Scan barcode
gothicvamperstein's review against another edition
2.0
I liked the illustrations and the fact that it has the message about not being selfish, but the end had me a bit confused.
briarsreviews's review against another edition
3.0
It's MY Tree by Olivier Tallec has one of the cutest and most amusing covers I've seen in a while, and we haven't even gotten into the story yet!
This little squirrel has a tree and it's HIS tree, don't be mistaken. He loves his tree very, very, very, very much, especially since it produces pine cones which he also loves. He comes to the realize that someone might one day want his tree for their own, and that is just horrifying! Especially when curiosity and further greed takes over him...
There isn't much of a lesson in here. I was really hoping he'd learn to share or something, instead of just seeing tons more squirrels and trees. I saw some potential there, but I also love educational books with themes. This book is just a cute book that could be a conversation after. Without a resolution to the problem of greed, I'm not sure where this story was going other than showing a greedy squirrel.
I love the illustrations! They are goofy, colourful and quite charming. Honestly, it's one of my favourite so far this year. It's quirky and definitely attracts my attention.
The plot gets one star, but the illustrations get five. So, I shall meet in the middle with three pine cone shaped stars!
Thank you to NetGalley and Kids Can Press for providing me a free copy of this book in exchange of an honest review.
This little squirrel has a tree and it's HIS tree, don't be mistaken. He loves his tree very, very, very, very much, especially since it produces pine cones which he also loves. He comes to the realize that someone might one day want his tree for their own, and that is just horrifying! Especially when curiosity and further greed takes over him...
There isn't much of a lesson in here. I was really hoping he'd learn to share or something, instead of just seeing tons more squirrels and trees. I saw some potential there, but I also love educational books with themes. This book is just a cute book that could be a conversation after. Without a resolution to the problem of greed, I'm not sure where this story was going other than showing a greedy squirrel.
I love the illustrations! They are goofy, colourful and quite charming. Honestly, it's one of my favourite so far this year. It's quirky and definitely attracts my attention.
The plot gets one star, but the illustrations get five. So, I shall meet in the middle with three pine cone shaped stars!
Thank you to NetGalley and Kids Can Press for providing me a free copy of this book in exchange of an honest review.
booktiamo's review against another edition
4.0
A great little story about sharing and appreciating what you've got! Perfect for children! Cute pictures too!
smorrison4's review against another edition
4.0
I requested and received an e-ARC of this book from NetGalley and Kids Can Press in exchange for my honest review.
This was a fun story about a squirrel who thinks that the tree he is currently eating pinecones from is his tree and only his tree. Although the tree has more than enough pinecones to go around the squirrel starts to imagine how he can protect his tree. He imagines building a giant wall that surrounds his tree and once the imaginary wall is built all he can think about are the possible trees on the other side and what he is missing out on.
This story provides a great start to conversations about greed, sharing, and FOMO.
This was a fun story about a squirrel who thinks that the tree he is currently eating pinecones from is his tree and only his tree. Although the tree has more than enough pinecones to go around the squirrel starts to imagine how he can protect his tree. He imagines building a giant wall that surrounds his tree and once the imaginary wall is built all he can think about are the possible trees on the other side and what he is missing out on.
This story provides a great start to conversations about greed, sharing, and FOMO.
annarau's review against another edition
4.0
Hilarious illustrations and an important message, a short whimsical read. Without guidance, the message may be a tad advanced for young readers, but if parents use this book to start a conversation about property and greed it would be great.
luftschlosseule's review against another edition
4.0
This is my tree! Mine alone! Nobody dare touch it!
This is not what I thought it'd be. It was better.
See, there is this neurotic squirrel that thinks about their tree. It's beautiful, comfy, a companion and a food source. They think about how to protect their tree from all the other forest animals, because this is the best tree every and surely everybody wants a taste. But what, exactly, would that entail?
Did not see the ending coming at all.
The illustrations are in very beautiful wood colours that give slightly autumnic vibes. Now I want to go and feel bark under my fingers.
I recieved a copy of this book in exchange for an honest review.
This is not what I thought it'd be. It was better.
See, there is this neurotic squirrel that thinks about their tree. It's beautiful, comfy, a companion and a food source. They think about how to protect their tree from all the other forest animals, because this is the best tree every and surely everybody wants a taste. But what, exactly, would that entail?
Did not see the ending coming at all.
The illustrations are in very beautiful wood colours that give slightly autumnic vibes. Now I want to go and feel bark under my fingers.
I recieved a copy of this book in exchange for an honest review.
youngdi's review against another edition
lighthearted
medium-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? A mix
- Strong character development? No
- Loveable characters? No
- Diverse cast of characters? No
- Flaws of characters a main focus? It's complicated
2.0
etienne02's review against another edition
5.0
That was a good one. I like the art, the humor of it and it as a good morale about possessing thing and how it can become overwhelming and that sharing and enjoying might be better. I really like it!
jmadey's review against another edition
3.0
**ARC provided by Kids Can Press from NetGalley**
A squirrel is very devoted to his tree and the pinecones it produces. He first worries if other people might decide it is "their" tree, so he brainstorms ways he can keep others away. But in doing so, he then worries about what other trees might be out there, and if they might be better than HIS tree.
I think the lesson here is that one should be thankful for what one has, but I think the message falls short at the end, as the squirrel presumably goes off in search of other trees. The illustrations are great, which is why I gave this book 3 stars instead of 2.
A squirrel is very devoted to his tree and the pinecones it produces. He first worries if other people might decide it is "their" tree, so he brainstorms ways he can keep others away. But in doing so, he then worries about what other trees might be out there, and if they might be better than HIS tree.
I think the lesson here is that one should be thankful for what one has, but I think the message falls short at the end, as the squirrel presumably goes off in search of other trees. The illustrations are great, which is why I gave this book 3 stars instead of 2.
smcgurren's review
4.0
Thank you #NetGalley for the free review copy of #ItsMyTree
I initially requested this book because of the cute cover picturing a fun character. In my role as a second grade teacher, I also look for stories with a message to readers. I was hopeful that a this story would be about greed or sharing.
Overall, this is a great story that children will love. The main character was hilarious and someone that readers will find funny. The illustrations were fantastic and the balance of words and pictures per page was perfect. The only thing that I would have changed was the ending, which came quite abruptly and left the reader to infer that the character learned his lesson. I would have liked the character to express his loneliness, admit his mistake, and then join the other animals on the other side of his wall. This ultimately lead to me giving the book four stars instead of five.
I initially requested this book because of the cute cover picturing a fun character. In my role as a second grade teacher, I also look for stories with a message to readers. I was hopeful that a this story would be about greed or sharing.
Overall, this is a great story that children will love. The main character was hilarious and someone that readers will find funny. The illustrations were fantastic and the balance of words and pictures per page was perfect. The only thing that I would have changed was the ending, which came quite abruptly and left the reader to infer that the character learned his lesson. I would have liked the character to express his loneliness, admit his mistake, and then join the other animals on the other side of his wall. This ultimately lead to me giving the book four stars instead of five.
More...