ha1011's review against another edition
emotional
funny
hopeful
lighthearted
medium-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? Character
- Strong character development? It's complicated
- Loveable characters? Yes
- Diverse cast of characters? No
- Flaws of characters a main focus? No
5.0
I love Freddy so much! ❤️
caitlancole's review against another edition
adventurous
funny
lighthearted
relaxing
medium-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? A mix
- Strong character development? Yes
- Loveable characters? Yes
- Diverse cast of characters? No
- Flaws of characters a main focus? It's complicated
4.5
fictionfan's review against another edition
5.0
Roses are red…
When curmudgeonly old miser Matthew Penicuik suffers a particularly bad episode of gout, he thinks it’s time to decide who will inherit his considerable fortune once he’s gone. Not that any of his relatives believe him to be in any danger, hypochondria being another of his endearing qualities. Many years earlier, he had taken in Kitty Charing, the orphaned daughter of a friend, and he wants to be sure she’ll be provided for. So he hits upon the infamous notion of announcing that he will leave all of his money to whichever of his great-nephews marries Kitty, and invites them all to come for a visit – and to propose to poor Kitty. Everyone assumes Jack will be the lucky man – not only is he Great-Uncle Matthew’s favourite, but Kitty has had a crush on him since she was a schoolroom miss. But Jack’s pride won’t let him dance to Great-Uncle Matthew’s tune and anyway he’s not ready to get married, being too busy womanising all over town, so he refuses to come. In a fit of pique, Kitty persuades her cousin, the Honourable Freddy Standen, to pretend to become engaged to her and take her to London for a month on the pretext of meeting his parents…
Georgette Heyer’s Regency romances are my idea of literary chicken soup – they’re what I turn to if I have a cold or a fit of the dismals or, as now, hit a brick wall with some of the stuff I’ve been reading. She writes with such humour and the books are generally light and frothy fun. The heroes are usually rich, often proud and always handsome. The heroines are always strong, usually feisty and spirited, and would never dream of marrying for anything other than love. In fact, they are all variations of Darcy and Lizzie, and the road to true love is always as convoluted as in Pride and Prejudice, but stripped of the serious side of that book. Heyer is fun and romance, pure and simple, and the inevitable happy ending in no way diminishes the pleasure of the journey.
Cotillion is my favourite of all Heyer’s romances. Kitty is such a likeable heroine – kept countrified and dowdy all her life, she discovers the joys of clothes-shopping, hairdressing, learning to dance, and is soon able to stand her ground with the best of them. Freddy’s friends and family have always considered him nothing more than a fashionable young man about town – a Bertie Woosterish figure – but as he has to pull Kitty out of one scrape after another, he shows a level of intelligence and competence no-one ever suspected he possessed. The supporting cast is the usual Regency line-up of fops and dandies, grande dames and put-upon companions, flirts and innocent young misses, out-and-outers and Pinks of the Ton. The assorted great nephews vying with varying degrees of enthusiasm for Kitty’s hand add an extra level of humour to the book. And then there’s Jack – all charming exterior and wicked interior.
Will Kitty realise Freddy’s superior worth before it’s too late? Will Freddy begin to reconsider his bachelor ways? Will Kitty’s friend Olivia marry the old roué Sir Henry Gosford for money or find a way to marry the gorgeous Chevalier d’Evron for love? Will Great-Uncle Matthew ever recover from his gout? And will I read this book again and again and again? Entertaining, mood-enhancing fun to brighten up the greyest day!
www.fictionfanblog.wordpress.com
When curmudgeonly old miser Matthew Penicuik suffers a particularly bad episode of gout, he thinks it’s time to decide who will inherit his considerable fortune once he’s gone. Not that any of his relatives believe him to be in any danger, hypochondria being another of his endearing qualities. Many years earlier, he had taken in Kitty Charing, the orphaned daughter of a friend, and he wants to be sure she’ll be provided for. So he hits upon the infamous notion of announcing that he will leave all of his money to whichever of his great-nephews marries Kitty, and invites them all to come for a visit – and to propose to poor Kitty. Everyone assumes Jack will be the lucky man – not only is he Great-Uncle Matthew’s favourite, but Kitty has had a crush on him since she was a schoolroom miss. But Jack’s pride won’t let him dance to Great-Uncle Matthew’s tune and anyway he’s not ready to get married, being too busy womanising all over town, so he refuses to come. In a fit of pique, Kitty persuades her cousin, the Honourable Freddy Standen, to pretend to become engaged to her and take her to London for a month on the pretext of meeting his parents…
‘You think I’ve got brains?’ he said, awed. ‘Not confusing me with Charlie?’
‘Charlie?’ uttered Miss Charing contemptuously. ‘I daresay he has book-learning, but you have—you have address, Freddy!’
‘Well, by Jove!’ said Mr Standen, dazzled by this new vision of himself.
Georgette Heyer’s Regency romances are my idea of literary chicken soup – they’re what I turn to if I have a cold or a fit of the dismals or, as now, hit a brick wall with some of the stuff I’ve been reading. She writes with such humour and the books are generally light and frothy fun. The heroes are usually rich, often proud and always handsome. The heroines are always strong, usually feisty and spirited, and would never dream of marrying for anything other than love. In fact, they are all variations of Darcy and Lizzie, and the road to true love is always as convoluted as in Pride and Prejudice, but stripped of the serious side of that book. Heyer is fun and romance, pure and simple, and the inevitable happy ending in no way diminishes the pleasure of the journey.
‘I daresay Freddy might not be a great hand at slaying dragons- but one has not the smallest need of a man who can kill dragons!’
Cotillion is my favourite of all Heyer’s romances. Kitty is such a likeable heroine – kept countrified and dowdy all her life, she discovers the joys of clothes-shopping, hairdressing, learning to dance, and is soon able to stand her ground with the best of them. Freddy’s friends and family have always considered him nothing more than a fashionable young man about town – a Bertie Woosterish figure – but as he has to pull Kitty out of one scrape after another, he shows a level of intelligence and competence no-one ever suspected he possessed. The supporting cast is the usual Regency line-up of fops and dandies, grande dames and put-upon companions, flirts and innocent young misses, out-and-outers and Pinks of the Ton. The assorted great nephews vying with varying degrees of enthusiasm for Kitty’s hand add an extra level of humour to the book. And then there’s Jack – all charming exterior and wicked interior.
Upon Mrs Scorton’s reappearance, she found herself confronted, not by the fool of his family, but by the Honourable Frederick Standen, a Pink of the Pinks, who knew to a nicety how to blend courtesy with hauteur, and who informed her, with exquisite politeness, that he rather fancied his cousin was tired, and would like to be taken home. One of the uninvited guests, entering the box in Eliza’s wake, ventured on a warm sally, found himself being inspected from head to foot through a quizzing-glass, and stammered an apology.
Will Kitty realise Freddy’s superior worth before it’s too late? Will Freddy begin to reconsider his bachelor ways? Will Kitty’s friend Olivia marry the old roué Sir Henry Gosford for money or find a way to marry the gorgeous Chevalier d’Evron for love? Will Great-Uncle Matthew ever recover from his gout? And will I read this book again and again and again? Entertaining, mood-enhancing fun to brighten up the greyest day!
www.fictionfanblog.wordpress.com
avalydia's review against another edition
4.0
I'm really enjoying Georgette Heyer's books, and this one was no exception! Still can't figure out why Freddy was talking so strangely, though...
carolynf's review against another edition
4.0
I was completely unaware of Georgette Heyer until just a few weeks ago. Apparently one of the the most prolific and well-research historical fiction writers managed to fly completely under my radar. I quickly picked up four of her most popular books: Cotillion, False Colors, Frederica, and The Grand Sophy. I read Cotillion first and I liked it the best.
The time period and social class is depicted in immaculate detail. It is the kind of book that makes people want to travel back in time, because they imagine that they would land in circumstances like these characters are in instead of working in a mine or popping out 19 kids or something. The main character, Kitty, has to marry a cousin in order to get her inheritance. The cousin that she wanted to marry, Jack, was a no show to the bidding party, so she gets fake engaged to her other cousin, Freddy. This enables her to get a trip out of the sticks and into London, where she can hopefully meet up with Jack. NON-SPOILER: Freddy turns out to be her ideal partner and Jack is a loser.
Kitty is a bit bland but I love Freddy. He is obsessed with his appearance and social standing, but is also polished, poised, and extremely kind-hearted. He is a stand-up guy and sacrifices his own values in order to do right by others. When Kitty got emotional and clung to his coat, potentially creasing the sleeves, and yet he overlooked this tragedy in order to comfort her, I knew he was a keeper. As she points out in one scene, girls dream of a knight who can save them from dragons, but really isn't it much more practical to have someone who can save them from embarrassing social situations. Remember the adaptation of "The Scarlet Pimpernel" starring Leslie Howard? The main character was putting on this persona to throw his enemies off, but he still reminds me of Freddy: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QD0cE8B5Dj0.
The time period and social class is depicted in immaculate detail. It is the kind of book that makes people want to travel back in time, because they imagine that they would land in circumstances like these characters are in instead of working in a mine or popping out 19 kids or something. The main character, Kitty, has to marry a cousin in order to get her inheritance. The cousin that she wanted to marry, Jack, was a no show to the bidding party, so she gets fake engaged to her other cousin, Freddy. This enables her to get a trip out of the sticks and into London, where she can hopefully meet up with Jack. NON-SPOILER: Freddy turns out to be her ideal partner and Jack is a loser.
Kitty is a bit bland but I love Freddy. He is obsessed with his appearance and social standing, but is also polished, poised, and extremely kind-hearted. He is a stand-up guy and sacrifices his own values in order to do right by others. When Kitty got emotional and clung to his coat, potentially creasing the sleeves, and yet he overlooked this tragedy in order to comfort her, I knew he was a keeper. As she points out in one scene, girls dream of a knight who can save them from dragons, but really isn't it much more practical to have someone who can save them from embarrassing social situations. Remember the adaptation of "The Scarlet Pimpernel" starring Leslie Howard? The main character was putting on this persona to throw his enemies off, but he still reminds me of Freddy: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QD0cE8B5Dj0.
katdid's review against another edition
4.0
4.5 stars. The Honourable Frederick Standen, Pink of the Pinks, is the best Heyer hero of my acquaintance! and particularly remarkable because he is so genuinely committed to dandyism. I also LOVE Freddy's father -- trying to recall whether we usually meet the hero's father in Heyer?
ladyhighwayman's review against another edition
4.0
Delightful. I loved it.
Freddy was the most unlikeliest of heroes and I loved seeing his character progress gradually throughout the book.
And Dolphinton was such a kick in the head! What a nut.
Freddy was the most unlikeliest of heroes and I loved seeing his character progress gradually throughout the book.
And Dolphinton was such a kick in the head! What a nut.
keira000's review against another edition
hopeful
lighthearted
medium-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? A mix
- Strong character development? No
- Loveable characters? Yes
- Diverse cast of characters? No
- Flaws of characters a main focus? No
4.0
rachel_abby_reads's review against another edition
4.0
(2008)I like this novel because the romantic hero is so unusual; he isn't the smartest or best looking man on the scene. He isn't the reformed rake or gambler. He's intended to make the desired male jealous, and ends up being the desired male. It's good to see Heyer go with the less obvious hero.
(2016) I feel a little gypped that we missed out on how Kit talked Freddy into going along with her plot. One minute, he has a bunch of objections that she can't answer, and "ten minutes later" they're getting ready to return to Arnside to execute Kit's plan. Kit must have been pretty persuasive.
What is it about a gambling womanizer that was so attractive in the Edwardian age? Heyer wrote some "reformed rake" novels, in which love makes a rake abandon his wicked ways. It seems to me that it might not be so clean and easy.
(2016) I feel a little gypped that we missed out on how Kit talked Freddy into going along with her plot. One minute, he has a bunch of objections that she can't answer, and "ten minutes later" they're getting ready to return to Arnside to execute Kit's plan. Kit must have been pretty persuasive.
What is it about a gambling womanizer that was so attractive in the Edwardian age? Heyer wrote some "reformed rake" novels, in which love makes a rake abandon his wicked ways. It seems to me that it might not be so clean and easy.
book_nut's review against another edition
4.0
So funny! Loved Freddy -- he totally killed me -- and everyone one else was dense enough that I just laughed and laughed. The only thing that bugged me was that it felt like it was set in the 1920s rather than the 1810s. But, I can forgive that.