A review by breaklikeafish
Giovanni's Room by James Baldwin

challenging dark emotional mysterious reflective sad medium-paced
  • Plot- or character-driven? Character
  • Strong character development? Yes
  • Loveable characters? It's complicated
  • Diverse cast of characters? Yes
  • Flaws of characters a main focus? It's complicated

4.5

Despite the fact that almost every character in this novel is morally bankrupt, relationships are toxic, and the narrative structure echoes my gripes from my review of The Seven Husbands of Evelyn Hugo, I found myself utterly captivated by Giovanni's Room.

Following the escapades of David, a young American in bohemian Paris, the story revolves around his attempts to evade adult responsibilities. David is a whiny, misogynistic character with few redeeming qualities. Yet there's an odd relatability in his admirable reluctance to confront his problems.

I think most of my love for this novel comes from James Baldwin's absolutely stunning writing style. Even as David indulges in long-winded contemplations of his self-imposed suffering, Baldwin weaves prose that is breathtakingly beautiful. Somehow, the author turns David's character, who could easily be off-putting, into someone engaging rather than annoying.

Despite my appreciation for the novel, I will note that I'm sure the transphobic and mysogynistic attitudes of almost all characters can be off-putting to some. I think David's blatant hate for everything feminine fits well with his character and development in the story. However, it leads to conversations between him and Giovanni that almost made me throw my book against the wall.

Hella, David's fiancée and only relevant female character, functions to at least challenge the protagonist's views on women. In the midst of a cast filled with terrible personalities, Hella emerges as a sole beacon of reason, adding depth and a refreshing contrast. She is probably the only character I rooted for.

Giovanni's Room, with its breathtaking prose and engaging story, manages to overcome its flaws to deliver a captivating and emotionally resonant experience. Baldwin's ability to make a narrative filled with mostly unlikable characters compelling is a testament to his mastery of storytelling.
Expand filter menu Content Warnings