A review by emily_journals
Meddling Kids, by Edgar Cantero
adventurous
dark
mysterious
fast-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? Plot
- Strong character development? No
- Loveable characters? It's complicated
- Diverse cast of characters? Yes
- Flaws of characters a main focus? No
2.0
The concept of this book really intrigued me. Scooby-Doo with Lovecraftian elements where the monsters MIGHT BE (and likely are) real? Sign me up!
Except this book was so disappointing in execution. From reading other reviews, I'm so glad I read the audiobook version of this, because the stage direction inserts and made up words weren't as noticeable, so I'll give the narrator mad props for making those things really unnoticeable. I thought the book started off on the right track, but around the halfway point in this book is when I really started noticing all the negatives.
First off, for being set in the 90s (and flashback-esque scenes from the 70s), I personally did not feel much nostalgia around any certain time period. This book really could have mostly been grabbed out of the 90s and plopped into modern day with very little change, which is 100% fine, EXCEPT this book promises to be nostalgic (which I personally did not find it to be).
Secondly, the ending of this book was an absolute mess. Everything that happened in the last ~20% of the book was so chaotic and unbelievable and hard to follow.
Seriously, so much of the end of this book was just fight scene after fight scene, with little substantial buffer between, which I personally find really boring to read (or listen to) for a significant amount of time, especially when every fight scene is "gang fights creatures, then run, then fight new hoard of same creatures, then run.... repeat".
Lastly, this book has some pretty awful and dangerous discussion and representation of mental health, trans people, and queer people. The mental health discussion in this book is unnuanced and the whole introduction scene to the asylum has some very problematic descriptions of people with and without mental health issues. The main villain ended up using transness as a device to live forever and be evil, which was super unnecessary and could have been entirely avoided and is a very pointed decision from the author. The lesbian character in this book is also very much a caricature of a "typical lesbian" media portrayal, and the sapphic relationship seemed like something that a man would write as a fantasy of a sapphic relationship.
Overall, I wish I had done more research into this book before picking it up instead of taking the promises given by the author/publisher at face value, and beyond that, I wish I had given up on this book sooner.
Except this book was so disappointing in execution. From reading other reviews, I'm so glad I read the audiobook version of this, because the stage direction inserts and made up words weren't as noticeable, so I'll give the narrator mad props for making those things really unnoticeable. I thought the book started off on the right track, but around the halfway point in this book is when I really started noticing all the negatives.
First off, for being set in the 90s (and flashback-esque scenes from the 70s), I personally did not feel much nostalgia around any certain time period. This book really could have mostly been grabbed out of the 90s and plopped into modern day with very little change, which is 100% fine, EXCEPT this book promises to be nostalgic (which I personally did not find it to be).
Secondly, the ending of this book was an absolute mess. Everything that happened in the last ~20% of the book was so chaotic and unbelievable and hard to follow.
Spoiler
People were dying and being resurrected left and right, dogs were getting possessed by demons/angels/random protector beings(?), rituals were being cast, people were living forever; it was all just TOO MUCH going on.Seriously, so much of the end of this book was just fight scene after fight scene, with little substantial buffer between, which I personally find really boring to read (or listen to) for a significant amount of time, especially when every fight scene is "gang fights creatures, then run, then fight new hoard of same creatures, then run.... repeat".
Lastly, this book has some pretty awful and dangerous discussion and representation of mental health, trans people, and queer people. The mental health discussion in this book is unnuanced and the whole introduction scene to the asylum has some very problematic descriptions of people with and without mental health issues. The main villain ended up using transness as a device to live forever and be evil, which was super unnecessary and could have been entirely avoided and is a very pointed decision from the author. The lesbian character in this book is also very much a caricature of a "typical lesbian" media portrayal, and the sapphic relationship seemed like something that a man would write as a fantasy of a sapphic relationship.
Overall, I wish I had done more research into this book before picking it up instead of taking the promises given by the author/publisher at face value, and beyond that, I wish I had given up on this book sooner.
Content Warnings
Graphic: Ableism, Blood, Death, Mental illness, Violence, Grief, and Injury/injury detail
Moderate: Confinement, Lesbophobia, Panic attacks/disorders, and Transphobia