readhikerepeat's review against another edition
5.0
Reviewed at The Book Wheel.
I’ve read two books by Meg Wolitzer – The Wife and The Interestings. One I loved, the other I was underwhelmed by. Her latest, The Female Persuasion, was the book that would tip the scales on how I feel about her books and wow, did she convert me into a fan.
In addition to being a great story, The Female Persuasion had my mind doing mental flip flops on what it means to be a woman in today’s world, how much we internalize the normalization of a male-dominated society, and how we all equally contribute to the success and failures of feminism and other women, generally speaking. It is a story of relationships between women – comfort, friendship, implicit and explicit competition (even between those who love each other and want what’s best for each other) and it is amazing.
The book starts out with Greer meeting a Gloria Steinem-like feminist icon named Faith in her first year of college. Shy, studious, and not one to make waves, Greer is instantly drawn to Faith. But because she in the midst of the phase of self-discovery that only comes to us in our late teens, Greet sets off to chart her own path, oblivious to how Faith will shape her life. The rest of the book tells the story of how this encounter irrevocably changes her life. Over the next ten years, we see Greer falter and thrive in both her personal and professional lives. Faith plays a major part in this and has a hold on every fiber of Greer’s being, though neither seems to be aware of the depths of her power.
But more than the story itself, this is a book that really made me question what I know about feminism. It touches on the realities of date rape, guilt, and societal pressures. It delves into how gender can dominate and change the dynamics of the workplace. It highlights the struggles young women face when they are sent into the world; a world where societal and social structures set you up to fail.
What really got me, however, was how much it made me think about the intersection of privilege and feminism. There are so many strong women in this book, and all come from a different background and have different dreams pushing them forward. But what was most obvious to me was the differences in how they acknowledged the privilege (or lack thereof) their upbringings and situations gave them.
One rhetorical conversation I had with myself after finishing the book went like this: I want equality but benefit from privilege. To acknowledge this privilege is difficult because that requires that I continuously make an effort to combat it. But isn’t that, in a way, combatting my very being because that privilege is what helped make me the way I am? Does denying it mean denying myself? Can you ever really escape yourself, even when your goals are worthy? Does intent outweigh the past or do we all, like Wolitzer says, have a “degree of awfulness” in us? At what point do we focus on daily sexism versus upending the entire system, and to what extent are they interrelated? How can someone who wants to do both elevate the voices of those who are truly marginalized, and at what point is elevating that voice co-opting them? How do we do better and does anyone ever get it right?
I don’t know the answers to these questions, but they do force me (and the reader) to take a hard look at what their personal views of feminism are. Are we someone who publicly rages against the forces that keep women down while silently accepting the life we get to live as a result? Or are we doing everything we can by leveraging our privilege to make it better for those who don’t have a voice that is being heard? Or are we someone who, like Greer, is unable to see our own privilege (and who gets to decide that?), and how destructive can that be?
I also found myself wondering about what it means to be lonely. Does being strong and independent mean being lonely? Does a crusade leave room for others in your life? Faith, for example, was incredibly desired, but was she was fulfilled? I felt there was a sadness to her that contrasted with Greer’s fearful optimism and was left wondering whether you can be both admired and fulfilled. Or, does the constant demand to do more for others preclude personal contentment? And how much of this self-sacrifice is worth it, or does it matter so long as the person doing it feels fulfilled? And what is fulfillment, anyway?
Like I said. It raised some questions, which is why I think you should read it and ask your own.
I’ve read two books by Meg Wolitzer – The Wife and The Interestings. One I loved, the other I was underwhelmed by. Her latest, The Female Persuasion, was the book that would tip the scales on how I feel about her books and wow, did she convert me into a fan.
In addition to being a great story, The Female Persuasion had my mind doing mental flip flops on what it means to be a woman in today’s world, how much we internalize the normalization of a male-dominated society, and how we all equally contribute to the success and failures of feminism and other women, generally speaking. It is a story of relationships between women – comfort, friendship, implicit and explicit competition (even between those who love each other and want what’s best for each other) and it is amazing.
The book starts out with Greer meeting a Gloria Steinem-like feminist icon named Faith in her first year of college. Shy, studious, and not one to make waves, Greer is instantly drawn to Faith. But because she in the midst of the phase of self-discovery that only comes to us in our late teens, Greet sets off to chart her own path, oblivious to how Faith will shape her life. The rest of the book tells the story of how this encounter irrevocably changes her life. Over the next ten years, we see Greer falter and thrive in both her personal and professional lives. Faith plays a major part in this and has a hold on every fiber of Greer’s being, though neither seems to be aware of the depths of her power.
But more than the story itself, this is a book that really made me question what I know about feminism. It touches on the realities of date rape, guilt, and societal pressures. It delves into how gender can dominate and change the dynamics of the workplace. It highlights the struggles young women face when they are sent into the world; a world where societal and social structures set you up to fail.
What really got me, however, was how much it made me think about the intersection of privilege and feminism. There are so many strong women in this book, and all come from a different background and have different dreams pushing them forward. But what was most obvious to me was the differences in how they acknowledged the privilege (or lack thereof) their upbringings and situations gave them.
One rhetorical conversation I had with myself after finishing the book went like this: I want equality but benefit from privilege. To acknowledge this privilege is difficult because that requires that I continuously make an effort to combat it. But isn’t that, in a way, combatting my very being because that privilege is what helped make me the way I am? Does denying it mean denying myself? Can you ever really escape yourself, even when your goals are worthy? Does intent outweigh the past or do we all, like Wolitzer says, have a “degree of awfulness” in us? At what point do we focus on daily sexism versus upending the entire system, and to what extent are they interrelated? How can someone who wants to do both elevate the voices of those who are truly marginalized, and at what point is elevating that voice co-opting them? How do we do better and does anyone ever get it right?
I don’t know the answers to these questions, but they do force me (and the reader) to take a hard look at what their personal views of feminism are. Are we someone who publicly rages against the forces that keep women down while silently accepting the life we get to live as a result? Or are we doing everything we can by leveraging our privilege to make it better for those who don’t have a voice that is being heard? Or are we someone who, like Greer, is unable to see our own privilege (and who gets to decide that?), and how destructive can that be?
I also found myself wondering about what it means to be lonely. Does being strong and independent mean being lonely? Does a crusade leave room for others in your life? Faith, for example, was incredibly desired, but was she was fulfilled? I felt there was a sadness to her that contrasted with Greer’s fearful optimism and was left wondering whether you can be both admired and fulfilled. Or, does the constant demand to do more for others preclude personal contentment? And how much of this self-sacrifice is worth it, or does it matter so long as the person doing it feels fulfilled? And what is fulfillment, anyway?
Like I said. It raised some questions, which is why I think you should read it and ask your own.
minty's review against another edition
3.0
There seems to be a trend lately, where books have to be sweeping in scope and tell the story of several characters, when really I think they would be better served to focus on only the main character, or maybe one other. The chapters about the boyfriend and the friend in Chicago dragged for me, and I kept wondering if I could fast-forward them without missing anything (I could have). Overall, the writing is great but this book was too long, and ended too preachy and pat.
onecrab's review against another edition
3.0
It was a pleasant enough read, but honestly it's perfectly forgettable. It reminded me a bit of A Painted House (John Grisham) in that it meanders through the characters lives, and also of Tomorrow, and Tomorrow, and Tomorrow (Gabrielle Zevin) without being as good as the books I just referenced.
The audiobook was well narrated by Rebecca Lowman.
The audiobook was well narrated by Rebecca Lowman.
roguedaffodil's review against another edition
challenging
hopeful
inspiring
reflective
medium-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? A mix
- Strong character development? Yes
- Loveable characters? It's complicated
- Diverse cast of characters? Yes
- Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes
5.0
emilybark02's review against another edition
adventurous
emotional
hopeful
inspiring
slow-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? A mix
- Strong character development? Yes
- Loveable characters? It's complicated
- Diverse cast of characters? Yes
- Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes
2.5
ozziemarie's review against another edition
4.0
While this wasn’t necessarily insightful or profound, I really enjoyed the stories and themes throughout it.
akc3318's review against another edition
emotional
hopeful
reflective
medium-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? A mix
- Strong character development? Yes
- Loveable characters? Yes
- Diverse cast of characters? No
- Flaws of characters a main focus? It's complicated
4.0
bbblomst's review against another edition
emotional
hopeful
inspiring
reflective
slow-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? A mix
- Strong character development? Yes
- Loveable characters? Yes
- Diverse cast of characters? No
- Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes
4.0
Content Warnings
Moderate: Child death, Drug use, and Sexual assault