daniell's review
4.0
Collins masterfully intersects accessibility, wit, and meaning.
Accessibility
There are no complex forms or strange words used in this book. There are no high conceits, no metaphysics, and no experiences depicted that a given reader might not know themselves.
Collins anchors his subjects in concrete objects and accompanying verbs. Abstraction and stillness are two ways to make poetry suck, and he consistently avoids both.
The downside of accessibility is that it indicates Poetry for Everybody, and near-universal conceits are not always desirable. Those with few objectors deserve scrutiny; beware the entertainer, the enchanter, the hypnotist.
Wit
To wit, here's an example of concrete objects and accompanying verbs, my favorite poem from this work, also a fine example of his wit.
Hangover
If I were crowned emperor this morning,
every child who is playing Marco Polo
in the swimming pool of this motel,
shouting the name Marco Polo back and forth
Marco Polo Marco Polo
would be required to read a biography
of Marco Polo-a long one with fine print-
as well as a history of China and of Venice,
the birthplace of the venerated explorer
Marco Polo Marco Polo
after which each child would be quizzed
by me then executed by drowning
regardless how much they managed
to retain about the glorious life and times of
Marco Polo Marco Polo
Collins is not always this funny, but his wit comes out in ways similar to this throughout this book, though in a less-pronounced way.
Meaning
Poetic meaning can be found when a poet's presented experience reduplicates the reader's similar experience. The theme of this book is, as the title suggests, various takes on death. Death may not seem to relate to his subjects immediately, but even those playing Marco Polo in a hotel pool replicate a kind of Hell-of-repetition for the prisoner narrator. Other topics include ancestors (Poem on the Three Hundredth Anniversary of the Trinity School) and progeny (My Unborn Children), both of which are easily considered by anyone ("What of those before? What of those to come?").
If I hadn't already returned this book I would do more explication.
Alas, it is for naught, and like Collins' subjects this review must too taste death. Horoscopes for the Dead is easily worth the price of admission; consider this a recommendation.
Accessibility
There are no complex forms or strange words used in this book. There are no high conceits, no metaphysics, and no experiences depicted that a given reader might not know themselves.
Collins anchors his subjects in concrete objects and accompanying verbs. Abstraction and stillness are two ways to make poetry suck, and he consistently avoids both.
The downside of accessibility is that it indicates Poetry for Everybody, and near-universal conceits are not always desirable. Those with few objectors deserve scrutiny; beware the entertainer, the enchanter, the hypnotist.
Wit
To wit, here's an example of concrete objects and accompanying verbs, my favorite poem from this work, also a fine example of his wit.
Hangover
If I were crowned emperor this morning,
every child who is playing Marco Polo
in the swimming pool of this motel,
shouting the name Marco Polo back and forth
Marco Polo Marco Polo
would be required to read a biography
of Marco Polo-a long one with fine print-
as well as a history of China and of Venice,
the birthplace of the venerated explorer
Marco Polo Marco Polo
after which each child would be quizzed
by me then executed by drowning
regardless how much they managed
to retain about the glorious life and times of
Marco Polo Marco Polo
Collins is not always this funny, but his wit comes out in ways similar to this throughout this book, though in a less-pronounced way.
Meaning
Poetic meaning can be found when a poet's presented experience reduplicates the reader's similar experience. The theme of this book is, as the title suggests, various takes on death. Death may not seem to relate to his subjects immediately, but even those playing Marco Polo in a hotel pool replicate a kind of Hell-of-repetition for the prisoner narrator. Other topics include ancestors (Poem on the Three Hundredth Anniversary of the Trinity School) and progeny (My Unborn Children), both of which are easily considered by anyone ("What of those before? What of those to come?").
If I hadn't already returned this book I would do more explication.
Alas, it is for naught, and like Collins' subjects this review must too taste death. Horoscopes for the Dead is easily worth the price of admission; consider this a recommendation.
compass_rose's review
2.0
Not my favorite of his collections. No poems even come close (for me) to those in [b:Picnic, Lightning|137110|Picnic, Lightning (Pitt Poetry Series)|Billy Collins|http://photo.goodreads.com/books/1172087928s/137110.jpg|132141]
bonnabelle's review
3.0
collins is definitely a talented writer, but i think his subject matter just doesn't suit me well. i can appreciate how smoothly the poems read but it's hard for a line to really grab me like some of my favorites do.
kristyreads's review
fast-paced
2.0
I’ll just say I’m still relatively new to poetry but this did not work for me like at all. The poems were shallow at best and where was the humor that was touted? Because I didn’t find it. Definitely not a poet for me.
everybody_h8s_k8's review
emotional
funny
hopeful
reflective
relaxing
fast-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? A mix
- Strong character development? N/A
- Loveable characters? Yes
- Diverse cast of characters? N/A
- Flaws of characters a main focus? It's complicated
4.0
beth_francine's review
3.0
I have always admired Collins' talent to become nothing into poetry. But, in this case, they were just too many pieces that fall out of purpose. I felt disconnected from the majority part of the book because of this.
nicolec417's review
4.0
Collins' poetry surprises me. He can capture so much in so little; I'm usually left smiling or shaking my head after each poem.
aschurtz's review
emotional
reflective
fast-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? N/A
- Strong character development? N/A
- Loveable characters? N/A
- Diverse cast of characters? N/A
- Flaws of characters a main focus? N/A
3.25
fieldofhats's review
funny
lighthearted
mysterious
medium-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? N/A
- Strong character development? N/A
- Loveable characters? N/A
- Diverse cast of characters? N/A
- Flaws of characters a main focus? N/A
4.5
Billy Collins does not miss. I don’t think it’s possible for him to write a poetry collection that isn’t absolutely amazing. The only reason this isn’t a solid 5-star rating is because I put it into perspective with The Trouble With Poetry and Musical Tables, both of which are (in my opinion) just a little better than this one.
This collection felt just as raw and real as other things I’ve read by him, but with a hint of impending mortality. The theme of death is subtly pervasive throughout the collection (as are ducks, for some reason), but he plays with mortality and makes it something more than just death. Absolutely solid collection, please read Billy Collins if you haven’t, he’s one of the best poets of the modern age.
This collection felt just as raw and real as other things I’ve read by him, but with a hint of impending mortality. The theme of death is subtly pervasive throughout the collection (as are ducks, for some reason), but he plays with mortality and makes it something more than just death. Absolutely solid collection, please read Billy Collins if you haven’t, he’s one of the best poets of the modern age.