A review by zeynepsertkaya
American Dirt by Jeanine Cummins

adventurous dark emotional sad tense medium-paced

• Plot- or character-driven? Plot
• Strong character development? Yes
• Loveable characters? Yes
• Diverse cast of characters? Yes
• Flaws of characters a main focus? It's complicated

5.0

In "American Dirt," Jeanine Cummins crafts a narrative that is far from being just another entry in the literature about immigration; it's a profound, heart-stirring odyssey that brings the immigrant experience into sharp, painful focus. This novel is not the definitive account of this experience—no single work could claim that—but it is a compelling and deeply human story that enriches our understanding of what it means to seek a new life in a foreign land.

Cummins skillfully avoids the pitfalls of clichés and negative stereotypes that often plague narratives about immigration. Instead, she presents a story that dismantles these stereotypes, echoing her intention to move beyond the portrayal of immigrants as "faceless brown masses"—a phrase she addresses in the epilogue. Through her vivid storytelling, Cummins highlights the individuality, backstories, and unique motivations of each person making the perilous journey across borders.

The plot centers around Lydia and her young son, Luca, whose flight from the clutches of a Mexican cartel is both gripping and harrowing. Cummins places the reader in Lydia's shoes, making her fear, determination, and maternal instinct palpable. The death of Beto and the actions of Lorenzo are moments that evoke strong emotional responses, from deep sorrow to triumphant relief, showcasing Cummins' talent for character development and her ability to make readers feel deeply connected to the characters' plights.

The novel also serves as a catalyst for further exploration and understanding of the real-world contexts it draws from, such as the dire conditions in Acapulco and the dangers of "The Beast"—the freight train many migrants risk their lives on in hopes of reaching safety. Cummins' portrayal is so vivid and compelling that it drives readers to learn more about the harsh realities faced by migrants.

It is disheartening to see Cummins subjected to vilification and threats over a work of fiction. The backlash she has faced, including unjust one-star reviews from individuals who haven't read the book, is a form of bullying and censorship that undermines the value of diverse storytelling. Cummins' book is a bridge, built on four years of meticulous research, offering a narrative that deserves respect and consideration.

"American Dirt" is not just a novel; it's an invitation to open hearts and minds, to engage in civil discourse about the complex issues surrounding immigration. Cummins doesn't claim to have all the answers, but through "American Dirt," she contributes a vital voice to a conversation that needs as many perspectives as it can get. This book is a must-read for anyone looking to understand the human stories behind the headlines and the statistics—a reminder that every immigrant is a person with a story, deserving of empathy and respect.