A review by amyl88
The Great Snape Debate by Joyce Millman, Amy Berner, Orson Scott Card

4.0

Yes, I've gone a bit nuts. This is a double book - one side gives evidence that Snape is bad (evidence in the books as well as literary devices used and, strangely, why the casting of Alan Rickman proves it!); flip it over for the same kinds of evidence proving Snape is good. A lot of the proof from the books is the same on both sides - Rowling is really good at hiding Snape's true colors, and he really could go either way (my vote is GOOD!! Remember Alan Rickman HAS been a good guy, too!)

It does a good job of dissecting the situations and dialogue that point to whichever version, but I guess we'll never really know until July!