A review by lolaslalaland
The Burning God by R.F. Kuang
challenging
dark
slow-paced
2.0
The final installment in the Poppy War Trilogy. A young girl fighting a war on multiple fronts: civil, foreign, mental, spiritual and physical.
Pros:
✅ historical parallels
✅ impactful themes of war and the crimes and brutality that follow it
✅ strong atmosphere of pain and suffering across an entire nation
Cons:
❌ very little character development. they mainly felt like chess pieces moved around or added to progress the war
❌ massive pacing issues... no down time! it's just war, war, war, war. no time to build any kind of connections
❌ magical elements were virutally useless and lead to nothing SPOILER:
❌ a well written unlikeable character but who is incredibly infuriating in her stupidity! She somehow always ends up in the same situation over and over and over again... I needed something new to happen at least once.
What I want to end this review with is that I am glad I read the trilogy because the themes it brings up are important and to have them in a "fantasy" setting lets the author explore them more deeply and with less limitations, but I also think this trilogy tried to do too much theme building and not enough story and character development. Perhaps R.F. Kuang is not the author for me. I will still read her standalone Babel though and find out!
Pros:
✅ historical parallels
✅ impactful themes of war and the crimes and brutality that follow it
✅ strong atmosphere of pain and suffering across an entire nation
Cons:
❌ very little character development. they mainly felt like chess pieces moved around or added to progress the war
❌ massive pacing issues... no down time! it's just war, war, war, war. no time to build any kind of connections
❌ magical elements were virutally useless and lead to nothing SPOILER:
Spoiler
So much hype for the Triad just for them to all get defeaeted at the top of a mountain byt eh same army their thought they could defeat with just the three of them... so incredibly disappointed and what a waste of time throughout the entire trilogy.❌ a well written unlikeable character but who is incredibly infuriating in her stupidity! She somehow always ends up in the same situation over and over and over again... I needed something new to happen at least once.
What I want to end this review with is that I am glad I read the trilogy because the themes it brings up are important and to have them in a "fantasy" setting lets the author explore them more deeply and with less limitations, but I also think this trilogy tried to do too much theme building and not enough story and character development. Perhaps R.F. Kuang is not the author for me. I will still read her standalone Babel though and find out!
Content Warnings
Graphic: Addiction, Rape, Death, Sexual violence, Blood, Gore, War, Torture, Religious bigotry, Body horror, Sexual assault, Racism, Genocide, Fire/Fire injury, Drug use, Child death, Cannibalism, and Colonisation