Scan barcode
A review by thebetterstory
Paladin's Grace by T. Kingfisher
adventurous
funny
medium-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? A mix
- Strong character development? Yes
- Loveable characters? Yes
- Diverse cast of characters? No
- Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes
3.5
Another book with a wonderful premise and T. Kingfisher’s signature mix of the creepy and the cozily mundane. Unfortunately, this is actually my least favourite of hers I’ve read so far—which is a shame, given it’s the only one that’s part of a series—owing purely to the rather clumsy romance.
Normally I quite like Kingfisher’s romantic subplots, perhaps because all the ones I’ve read previously have been quite low-key, but it takes up a much larger focus in this one and the novel suffers for it. Grace and Stephen are individually likeable, but there were numerous asides in every chapter where they had ill-timed inappropriate thoughts about each other and pattered on for a bit about what a bad idea it would be to kiss/have sex with the other that quickly weighed the narrative down and honestly felt a bit juvenile. You could cut out all the times Stephen thought about breasts or Grace thought about muscles, or a side character teased them about it, and the book would be both much shorter and much better.
Happily, there’s still plenty to like here. Things pick up a lot about halfway through, which thankfully also means less badly written internal monologuing about anatomy, and the plot is tidy and satisfying. The entire conceit behind the paladins and their dead god hits all my fealty kink buttons, the banter is funny when it’s not about getting laid, and the supernatural villain eventually encountered is fantastically creepy. There’s enough depth to the worldbuilding that I’m excited to get different characters in future instalments that can explore the setting from more angles.
Recommended along with the rest of T. Kingfisher’s work; even not at her best, she packs lots of fun ideas into her narratives. Just know that you might enjoy yourself more with a different book of hers if you end up bouncing off of this one.
Normally I quite like Kingfisher’s romantic subplots, perhaps because all the ones I’ve read previously have been quite low-key, but it takes up a much larger focus in this one and the novel suffers for it. Grace and Stephen are individually likeable, but there were numerous asides in every chapter where they had ill-timed inappropriate thoughts about each other and pattered on for a bit about what a bad idea it would be to kiss/have sex with the other that quickly weighed the narrative down and honestly felt a bit juvenile. You could cut out all the times Stephen thought about breasts or Grace thought about muscles, or a side character teased them about it, and the book would be both much shorter and much better.
Happily, there’s still plenty to like here. Things pick up a lot about halfway through, which thankfully also means less badly written internal monologuing about anatomy, and the plot is tidy and satisfying. The entire conceit behind the paladins and their dead god hits all my fealty kink buttons, the banter is funny when it’s not about getting laid, and the supernatural villain eventually encountered is fantastically creepy. There’s enough depth to the worldbuilding that I’m excited to get different characters in future instalments that can explore the setting from more angles.
Recommended along with the rest of T. Kingfisher’s work; even not at her best, she packs lots of fun ideas into her narratives. Just know that you might enjoy yourself more with a different book of hers if you end up bouncing off of this one.
Content Warnings
Moderate: Body horror and Toxic relationship
Minor: Miscarriage and Violence