A review by samanthas_book_nook
Uprooted by Naomi Novik

adventurous dark mysterious medium-paced
  • Plot- or character-driven? Plot
  • Strong character development? No
  • Loveable characters? No
  • Flaws of characters a main focus? No

3.5

Uprooted is a standalone, single POV, high fantasy novel with a romance subplot loosely based on Beauty and the Beast. I love Naomi Novik’s writing style and her ability to create unique, high fantasy worlds within a single novel. I really loved Novik’s Spinning Silver- also high fantasy and standalone- so I had high expectations for Uprooted. For the first 150 pages, I was totally captivated by the Wood, the magic, and the banter between Agnieszka and the Dragon. Novik is really good at not just building fantasy worlds but answering all the questions I have and tying up all the loose ends, something I can’t say about all fantasy authors. But this all came crumbling down with the first sexual scene (kissing and graphic touching, p. 158-159). 

Sexual Content

I didn’t even think to check this book for sexual content because Spinning Silver barely had any. I kept reading thinking that was the end of it until the full blown sex scene on pages 353-355. Not to mention, she’s 17 and he’s approximately 150 years old. This didn’t bother me at first because I can excuse an age gap in a fantasy world. He doesn’t age normally so I assumed it’s not weird in this world, but that assumption was shattered when he, the Dragon, says “I’m a century and more older than you-” and protests Agnieszka’s advances (p. 353). That tells me it is in fact taboo, even in Novik’s fantasy world, ew. After I finished that specific chapter, I closed the book in frustration and almost dnf. 

There is a sexual assault scene on pages 43-44 that I would not consider graphic. 

Romance

Personally, I don’t like sexual content (kisses only, please). It completely ruins the fairytale vibe for me, but putting that aside, it just didn’t make any sense. There was no slow burn- barely any build up. The romance between Agnieszka and the Dragon was flat and didn’t feel believable. It felt like Novik only put it in there to fit the Beauty and The Beast trope and I found myself having to insert my own imaginings of emotions and dialogue to make it believable. Again, it was so different from Spinning Silver where the romance was subtle, yet beautifully done, and made me want to cry tears of joy in the end. I expected more! So. Much. More. 

Plot and World 

I did enjoy the magic system in this book and I loved the clash between the Dragon’s magic and Agnieszka’s- one methodical and one driven by pure instinct. Being methodical and logical myself, I could feel the Dragon’s frustration as he tried to teach her. And I could easily imagine how the two of them working together would create something truly, well, magical. 

I got bored around page 250 and didn’t get back into it until about 50 pages from the end, but I really appreciated that I wasn’t able to guess the plot. 

Character Development 

Character development was really lacking.
[ Spoiler: The only time I noticed any real growth in characters was when the Dragon apologized to Kasia and said he would never take another girl.]
Speaking of Kasia, her character was so flat. We only really got a glimpse of her during the Summoning, yet she had a pretty large role in the story. She just felt like a pawn, only useful for the plot, not a meaningful character at all, but maybe that’s because she became more wood than human? 

I really enjoyed the Dragon as a character and wished we could have learned more about him! Agnieszka, however, was just meh. I honestly don’t really have any thoughts about her. 

Final Thoughts

Putting aside my high expectations for a moment, I really did enjoy the plot and the magic in this novel. I loved learning about the mysterious Wood and its connection to the people in the valley. However, this was ruined by the flat and awkward romance and completely unnecessary, and out of place, sex scene. I was also bored in the middle and as another reviewer suggested, this would have been better if it stayed in the tower and the valley. 

Overall, not a terrible book, but it left me frustrated and disappointed. 
Expand filter menu Content Warnings