Scan barcode
A review by lomeraniel
Dust by Hugh Howey
4.0
Review originally published at: https://www.lomeraniel.com/audiobookreviews/book-review-dust-by-hugh-howey/
Dust is the conclusion to the stories that started in Wool and Shift. This book presents not only the outcome of Juliet's rebelion, but also her contact with Donald who, by chance, has assumed the authority of Silo 1. It was a bit better than the previous book, but still not at the same level of Wool.
Donald managed to make some wrong decisions again, but he's almost redeemed towards the end. We also meet his sister Shirly, which Donald managed to get out of the deep freeze.
I was anxious to know how the story would end, and even though I felt somewhat satisfied, this book felt again for this long-winded and with non-descriptive characters. This last point has been also my complaint about books one and especially two. Wool is a great book but with well-developed characters, it could have been a masterpiece. There were some exciting scenes in Dust that were worth the reading, and I am happy that I stuck to this series until the end.
The ending was okay, it felt right, but I wish it inspired me deeper feelings. I think it all comes down to not being really attached to the characters. They never felt real enough to me.
Tim Gerard Reynolds delivered a correct narration, without audio production issues. He transmitted the characters’ emotions, and was a nice addition to the book, but women sounded exactly like men. I know it is difficult for a male narrator to interpret a female character but Reynolds did not even try. As there were many dialogs between Juliet and Shirly, Reynolds used different accents to differentiate both characters. Somehow Shirly's Southern accent sounded weird, probably because Reynolds is Irish.
Dust was a good book, better than Shift, but it does not still live up to the hype of Wool. I still think it is worth reading if you loved Wool.
Dust is the conclusion to the stories that started in Wool and Shift. This book presents not only the outcome of Juliet's rebelion, but also her contact with Donald who, by chance, has assumed the authority of Silo 1. It was a bit better than the previous book, but still not at the same level of Wool.
Donald managed to make some wrong decisions again, but he's almost redeemed towards the end. We also meet his sister Shirly, which Donald managed to get out of the deep freeze.
I was anxious to know how the story would end, and even though I felt somewhat satisfied, this book felt again for this long-winded and with non-descriptive characters. This last point has been also my complaint about books one and especially two. Wool is a great book but with well-developed characters, it could have been a masterpiece. There were some exciting scenes in Dust that were worth the reading, and I am happy that I stuck to this series until the end.
The ending was okay, it felt right, but I wish it inspired me deeper feelings. I think it all comes down to not being really attached to the characters. They never felt real enough to me.
Tim Gerard Reynolds delivered a correct narration, without audio production issues. He transmitted the characters’ emotions, and was a nice addition to the book, but women sounded exactly like men. I know it is difficult for a male narrator to interpret a female character but Reynolds did not even try. As there were many dialogs between Juliet and Shirly, Reynolds used different accents to differentiate both characters. Somehow Shirly's Southern accent sounded weird, probably because Reynolds is Irish.
Dust was a good book, better than Shift, but it does not still live up to the hype of Wool. I still think it is worth reading if you loved Wool.