trouve ça dommage, car dans la série je l'adore. Il faut se qu'il faut pour garder sa famille en vit sans réfléchir et j'aime ce côté de lui.
raloveridge's review
3.0
The Safe-Zone storyline just isn't as interesting as I want it to be. Also. Andrea. LOOK AT YOUR LIFE, LOOK AT YOUR CHOICES. I miss Dale.
craigmaxwell's review
4.0
Rebuilding Alexandria again after the hoard attacked. Kirkman is starting to show the complexities of some of the characters in this Volume. Rick, Rosita, Andrea we are seeing all different sides of their personalities.
They’re becoming too comfortable, I’m just waiting for Negan to show up, then it’s going to hit the fan!
They’re becoming too comfortable, I’m just waiting for Negan to show up, then it’s going to hit the fan!
charliebuck's review against another edition
dark
emotional
sad
tense
medium-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? A mix
- Strong character development? Yes
- Loveable characters? Yes
- Diverse cast of characters? Yes
- Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes
4.0
rhysciar's review
4.0
God, it's time for changing the illustrator, don't you think? It always bugged me, that the art is shit in this comic, but c'mon, this is pathetic. All the women look like men, the shading is crap, there's no background most of the times, it makes me really sad. Compared to other Image comics, this is by far the worst when it comes to the graphics, which is just sad, because the story is really good.