Reviews

Duke of Midnight by Elizabeth Hoyt

bookdragon85's review against another edition

Go to review page

  • Loveable characters? Yes

5.0

mvbookreviewer's review against another edition

Go to review page

5.0

Duke of Midnight is the 6th book in the Maiden Lane series and by far my most favorite. Towards the end of Lord of Darkness, the 5th book, once again Elizabeth Hoyt makes a startling revelation, perhaps the most astonishing one at that since the series began. The identity of the 3rd Ghost of St. Giles, this time someone who is more driven by his own personal vengeance against those that had done him and his family wrong, a member of the nobility, not to mention a member of the Parliament itself; Maximus Batten, the Duke of Wakefield.

Readers who have had their run ins with Maximus in previous books in the series would have been hard pressed not to be intrigued by all that he is. Projecting a cold and formidable front, the Duke of Wakefield is someone who seems to be as straitlaced as they come, his utter dislike or perhaps even hatred for gin and makers of gin something that is known all over the country. While Maximus works hard to push through relevant laws that could tackle with gin making, something which he believes most passionately is the core reason behind the decay of society, at night, Maximus dons the mask and costume of the Ghost and traipses through the worst of slums in London, in the hopes of finding clues that would lead him to the villain he has been pretty much searching for a major part of his adult life.

Artemis Greaves is a character that came into prominence through the introduction of her beautiful cousin Lady Penelope Chadwicke into series, for whom Artemis is companion to. Lady Penelope is someone who wants nothing but the best for herself. Thus, determined to have Maximus as her husband, Penelope embarks upon the quest with much fervor, which does earn her the attention of Maximus in his usual cool, aloof and calculated manner. There is no joy in a transaction which Maximus believes suites him rather well. There is no fire that burns in him to possess Lady Penelope, unlike Artemis her companion who makes him want to go into hiding with her by his side and forget the whole world.

Artemis gets under his skin without Maximus knowing of it, their interludes during the quiet hours of the morning on his estate grounds something that pricks and prods at him until his emotions are tangled up in need for none but Artemis. But Artemis is one with her own agenda to push forward. Someone who is ready to do anything for the freedom of the one man for whom she would lay down her whole life for, even if it means enlisting, bribing or even coercing the help of the powerful Duke himself to do so.

There are multiple reasons why Duke of Midnight ended up being my favorite of the series. For anyone who knows of my reading tastes, I am someone who is drawn to dark characters, a bit ruthless and driven by needs that they cannot control when it comes to the heroine in question, no matter how hard they may try. Maximus was that hero for me from the Maiden Lane series. Brought up to take his rightful role as the Duke, the responsibilities of being one are thrust upon him at a tender age when both his parents get killed. Maximus has to grow up overnight without having time to properly grow into the duties required of him. Thus makes Maximus a hard man, a man who is principled, a man who often times comes off as cold, aloof and removed from the rest of the world, an image that serves him well most times.

Maximus is also the only Ghost of St. Giles who actively continues his training for the role, having turned part of his home into a training facility where he subjects himself to grueling hours of training so that he is one lethal machine of brawn, intelligence and strong will, focused on getting to the truth behind the murders of his beloved parents and making those responsible pay.

That strong ironclad will of Maximus was something that I admired and bemoaned over in equal doses. There is something quite alluring about a man who knows his own mind, well, for that matter I love a woman who knows her own mind as well – but with Maximus, him being my favorite hero in the series, I am allowed to be a little biased. The fact that his attraction and want for Artemis clouds all his senses does not make him give up on what he has planned for his life, but rather, he wants Artemis on his terms, as hard headed and stubborn it makes him. But the beauty of it when it comes to heroes who are strong minded comes in their submission to the greater force of love for the heroine, which is an aspect I enjoyed in Duke of Midnight. The moments of jealousy which overtakes Maximus during the heady encounters with Artemis, the ones that makes him go all “mine” with sheer possessiveness – those were the moments I reveled in.

Artemis is a heroine who shone equally bright in the story. With a future that looked bleak, with nothing to her name but the goodwill of an uncle who took her in, Artemis’s determination to work against the odds nevertheless, to prove the innocence of her brother was something that resonated deep within me. Even her burgeoning feelings for the Duke is something Artemis is willing to sacrifice in order to see to it that her beloved brother is removed from Bedlam, where he is rotting away into an existence that would prove to be the death of him, sooner rather than later.

I believe that Artemis is the best fit for someone with such powerful emotions and desires as Maximus. She is able to get through to him in a way that no one else can, her ability to read him so effectively being a quality of utmost importance given how easily he can don on a mask that would show to to the rest of the world that nothing touches him, when in fact things deeply do. Artemis dares him to show to her that side of his that few would ever see – the one without the artifice that society dictates he wears whenever he goes out and about. That for me, was the beauty behind the union between Artemis and Maximus when all was said and done.

Loved it all, which is why I would recommend this book with the whole of my heart!

Rating = 4.75/5

For more reviews and quotes, please visit, www.maldivianbookreviewer.com

desertlover's review against another edition

Go to review page

4.0

Like the majority of my book friends, this has been my favorite of the series thus far. Artemis was everything I appreciate in a heroine.

felizas's review against another edition

Go to review page

lighthearted medium-paced
  • Plot- or character-driven? Character
  • Strong character development? It's complicated
  • Loveable characters? It's complicated
  • Diverse cast of characters? It's complicated
  • Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes

3.5

tiffany_sostar's review against another edition

Go to review page

Almost forced myself to finish this just so I could give it 0.25 stars. I do not come to romance books for misogyny, homophobia and sexual assault. The scene at 35% in the prison was so disgustingly violent and unnecessary. What the actual fuck. First and absolutely the last time I will touch anything by this author. Romance can be such a joyful and liberatory genre, but this is absolutely not it. 

Expand filter menu Content Warnings

julie2525's review against another edition

Go to review page

3.0

Action & Adventure, Class Difference/Forbidden Romance, Off-Limits Friend

Max (Maximus Batten, Duke of Wakefield), is looking for a wife who meets simple and strict parameters: rich, beautiful, and not particular inquisitive. He scours St. Giles at night, looking for the person who killed his parents, so a simple woman who is ideal. He finds his vapid woman. He also find her female companion, Artemis, who doesn't miss a thing and is quite the huntress herself. [Insert romance.] Her past is complicated. His past is complicated. He doesn't know what he wants. There's quite a bit of sneaking around and action.

tak_everlasting's review against another edition

Go to review page

1.5

reviewing this so i can remember that i don't read elizabeth hoyt bc a) sexism and b) high frequency of sexual assault victims + that topic not being handled well (the SA isn't an issue in this book... i mean, there is one thing but the fmc thinks it's hot so i guess that's fine then. at least it's not the canon abuse recovery plot. but also the mmc kept calling the fmc "diana", i guess because her name was artemis?? even in serious conversations. i was not convinced that he knew her actual name. also refusing to marry your love interest because of "pride" in a time period where doing that makes them a complete social outcast is always a black mark in my book. stand up for her, or get out of the ring. this is a romance book i didn't sign up for this halfassery. i'd prefer the classic regency novel "oh no! i'm being hunted by a murderer!" plot to this lukewarm take. he absolutely does not have the right to say he loves her if he's treating her like this.)

genniegee's review against another edition

Go to review page

5.0

I have eagerly awaited the Duke of Wakefield's book, and it did not disappoint. Artemis is the perfect mate for Maximus and the tale Ms. Hoyt spins is enthralling. I for one cannot not wait for the next installment (there will be one, right?!?). Asa and Apollo need to find their match, plus I'd love to see Phoebe find the one. Also, I'm interested in Penelope's fate :)

haithar's review against another edition

Go to review page

adventurous emotional hopeful mysterious fast-paced
  • Plot- or character-driven? A mix
  • Strong character development? Yes
  • Loveable characters? Yes
  • Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes

5.0

I loveeeeeeed it, I couldn't stop reading it. I didn't think Maximus's story would draw me in like this BUT I ATE IT UP. I am ecstatic over this book, both the hero and heroine are so bitey with each other I am feral for it. Georgian Batman storyline was perfection.

lizzie_reads_books's review against another edition

Go to review page

3.5

I really enjoyed this dynamic and thought the story was fun. I wish he got a little more from the hero as he was just brooding and that was his story line but oh well.