bmariem's review against another edition
Spoiler
Oscar dies and doesn’t come back and there’s no third book to fix it!Spoiler
etinney's review against another edition
4.0
Like the first book, The Eternal Sea is MUCH better than it sounds like. I found that I couldn't stop reading it, which is weird for me when the book is mostly about a love triangle. So I have come up with three reasons why this might be possible:
1. Frazier is a good writer: Frazier is able to mix romance and adventure well, which is rare these days. She doesn't make me want to puke at the romance! Whoa! Also, I actually like that Camille understands that Randall is a good guy. Usually, you have the girl in love with the broody guy and she totally ignores the good guy. And although Oscar was the broody guy, the fact that he died at the end was a nice plot twist from the norm. Also can I mention that Randall was a sexy badass at times?? He kisses her, and she says to stop, and he looks at her like, I'm not even sorry. That just made me crack up.
2. I have finally accepted that stories about romance can be good reads: Although Twilight and Fallen kind of destroy this theory, I have read enough good romance books to *reluctantly* accept that I would actually enjoy a book where romance is a key component in the plot. However, there has to be a badass fight scene in there. I am not, nor will I ever be, a Nicholas Sparks girl.
3. I'm turning into a teenage girl: DARN YOU HORMONES!!! AHHHHHH why do I picture a man sweeping me off my feet, URGHHHHHHHHHHHHHH
*deep breath, Erin*
Okay, moving on. There were a couple of things I didn't like. First, IRA WAS GONE. Why is it that during the sequel of my favorite books, my favorite character dies or disappears for some/most of the book??? Next, I still don't like that her dad was still not resurrected. I know that's one of the points of the novel, but it still was annoying to me.
Overall: 3.75 out of 5 stars
Cover: I like this better than the first cover, and the art is nice.
1. Frazier is a good writer: Frazier is able to mix romance and adventure well, which is rare these days. She doesn't make me want to puke at the romance! Whoa! Also, I actually like that Camille understands that Randall is a good guy. Usually, you have the girl in love with the broody guy and she totally ignores the good guy. And although Oscar was the broody guy, the fact that he died at the end was a nice plot twist from the norm. Also can I mention that Randall was a sexy badass at times?? He kisses her, and she says to stop, and he looks at her like, I'm not even sorry. That just made me crack up.
2. I have finally accepted that stories about romance can be good reads: Although Twilight and Fallen kind of destroy this theory, I have read enough good romance books to *reluctantly* accept that I would actually enjoy a book where romance is a key component in the plot. However, there has to be a badass fight scene in there. I am not, nor will I ever be, a Nicholas Sparks girl.
3. I'm turning into a teenage girl: DARN YOU HORMONES!!! AHHHHHH why do I picture a man sweeping me off my feet, URGHHHHHHHHHHHHHH
*deep breath, Erin*
Okay, moving on. There were a couple of things I didn't like. First, IRA WAS GONE. Why is it that during the sequel of my favorite books, my favorite character dies or disappears for some/most of the book??? Next, I still don't like that her dad was still not resurrected. I know that's one of the points of the novel, but it still was annoying to me.
Overall: 3.75 out of 5 stars
Cover: I like this better than the first cover, and the art is nice.
catcervone's review against another edition
3.0
Some of this book was really great, and other parts seemed to have plot holes and unanswered questions. The ending didn’t seem like a good ending to me, whether it was a “happy ending” or not. I will say that I accidentally picked this book up not knowing it was the second of a series, but the author did a good job catching the reader up to speed.
shadyglade's review against another edition
3.0
A worthy sequel to the original. Kept the same level of action, characterizations, romance, and adventure of the first. And it still didn't hit a strong chord with me either. It was good, enough to keep me going, and I will probably read another if she does a 3rd book with these characters. Not one of my favorites, but not bad either.
I know lots of people who have loved this one (and its prequel) so I encourage you to give them at least a try. For some reason they just didn't hit with me.
I know lots of people who have loved this one (and its prequel) so I encourage you to give them at least a try. For some reason they just didn't hit with me.
lil_starz33's review against another edition
2.0
2.5 stars
Am I really that hard to please lately? This is the second book that I've read recently that is a sequel to a great first book that appeared to be a stand-alone book. I enjoyed the first one and was satisfied with the ending. There was no need to make a sequel, and I fear there will be a third book to follow. All of the things I enjoyed about the first one are practically non-existent in this one.
Additionally, all of the characters act differently in this book. For example, Oscar spends almost the whole book pushing Camille away and being a jerk. Samuel spends the whole book being a jerk as well and I thought his "secret" was so obvious. I knew what he was going to do at the end the whole time (not exactly, but the concept). Ira is missing for the whole book, but he seems to have changed from a dangerous card shark to a protective teddy bear.
Camille has her own set of issues now that she can't decide between Randall & Oscar. Randall is now painted as this fabulous, loving guy that she never knew existed. Maggie, a new character, is wholly obnoxious and annoying, especially when she refuses to tell Camille anything about the stones.
The journey was the best part, but seemed drawn out, like Camille and co. couldn't catch a break. Then the whole journey turned out to be for no reason, unless there is a third book and she goes to the next spot on the map, which at this point, I don't really want to read about.
Am I really that hard to please lately? This is the second book that I've read recently that is a sequel to a great first book that appeared to be a stand-alone book. I enjoyed the first one and was satisfied with the ending. There was no need to make a sequel, and I fear there will be a third book to follow. All of the things I enjoyed about the first one are practically non-existent in this one.
Additionally, all of the characters act differently in this book. For example, Oscar spends almost the whole book pushing Camille away and being a jerk. Samuel spends the whole book being a jerk as well and I thought his "secret" was so obvious. I knew what he was going to do at the end the whole time (not exactly, but the concept). Ira is missing for the whole book, but he seems to have changed from a dangerous card shark to a protective teddy bear.
Camille has her own set of issues now that she can't decide between Randall & Oscar. Randall is now painted as this fabulous, loving guy that she never knew existed. Maggie, a new character, is wholly obnoxious and annoying, especially when she refuses to tell Camille anything about the stones.
The journey was the best part, but seemed drawn out, like Camille and co. couldn't catch a break. Then the whole journey turned out to be for no reason, unless there is a third book and she goes to the next spot on the map, which at this point, I don't really want to read about.
rakesrogues's review
4.0
Review Overview:
Romance, fantasy, historical, and adventure all packed into one novel
Starts off with a bang
Delicious romance
Fantastic sequel that will not disappoint fans of Everlasting
Note: I read an insanely early version of this novel.
This is the last book that I got to read for the lovely editor I worked with at Scholastic before the end of my internship. I also read Everlasting during this internship, which I absolutely adored so I jumped at the chance when my editor offered me to read it. At the time, THE ETERNAL SEA was known to me and Angie as #thebookwithoutaname because it was only known as Everlasting #2 while Angie and the editors tried to come up with a title.
I love Everlasting and THE ETERNAL SEA because it combines so many different genres that I enjoy. THE ETERNAL SEA definitely packs romance, fantasy, historical, and adventure all into one novel. Everything was escalated in the sequel! It had been a while since I read Everlasting, but THE ETERNAL SEA does a great job in catching up where the story left of. It can be read by itself, if one truly wishes, but I think you’ll miss out on the build-up to the foundation of Camille and Oscar’s relationship – an important thing to understand when reading the sequel. THE ETERNAL SEA started out with a bang and kept it going all the way through. The novel is fast-paced and I couldn’t put it down. The magic in this book, in my opinion, is elevated onto a whole new level. It is a lot more complex and we, as readers, learn more about the story behind the stones.
I think the best part of this book is the love triangle that emerges. I am 100% Team Oscar, but the drama between Oscar, Randall, and Camille was just too delicious. Camille definitely gets her share of attention in this book. The frustration jumps right of the page to the point where I want to rip my hair out and scream, “WHY?!” I love the chemistry between Oscar and Camille. It’s definitely one of the top reasons why I love the book.
To me, the book will always be known as Eventide. It was one of the title suggestions that Angie gave her editor, which I absolutely loved. THE ETERNAL SEA won out in the end – which is still a pretty good name. I give THE ETERNAL SEA a rating of four stars. I truly enjoyed the book, but I hated how the ending left me hanging with a bittersweet feeling. (Can’t say more… wouldn’t want spoilers!)
Romance, fantasy, historical, and adventure all packed into one novel
Starts off with a bang
Delicious romance
Fantastic sequel that will not disappoint fans of Everlasting
Note: I read an insanely early version of this novel.
This is the last book that I got to read for the lovely editor I worked with at Scholastic before the end of my internship. I also read Everlasting during this internship, which I absolutely adored so I jumped at the chance when my editor offered me to read it. At the time, THE ETERNAL SEA was known to me and Angie as #thebookwithoutaname because it was only known as Everlasting #2 while Angie and the editors tried to come up with a title.
I love Everlasting and THE ETERNAL SEA because it combines so many different genres that I enjoy. THE ETERNAL SEA definitely packs romance, fantasy, historical, and adventure all into one novel. Everything was escalated in the sequel! It had been a while since I read Everlasting, but THE ETERNAL SEA does a great job in catching up where the story left of. It can be read by itself, if one truly wishes, but I think you’ll miss out on the build-up to the foundation of Camille and Oscar’s relationship – an important thing to understand when reading the sequel. THE ETERNAL SEA started out with a bang and kept it going all the way through. The novel is fast-paced and I couldn’t put it down. The magic in this book, in my opinion, is elevated onto a whole new level. It is a lot more complex and we, as readers, learn more about the story behind the stones.
I think the best part of this book is the love triangle that emerges. I am 100% Team Oscar, but the drama between Oscar, Randall, and Camille was just too delicious. Camille definitely gets her share of attention in this book. The frustration jumps right of the page to the point where I want to rip my hair out and scream, “WHY?!” I love the chemistry between Oscar and Camille. It’s definitely one of the top reasons why I love the book.
To me, the book will always be known as Eventide. It was one of the title suggestions that Angie gave her editor, which I absolutely loved. THE ETERNAL SEA won out in the end – which is still a pretty good name. I give THE ETERNAL SEA a rating of four stars. I truly enjoyed the book, but I hated how the ending left me hanging with a bittersweet feeling. (Can’t say more… wouldn’t want spoilers!)
readeradventure's review
4.0
If you read my review of the first book you know that I really enjoyed the characters in that book, this book was no different! I liked delving back into this world and getting to know the characters even better, as well as meeting new ones!
The plot of this book was full of action and adventure, I was kept on my toes wondering what was going to happen next and how it was going to end. Even though most of the book takes place on a ship it wasn’t boring or mundane like it could have been.
I have two words for you, LOVE TRIANGLE. There was a definite love triangle in this book but I think it was done better than in many other books. Camille’s reasons for being torn were valid and I found myself switching back and forth with who she should be with. (OSCAR)
The only problem I had with this book was that I wish the mythology had been gone into more. While it was gone into more than in the first book I found myself craving even a little more.
Overall a good book and I hope there is going to be another book because I was not satisfied with that ending!
The plot of this book was full of action and adventure, I was kept on my toes wondering what was going to happen next and how it was going to end. Even though most of the book takes place on a ship it wasn’t boring or mundane like it could have been.
I have two words for you, LOVE TRIANGLE. There was a definite love triangle in this book but I think it was done better than in many other books. Camille’s reasons for being torn were valid and I found myself switching back and forth with who she should be with. (OSCAR)
The only problem I had with this book was that I wish the mythology had been gone into more. While it was gone into more than in the first book I found myself craving even a little more.
Overall a good book and I hope there is going to be another book because I was not satisfied with that ending!
More...