Scan barcode
A review by antimony
The Witch and the Tsar by Olesya Salnikova Gilmore
slow-paced
- Strong character development? No
- Loveable characters? No
- Diverse cast of characters? No
2.0
reminder to my future self that if a book mentions someone vying for power in the summary i will not enjoy myself while reading it. even if it has baba yaga. i don't like reading about nobility i don't like fantasy politics i don't like strategizing and battles and war. and the romance was nonsense it felt like ya-levels of fake and shoehorned. sorry!
the feminism also felt like very ya. like yaga oftentimes felt like when people try to write feminism into their historical fiction but give the character a very modern view of things instead of a view that would fit into the times while still wanting a better life for women. AND she spends so long talking about how she doesn't want to get married, she doesn't need a man, marriage is just a way for her to be trapped, and then falls in instalove with a guy she has no chemistry with and gets pregnant and gets married and has a kid and is obsessed with this man for no reason. and no one has any personality!!!! :(
additionally . how in the world was this so slow for covering a timeline of twenty years :/ so maybe it was boring on its own not just because of the war.
ALSO what olesya salnikova gilmore wanted to do with subverting baba yaga stories that were told by christians to make her into an evil witch instead of a nice healer with pagan roots was like. nice idea i guess. but to be perfectly honest. i love evil baba yaga that eats kids and has skulls on her house etc. and there was not nearly enough time spent with her house i love her house :( and this did not feel like it was about baba yaga at ALL!
the feminism also felt like very ya. like yaga oftentimes felt like when people try to write feminism into their historical fiction but give the character a very modern view of things instead of a view that would fit into the times while still wanting a better life for women. AND she spends so long talking about how she doesn't want to get married, she doesn't need a man, marriage is just a way for her to be trapped, and then falls in instalove with a guy she has no chemistry with and gets pregnant and gets married and has a kid and is obsessed with this man for no reason. and no one has any personality!!!! :(
additionally . how in the world was this so slow for covering a timeline of twenty years :/ so maybe it was boring on its own not just because of the war.
ALSO what olesya salnikova gilmore wanted to do with subverting baba yaga stories that were told by christians to make her into an evil witch instead of a nice healer with pagan roots was like. nice idea i guess. but to be perfectly honest. i love evil baba yaga that eats kids and has skulls on her house etc. and there was not nearly enough time spent with her house i love her house :( and this did not feel like it was about baba yaga at ALL!
Content Warnings
Graphic: Death, War, and Violence
Minor: Death of parent