A review by novelheartbeat
Sign of the Moon by Erin Hunter
3.0
2.5/5
WHERE is the magic of the first series?! I am so depressed that it is now completely gone. Nothing really happened in this one, and I was bored for most of it. I'm really over the Dark Forest storyline AND the Tribe storyline. Snoooore. Can something interesting please happen? And no, I don't mean Firestar's death, which I am positive is coming, and soon. At this point the death of a major character would just piss me off, because hardly anyone important has died in several series despite the dangers of the outdoors that the cats face. THERE ARE NO STAKES ANYMORE. I was reading my reviews of the first series yesterday, and it made me even more depressed that the rest of the series is nothing like that first set. It really is like Game of Thrones with cats, and the last 3 sets of 6 books have been season 8.
The only thing that really stood out in this one is that I feel bad for Jayfeather. I wish he could have had a normal life with Half Moon!
WHERE is the magic of the first series?! I am so depressed that it is now completely gone. Nothing really happened in this one, and I was bored for most of it. I'm really over the Dark Forest storyline AND the Tribe storyline. Snoooore. Can something interesting please happen? And no, I don't mean Firestar's death, which I am positive is coming, and soon. At this point the death of a major character would just piss me off, because hardly anyone important has died in several series despite the dangers of the outdoors that the cats face. THERE ARE NO STAKES ANYMORE. I was reading my reviews of the first series yesterday, and it made me even more depressed that the rest of the series is nothing like that first set. It really is like Game of Thrones with cats, and the last 3 sets of 6 books have been season 8.
The only thing that really stood out in this one is that I feel bad for Jayfeather. I wish he could have had a normal life with Half Moon!