A review by takara_reads
The Best Book Boyfriend by Holly June Smith

medium-paced
  • Plot- or character-driven? A mix
  • Strong character development? Yes
  • Loveable characters? It's complicated
  • Diverse cast of characters? It's complicated
  • Flaws of characters a main focus? It's complicated

5.0

The novel presents a heartwarming and realistic journey for two characters, Kara and Luke, who are both healing from past wounds. Kara’s retreat into fictional romances after a painful breakup, and Luke’s grief from losing his wife, set up a poignant backdrop for their unexpected connection. 

Luke's transformation—from someone dismissive of romance novels to someone who starts seeing their deeper value—is a fresh and charming twist. His willingness to open up to Kara’s world by reading romance is both endearing and insightful, especially since it highlights how fiction can bring people together in unexpected ways. Kara’s love for stories with guaranteed happy endings becomes a metaphor for her own quest for emotional healing and stability, while Luke's journey from loss to rediscovery of love mirrors the kind of arcs often found in romance novels. 

The evolution from their "not-so-cute" first meeting to a deep friendship and possible romance is something readers will find both funny and heartfelt. The exploration of past trauma and how it impacts their ability to move forward makes the characters relatable and adds emotional depth to the lighthearted romantic moments. 

Holly June Smith seems to capture the balance between humor, emotional depth, and romance perfectly. The novel's nod to romance novels as a genre is a clever way to engage readers who already love these stories, while Luke's discovery of the genre makes it appealing even to those new to it. 

Overall, the book promises a touching and enjoyable read, with moments of laughter, growth, and of course, love. If you’re a fan of slow-burn romances where both characters grow individually and together, The Best Book Boyfriend might just be the perfect pick for you.