A review by deathicey
And Then She Fell by Alicia Elliott

challenging dark emotional reflective sad tense fast-paced

• Plot- or character-driven? Character
• Strong character development? Yes
• Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes

3.75

 

A captivating novel that delves into the intricacies of motherhood, mental health, trauma, and the experiences of being a minority. Alicia Elliott skillfully weaves a narrative around the power of storytelling, exploring how the tales we tell can simultaneously empower and ensnare us. The inclusion of the Haudenosaunee creation story alongside Alice's perspective on writing adds depth, creating a parallel that enriches the overall narrative.

This work is significant, particularly in its portrayal of the clash between traditional customs and modern values influenced by the Western world. The insights into Mohawk culture and the struggles of the indigenous community to find their place in a society historically opposed to them are both enlightening and moving.

Addressing critical social issues such as racism, misogyny, and the challenges faced by women in a society imposing Western expectations, the narrative is impactful. The exploration of mental illness resonates deeply, offering a poignant understanding of Alice's emotions as she grapples with her mother's struggles and her own evolving awareness. The portrayal of Alice's husband provides a nuanced perspective on well-intentioned yet damaging microaggressions, risking the erosion of Alice's identity and jeopardizing her daughter's connection to her Native heritage.

The book's strength lies in its raw depiction of the profound impact of mental health struggles, revealing the vulnerability that surfaces in such moments. While the majority of the narrative flows smoothly, the final quarter introduces a more challenging, surreal tone. This section, perhaps due to its rushed feel, could benefit from being presented as an epilogue separate from the main story, potentially enhancing the overall reading experience.