Scan barcode
A review by emmas_reads_
Jade City by Fonda Lee
tense
medium-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? A mix
- Strong character development? No
- Loveable characters? No
- Diverse cast of characters? It's complicated
- Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes
2.5
this book has pacing issues, it feels simultaneously short and long, and that didn’t work for me. the time passage in this book was supposedly over months, but it felt like everything was happening on successive days which made the pacing of the novel fucked in my head.
i don’t care about any character except anden, and lan when he was alive. i’m not a fan of hilo and shae feels like she has some internalized misogyny to work through even though she’s a woman with power. like this quote?
“Two strong-minded women in a man’s world, if they do not wuickly become allies, are destined to be incurable rivals.” (pg 373)
misogyny coded, i’m sorry. i also felt like doru was made a pedophile solely to make him unlikable, i don’t feel there was any reason otherwise to make him so. it felt kind of out of place and unnecessary.
there was some infodumping, but i thought the way it was worked into the story was clever so i didn’t mind it. there was also some weird indigenous stereotyping that came out of nowhere about the Abukei being drunks, gamblers, and whatever “whor[ing] away their earnings” is as a noun?? not needed. come on.
this book honestly reminds me of that one pride and prejudice review that goes like:
“just a bunch of people going to each other’s houses”
the action scenes were a lot more prevelant than some low reviews made it out to be, but i still felt like this book tried too hard to be political. but fonda lee is so good at writing action scenes, i really enjoyed them!!
i don’t care about any character except anden, and lan when he was alive. i’m not a fan of hilo and shae feels like she has some internalized misogyny to work through even though she’s a woman with power. like this quote?
“Two strong-minded women in a man’s world, if they do not wuickly become allies, are destined to be incurable rivals.” (pg 373)
misogyny coded, i’m sorry. i also felt like doru was made a pedophile solely to make him unlikable, i don’t feel there was any reason otherwise to make him so. it felt kind of out of place and unnecessary.
there was some infodumping, but i thought the way it was worked into the story was clever so i didn’t mind it. there was also some weird indigenous stereotyping that came out of nowhere about the Abukei being drunks, gamblers, and whatever “whor[ing] away their earnings” is as a noun?? not needed. come on.
this book honestly reminds me of that one pride and prejudice review that goes like:
“just a bunch of people going to each other’s houses”
the action scenes were a lot more prevelant than some low reviews made it out to be, but i still felt like this book tried too hard to be political. but fonda lee is so good at writing action scenes, i really enjoyed them!!
Content Warnings
Graphic: Violence
Moderate: Death and Drug use