A review by busyblackbookworm
Your House Will Pay by Steph Cha
dark
emotional
reflective
sad
tense
medium-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? A mix
- Strong character development? Yes
- Loveable characters? It's complicated
- Diverse cast of characters? Yes
- Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes
2.5
This is an interesting read that deals with anti-Blackness in Asian American (specifically Korean American) communities, focusing on a conflict based heavily on the murder of Latasha Harlins in the 90s. It reads more like a crime thriller since there's an element of mystery to it, but it also explores very real racial tensions.
First, I want to say that I appreciate Cha's decision to broach an important topic that unfortunately is not discussed in literature very frequently, but which has shaped interracial (Black/Asian American) solidarity and relations for decades. I would love to see more books, and fiction specifically, explore this issue. I appreciated that Cha considers the ways in which Asian American communities, which themselves have experienced devastating racism and racial violence, can perpetuate anti-Blackness because white supremacy pits us all against each other. It's an incredibly important conversation to have, and it's not an easy one.
With that being said, I felt that this book was a bit shallow in its engagement with the issues. The writing is a tad on the nose, which isn't necessarily a bad thing, since everyone needs a starting point from which they begin thinking about these issues. But I did feel like Cha was writing for an audience with a very low-level understanding of these issues. And for me, the ending wasn't all that satisfying--Grace has gone through the bare minimum amount of personal development and exploration (going from defending someone who straight up murdered a Black child to thinking that it probably wasn't okay), but Shawn and his family are shown as defending and even forgiving her at the end, suggesting a neat resolution.
Moreover, I felt uncomfortable with Cha having her Black characters refer to themselves and others as "Negroes" even in jest...was that necessary? This felt like an end-run around using the N-word outright but still give the impression of "authenticity" despite not being a member of Black communities. I was additionally a bit irked by the fact that Shawn's Black family was so mired in "criminal" activity and incarceration--every other member of the family was either in prison/jail, previously incarcerated, or embroiled in gang activity. It's true that Black folks are more likely to be incarcerated and impacted by policing, but when the primary audience of this book is Asian American folks, I feel some discomfort in this depiction. I seriously question whether this is simply further entrenching stereotypes.
Another thing that aggravated me was
Cha is getting at some really important interracial dynamics, and sadly this topic isn't discussed nearly as much as it should be in literature, but I think much more care needs to be taken. I'm generally not a fan of dual-author books, but given how complex and thorny this issue is, I think two authors would be really helpful here to ensure that Black and Asian American voices are accurately and carefully reflected.
First, I want to say that I appreciate Cha's decision to broach an important topic that unfortunately is not discussed in literature very frequently, but which has shaped interracial (Black/Asian American) solidarity and relations for decades. I would love to see more books, and fiction specifically, explore this issue. I appreciated that Cha considers the ways in which Asian American communities, which themselves have experienced devastating racism and racial violence, can perpetuate anti-Blackness because white supremacy pits us all against each other. It's an incredibly important conversation to have, and it's not an easy one.
With that being said, I felt that this book was a bit shallow in its engagement with the issues. The writing is a tad on the nose, which isn't necessarily a bad thing, since everyone needs a starting point from which they begin thinking about these issues. But I did feel like Cha was writing for an audience with a very low-level understanding of these issues. And for me, the ending wasn't all that satisfying--Grace has gone through the bare minimum amount of personal development and exploration (going from defending someone who straight up murdered a Black child to thinking that it probably wasn't okay), but Shawn and his family are shown as defending and even forgiving her at the end, suggesting a neat resolution.
Moreover, I felt uncomfortable with Cha having her Black characters refer to themselves and others as "Negroes" even in jest...was that necessary? This felt like an end-run around using the N-word outright but still give the impression of "authenticity" despite not being a member of Black communities. I was additionally a bit irked by the fact that Shawn's Black family was so mired in "criminal" activity and incarceration--every other member of the family was either in prison/jail, previously incarcerated, or embroiled in gang activity. It's true that Black folks are more likely to be incarcerated and impacted by policing, but when the primary audience of this book is Asian American folks, I feel some discomfort in this depiction. I seriously question whether this is simply further entrenching stereotypes.
Another thing that aggravated me was
Spoiler
Cha's choice to have Shawn's nephew be the killer. It seemed a bit lazy and random given that Shawn's nephew had little to no concrete motivation since he never personally knew his aunt and Shawn's nephew barely even figured in the story at all until it was revealed that he killed Grace's mother.Cha is getting at some really important interracial dynamics, and sadly this topic isn't discussed nearly as much as it should be in literature, but I think much more care needs to be taken. I'm generally not a fan of dual-author books, but given how complex and thorny this issue is, I think two authors would be really helpful here to ensure that Black and Asian American voices are accurately and carefully reflected.
Content Warnings
Graphic: Gun violence, Racism, Xenophobia, Child death, and Death of parent