A review by smitty2567
Dogs: From Predator to Protector by Andy Hirsch
5.0
Hi-Lo Non-fiction
Target Audience: 4-12th Grade
Summary:
This graphic novel addresses evolution, genetics, natural selection through the story of how dogs evolved from wolf-like animals to our beloved pets.
Strengths & Weaknesses:
Dogs approaches some very complicated subjects in an easy, narrative way. The scientific ideas flow naturally from one to the next, as the narrator (a dog named Rudy) explains different aspects of dogs' history and anatomy to the reader. Evolution and natural selection become easy to understand when explained through dogs. Using adorable, cartoon dogs is a good way to gain and keep the audience's attention. The author also makes good use of humor to keep the reading simple and entertaining.
Personal critique:
While this graphic novel might not be in depth enough for students trying to pass a Biology AP, it would a great introduction to genetics and evolution younger students or a gateway book for older students to understand the broader ideas presented. The explanations were really clear and concise and I really enjoyed the artwork.
Illustrations:
Color Illustrations .
Notable awards:
None
Lesson Planning:
This would be a great companion text for high school students in biology who need explanations of genetics and evolution at a lower reading level.
Target Audience: 4-12th Grade
Summary:
This graphic novel addresses evolution, genetics, natural selection through the story of how dogs evolved from wolf-like animals to our beloved pets.
Strengths & Weaknesses:
Dogs approaches some very complicated subjects in an easy, narrative way. The scientific ideas flow naturally from one to the next, as the narrator (a dog named Rudy) explains different aspects of dogs' history and anatomy to the reader. Evolution and natural selection become easy to understand when explained through dogs. Using adorable, cartoon dogs is a good way to gain and keep the audience's attention. The author also makes good use of humor to keep the reading simple and entertaining.
Personal critique:
While this graphic novel might not be in depth enough for students trying to pass a Biology AP, it would a great introduction to genetics and evolution younger students or a gateway book for older students to understand the broader ideas presented. The explanations were really clear and concise and I really enjoyed the artwork.
Illustrations:
Color Illustrations .
Notable awards:
None
Lesson Planning:
This would be a great companion text for high school students in biology who need explanations of genetics and evolution at a lower reading level.