A review by jourdanicus
Holly by Stephen King

dark medium-paced
  • Plot- or character-driven? A mix
  • Strong character development? Yes
  • Loveable characters? It's complicated
  • Diverse cast of characters? Yes
  • Flaws of characters a main focus? It's complicated

3.75

I was eagerly anticipating listening to this after establishing my appreciation for Holly as a character in the Bill Hodges trilogy, and then the first two books in Holly's trilogy. I am no covid denier or anti-vaxxer, in fact quite the opposite a someone who still routinely masks in 2024, but unfortunately the c o n s t a n t "are ya vaxxed?" "Double!" had even me rolling my eyes hard. That's probably because one of the reasons I read is escapism. I'm already worried enough about covid irl. I'm not worried about elderly cannibal neighbors though - that's the story I'm here for!

It's not that the book was ruined by the frequent mentions of vaxxing, masking, and covid. It was just laid on so thick. The story would have been better served by briefer mentions or letting the reader assume continuity in the characters' behavior. I also felt kinda off about the very black and white, "this person got covid so they died and probably deserved it because they didn't get vaxxed."
Primarily regarding Holly's mother.
Or how the bad guys were staunchly anti-vaxx. Unfortunately(?) reality is much more complicated than that.

An earlier-in-the-pandemic version of myself honestly would probably have appreciated all that, because there was a long chunk of time where it felt uncanny to read or watch anything fictional that didn't mention covid. But this was too much. I also felt like I didn't get enough "oofs" from Holly. She didn't quite seem like herself, but maybe I was just distracted by yet another character encouraging her to unmask because they'd "gotten the jab!"
Expand filter menu Content Warnings