Scan barcode
A review by shanaqui
A History of the Roman Empire in 21 Women by Emma Southon
informative
lighthearted
medium-paced
4.0
Emma Southon has a particular style that I imagine some people really hate: conversational, chatty, often even flippant. When she doesn't know something, because no one knows, she says so. When she's painting a picture from imagination to fill in the gaps, or choosing one interpretation of many, she says so very frankly. I find it very readable, and I appreciate how clear she is about when she's using sources, how she's using sources, and when she's just having to make things up -- or choose one option above others because there's nothing particular to tell them apart. She's interested in telling a story here, and it shows.
That said, I can understand why those who are just looking for facts would rather she stop it; for all that she's clear about sources vs imagination, it's really not formalised. Don't let that fool you, though: there's an extensive bibliography at the back.
I really liked Southon's plan to discuss events through women: I was kind of surprised Livia wasn't a choice, for example, or Cleopatra, or Agrippina (who Southon has written a whole biography of!) -- but instead Southon makes a harder decision, and often picks less well-known women.
I found it really enjoyable, though I still prefer her book on murder in Ancient Rome.
That said, I can understand why those who are just looking for facts would rather she stop it; for all that she's clear about sources vs imagination, it's really not formalised. Don't let that fool you, though: there's an extensive bibliography at the back.
I really liked Southon's plan to discuss events through women: I was kind of surprised Livia wasn't a choice, for example, or Cleopatra, or Agrippina (who Southon has written a whole biography of!) -- but instead Southon makes a harder decision, and often picks less well-known women.
I found it really enjoyable, though I still prefer her book on murder in Ancient Rome.