the opposite of trauma porn. a very important read executed with the same grace as the author's children's series. it very much feels like an accurate and loyal depiction of the worst years of Irish history as opposed to a nuanced character study - main characters are not full of flaws or exceptionally layered with tendencies to do great wrongs. a must read to empathise with Ireland's shameful and difficult history.
fantastic. felt ever so real and i could really see myself in this book. makes me excited to grow up and outgrow these horrid thought patterns.
would have been nice for it to do even even more but it is beautifully messy as is. i don't know if i loved the ending but i like where it did decide to end.
one to reread and revisit again and again! a polemic against wage-price spiral. hard to read through but very pithy and so short it is absolutely worth it. come on capital!
i'm sorry but SUSPENSION OF DISBELIEF was required for me to read this book! it sounded like the best plot ever, but whilst the author writes multifaceted characters, they did not feel believable to me for some reason, it felt as though everything was happening on the surface only. i know that's very vague, but it is at least partly because the writing did not work for me - it didn't feel refined and cuddly as i'd hoped, but immature. i couldn't believe that August was 23 years old by the writing. the cut-off sentences as characters have realisations as they speak to one another is incessant and was quite annoying imo. and whilst i loved the emphasis on friendship i didn't feel like i really knew the ensemble either (maybe because there was so many characters??). and perhaps i am just not as much of a genius as August is said to be to understand the surrealist aspect, but there is so much discussion of the plot and the various 'cases' the main character is meddled in, yet they feel completely nonsensical. i would have rathered not being given a justification for someone being stuck on a subway for 45 years, than the messy one given here.
all of this being said this is still a lovely fun book with fantastic representation of queer relationships (although Jane's ethnicity and family background didn't feel rounded out to me personally). maybe i am just salty at how good the sex between August and Jane was when it was her FIRST TIME! also by how the manage to fuck on a full carriage - i find myself on crowded trains imagining how that could have been possible lmao
What a luscious and sparkling translation! After the introduction, which was so accessible and made excellent points on the language of translations, and generally added to my understanding and enjoyment of the story, I had geared myself up for a difficult and tenuous read. But I was surprised by how beautifully simple the language used was. I have read very few ancient texts, so this interpretation is one I would absolutely recommend to beginners like me. In the poem itself, I was surprised by its domesticity, and the fact that half of it take place upon his return to Ithaca!