A review by samdalefox
The Iron Man by Ted Hughes

adventurous sad tense fast-paced
  • Plot- or character-driven? Plot
  • Strong character development? It's complicated
  • Loveable characters? Yes
  • Diverse cast of characters? Yes
  • Flaws of characters a main focus? It's complicated

3.25

I know I watched The Iron Giant as a kid, but I hoenstly can't remember it, so I went in to the book without preconceptions. Like other readers, I found the introduction of the second main character
the the space-bat-angel-dragon
a sudden change in tone but I still thoroughly enjoyed the story. I can clearly identify the themes Hughes was trying to introduce, but I don't think it was cohesive at all. For example, he incorporates themes of consumption, war, greed, and the message for us to live in harmony with each other, to find a natural calmness and balance. YET, he has a clear cut case of slavery with no moral implications or indications which is contrary to that aim... He also hints at themes of man made machinery vs nature where the message at first seems to be that nature should be respected, should triumph, and harmony should be found. YET AGAIN, he contradicts this with a clear example that machinery can win over a natural being and enslave it for the greater good of humanity and that this is desirable. As such, the true morals of the fable are contradictory and confusing.

The best part is definitely the characterisation of the iron man, I especially loved the first part and the description of his colour changing eyes and behaviours. I found the below review had a particularly interesting point that I agree with and adds to the contradictory and confusing nature of the story (specific section highlighted in bold). Contains spoilers.

insomniac2453's review

...I could see kids being read this book and proclaiming how they believe the story will continue or how the situation will play out, who they support - the farmers or the iron man. And later in the story, if they feel bad for the iron man or the space-bat-angel-dragon. The sentences were full of descriptive language so it always felt action packed, even if the iron man was just collecting his body parts....




Expand filter menu Content Warnings