Reviews

A Study in Stone by Michael Campling

cmdro's review

Go to review page

slow-paced

2.0

risingphoenix54's review

Go to review page

5.0

A thoroughly enjoyable British cozy mystery! Can’t wait to read the next book in the series.

angelic712's review against another edition

Go to review page

3.0

Maybe 2.5 Stars… it should have been a solid 4 for the cozy mystery genre. It had an uncomplicated cast of characters-just the main who is investigating, a side kick, and the deceased as well as the various background characters. It was a historical death so no stress about hiding from a murderer. A delightful setting in the quaint English countryside. Everything one would want when looking for a relaxing book to snuggle down with during a dreary weekend. But the main character, Dan, was basically nothing more than the stereotype of the pushy jerk from the big city who looks down on all the country bumpkins for their slow way of life and manners. He was flat. And boring. And a tiny moment was spent on his backstory which could have really been built upon to give him depth, but was instead just mentioned and then ignored for the boring stereotype. For an interesting plot, the character made it so disappointing.

clacksee's review

Go to review page

5.0

Dan is a bitter, grumpy, irascible man. Alan is a cheerful man with a sunny disposition and an easygoing nature. They don't sound like they'd be a good fit but both are lonely and share a love of puzzles.

This is a mystery that doesn't really need solving – though actually it does. But it's also the story of a friendship.

On the narration side of things, Greg Barnett does a good job. He doesn't do different voices for the characters but he occasionally strays (briefly) into a few regional accents, which he does well. And while he doesn't really vary the voices of the characters, he does infuse them with a different energy, which does help bring them to life.

socorrobaptista's review

Go to review page

4.0

O que me parecia muito uma história monótona, me surpreendeu por ser uma quase narrativa de detetives, embora mais ligada a questões históricas. Bastante interessante.

balthazarlawson's review against another edition

Go to review page

mysterious relaxing fast-paced
  • Plot- or character-driven? Character
  • Strong character development? Yes
  • Loveable characters? Yes
  • Diverse cast of characters? No

4.0

Dan Corrigan is burnt out and decides to take a break from London and moves into his sister's cottage in a small village in Devon. He gets to know his neighbour, Alan, and on a trip to Exeter, in search of real coffee, they come upon a cryptic message on a slab of stone in a cafe that claims to be more than it is. This sets them on the path to decrypt the message and find it's meaning. But there are those that don't want the truth revealed. 

This is a novella that introduces the main characters of the series and is a good introduction. You get to learn about their personality and their motivations. I really enjoyed this, though, one or two things about the main character did annoyed me. His intense reactions is clearly why he is hiding out in a small village.

crazydach's review

Go to review page

2.0

Honestly I was getting really interesting and then it started to wind up. Good story but maybe too short

katiya's review

Go to review page

4.0

4.75 Stars
(This book came close to 5 stars for me and I generally don't award such an honour. I went back and forth on this and then remembered the advice I received when I first began reviewing on GR: Only grant 5 stars to books that are life-changing. So close, so close!)

We have Dan, a Londoner, who's left his corporate world behind for a time as he heads to his sister's holiday cottage in Devonshire and Alan, a local and a former teacher, who befriends Dan. We follow the pair through their adventures (and misadventures) as they try to solve the riddle of a cypher chiselled in stone and its relation to a manor house.

As other reviewers have mentioned, Dan is a bit much. In the beginning, I wasn't sure I would even manage to finish the story. And then we met Alan. Together the two complete each other. Dan's rough edges are smoothed by Alan's empathy and Alan's hesitancy is overcome by Dan's exuberance. Once that had been settled, the fun began! The mystery (a puzzle rather than a murder) was quite basic and if you wanted to spoil a good read, you could have guessed the outcome, but you would have missed all the enjoyable parts: the camaraderie, the logistics of solving a code, the blast of being ejected from places because you and your mate were being cheeky. (Well, Alan might protest a little at that last one.)

I absolutely scored up my copy with the various quips and potshots they took at each other - all in a sense of fun. It's isn't endearment unless there a slight touch of sarcasm, fondly meant, of course. The friendship between these two completely opposite men was joyful, playful, and enduring. It is the very essence of the success of the storytelling. Such good writing.

I see that I'm very late to the party and I have three more books in this series and I hope for many many more. I also have high hopes of a tv series or (gasp!) a movie. What say you, Michael?

Highly recommended.

*Revised to upgrade my rating to 4.95 Stars.

cantdrive55's review

Go to review page

mysterious medium-paced
  • Plot- or character-driven? Plot
  • Strong character development? No

3.75

avidreadergirl1's review

Go to review page

4.0

Actually 3.75 stars for this book. Rarely do I give such high mark to first books in a series but this one was fun and fast paced while avoiding many of the faults of cozy mystery.
In this first book, Dan, a Londoner suffering a burnout, an Alan, former teacher turned author, join forces to elucidate a mystery set in motion during a visit at a local café. Dan, being used to a fast-paced life, is a bit discombobulated when he arrives at his sister’s house in Devonshire and Alan, his friendly neighbor, keen on finding inspiration for his new book are both intrigued by a coded inscription on a stone slab shown to them in a cafe in town. Throughout this fast-paced adventure, they face the wrath of the family that owns the stone that sends both men on a quest to discover the truth and the truth comes out in the end.