A review by kananineko
The Witchery by S. Isabelle
adventurous
dark
hopeful
mysterious
reflective
tense
medium-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? Plot
- Strong character development? No
- Loveable characters? Yes
- Diverse cast of characters? Yes
- Flaws of characters a main focus? It's complicated
3.0
I want to start by saying this is not a terrible book and i think there will be lots of people who will love it. However, it just simply felt meh to me. Very mid. I also think I am starting to get too old for YA fantasy. The plot and location was interesting, but tbh the worldbuilding fell kinda flat for me. (I also was rushing a bit while reading, so that might be my fault for potentially skipping some things).
The characters were hit or miss for me. I didn’t like Logan at all and her dynamic as the “baby witch” was kinda annoying and i didn’t really get why the others invited her into their group? I actually did really like Iris, and kinda wish she was the main character. I loved what we saw of Jaila but I wish we got more or her—I feel like her story was underdeveloped. And I didn’t really like Thalia either although unlike Logan I couldn’t really tell you why. Both of the male characters were bland AF and I didn’t really care about them at all. None of the romances were compelling either, the only one I was semi invested in was Iris (plus the guy who’s name I forgot) but I love grew into caring about them a little bit (but not enough to read the next book lol).
The plot was pretty weak imo. So why 3 stars and not 2? tbh I still enjoyed the book overall and I read it pretty quickly, it held my attention. Someone said it was like a bad CW show and I agree. So if you like those kinds of shows, if you like YA fantasy and stuff, I think you’ll like this. I also kinda hyped this book up in my head a lot bc the description sounded so cool to me and it took me like a year to actually get my hands on it, so the disappointment factor is there too.
One last note, the word “witchy” was used wayyyy too often and annoyed me so much. Like literally everything was described as witchy, like a “witchy book” rather than a “witch book” idk why but that annoyed me? Def a personal pet peeve but just wanted to say it lol.
The characters were hit or miss for me. I didn’t like Logan at all and her dynamic as the “baby witch” was kinda annoying and i didn’t really get why the others invited her into their group? I actually did really like Iris, and kinda wish she was the main character. I loved what we saw of Jaila but I wish we got more or her—I feel like her story was underdeveloped. And I didn’t really like Thalia either although unlike Logan I couldn’t really tell you why. Both of the male characters were bland AF and I didn’t really care about them at all. None of the romances were compelling either, the only one I was semi invested in was Iris (plus the guy who’s name I forgot) but I love grew into caring about them a little bit (but not enough to read the next book lol).
The plot was pretty weak imo. So why 3 stars and not 2? tbh I still enjoyed the book overall and I read it pretty quickly, it held my attention. Someone said it was like a bad CW show and I agree. So if you like those kinds of shows, if you like YA fantasy and stuff, I think you’ll like this. I also kinda hyped this book up in my head a lot bc the description sounded so cool to me and it took me like a year to actually get my hands on it, so the disappointment factor is there too.
One last note, the word “witchy” was used wayyyy too often and annoyed me so much. Like literally everything was described as witchy, like a “witchy book” rather than a “witch book” idk why but that annoyed me? Def a personal pet peeve but just wanted to say it lol.
Content Warnings
Graphic: Blood, Car accident, Injury/Injury detail, Self harm, and Violence
Moderate: Grief, Murder, Animal death, Death, Death of parent, Gore, Body horror, and Religious bigotry
Minor: Cursing and Fire/Fire injury