A review by hiking_reader
The Legend of Black Jack by A.R. Witham

5.0

I don't have too much to add from my original review. It's still a great story! But I loved the narration by Andy personally. It's hard to beat the ability of an author that has the skill set to handle their narration who is intimate with the book. As I mentioned on social media I had strong narration style vibes from Andy comparing him to the late great Jean Shepherd. Very similar styles and it just fit this story perfect for my immersion. It felt like someone was sitting in the room with me just telling me of this epic story! I bumped this up to a solid 5.0/5.0 with the audiobook.

Original Review 4.5/5.0 officially

I had heard about this one from the community both in Discord and on Twitter this Summer so I had added it to my short list and found some time here in early September to dive into this one. I honestly didn't know much going in other than most readers I had seen enjoyed it to some extent or another.

I will say as interesting as the prologue was to start this book, by the second chapter I was scratching my head as our world was being turned upside down. The prologue had me expecting a bit of an Indiana Jones type of story which I wouldn't have been mad about at all. However, the way this book progressed I ended up with very strong nostalgia vibes reminding me of fantasy movies from the 80s that I grew up watching. It felt like I was being throw back into fantastical worlds such as The Never Ending Story, Time Bandits, Dark Crystal or Labyrinth once again.

The pacing seemed very consistent for me. There was a lot of action or anxiety as we learn about the world and characters around our protagonist and his story. This was one of those books that I found time whenever I could to keep moving along with this story.

The character development was strong as well. We certainly learn a lot about Jack but as the story is told we learn more and more about many of the supporting characters as well. I'm not sure I'll forget the introduction of Memphis to Jack for quite some time. That was the moment I shoock my head wondering just what I had gotten into! There are also several touching moments near the end of the story and one specifically that actually got me a little choked up. It wasn't a sad moment, just a very powerful and emotional moment!

The world building was another strong aspect of this read. We start our early learning about a few areas within Jack's world in detail before we are transported to another fantastic world which spends most of the book learning about this new world. There were so many regions, environments, races and cultures introduced and explained to us by the author. There were so many different traditional fantasy aspects pulled into this grand story! We have pirates, mages, knights/samurai and deamons to make one hell of an adventure!

I thoroughly enjoyed this read and I hope that Andy (now that I've finished his book, I hope I can call him that) can continue to give us more wonderful stories and worlds to explore in the future!

I think this book could appeal to many different readers since it touches on a lot of different sub-genres to fantasy. I've since seen this book categorized as a Young Adult Portal Science Fiction Fantasy. And though it does have aspects that fit that, I hope that doesn't turn readers off from giving this one a chance. It's not a very long read and the style is a very easy read as well. Definitely worth the time!