Scan barcode
skumbanaan's review against another edition
adventurous
fast-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? Plot
- Strong character development? It's complicated
- Loveable characters? It's complicated
- Diverse cast of characters? It's complicated
- Flaws of characters a main focus? No
3.0
alivaster's review against another edition
2.0
I was immensely disappointed in this book. It should really be a one star, but was not a complete failure of a book. I wasn't pleased at all with how everything was thrown together. It seemed like a lot of mashed up ideas into one book and different interesting aspects showed up and were gone without much explanation. Plus, she takes away our two favorite characters from the war at hand and it really wasn't necessary to do. Not only did it take them away from the action, nothing really big or important happened in the god realm. You had the introduction of the cute little darklings, but those things could have easily happened even if she was there fighting in the war effort. Moving the book from the mortal realm to the god realm took the book from high level of interest and action (skinners) to it becoming boring and immensely slow-paced (stuck for days in parent's cabin) in comparison. The book builds up to this big war, but we see pretty much none of it. Just really disappointing.
kathydavie's review against another edition
4.0
Fourth and last in the Immortals fantasy adventure series for children revolving around Daine, a wielder of the wild magic. If you like to read an author's series in order, start with Alanna: The First Adventure in the Song of the Lioness series or explore the chronological listing of the Tortall books on my website.
My Take
Oh, I do adore Tamora Pierce's stories! Great characters with fantastic adventures that emphasize kindness and consideration for others.
In this installment, the war is pressing hard on Tortall until kindness turns the tide. And the focus of all this kindness is Daine.
I found it odd that the gods saw Daine's kindnesses as meddling. That they thought her actions created trouble and disorder. I don't see that. I'm also thinking I'd better read through the Protector of the Small series because the choices the gods give Daine here don't seem to match up with what I read in the Daughter of the Lioness series. So, now I'm curious…
I did enjoy Daine's response to Numarin's proposal of marriage! Hee-hee…
The Story
The barriers mages put in place to keep the immortals in another plane collapses one night — the final blow by the old emperor mage, Orzone. When the emperor's mages opened the gates between realms some years ago, the barrier attempted to compensate, but it weakened. Now there is nothing to protect mortals from giants, stormwings, griffins, basilisks, tauroses, Coldfangs, ogres, hurroks, centaurs, winged horses, or unicorns.
Stormwing Orzone has quickly learned to use his stormwing magic and now has spies everywhere. The kingdom can't continue to fight against Orzone and his allies forever, especially when the enemy seems to know what they're doing before they do! But its his Skinners that tilt the action, for it encourages Daine's parents to help their daughter, leading to a great many adventures in the realms of the gods and unexpected alliances.
Alliances that will tip the balance in a number of unexpected directions. And that will cause the Gods to force an unwelcome, irrevocable decision about Daine.
The Characters
Veralidaine "Daine" Sarrasri is gifted with the wild magic which enables her to speak to and shapeshift into any animal. With the kingdom of Tortall under attack, Daine is asking all her animal friends to help in its defense. She also meets her dad, the god of the hunt Weiryn when he and her mother, Sarra Beneksri, the Green Lady, rescue her and Numarin from the Skinners.
Rattail from the Long Lake Pack shows up to help Daine in the Divine Realms. Even Tkaa the basilisk and Kitten, a.k.a., Skysong, the baby dragon have duties in saving the kingdom. Diamondflame is Kitten's many-times great-grandfather while Wingstar is her grandmother and, luckily, both are feeling quite indebted to Daine for her care of Skysong.
Badger is joined by Broad Foot, a duckmole, in aiding Daine and Numarin to get to the Dragonlands across the Sea of Sand. Queenclaw is a house cat goddess with all of a cat's characteristics! In some of her dreams, Daine watches the gods fight the Chaos Queen: the Black God; the Great Mother Goddess, Sir Alanna's personal contact; Kidunka, the world snake and lord of the Banjiku tribes; Wave Walker; Thief; Smith; the K'miri gods of storms and fire; and, Mithros. Gainel is the Dream God.
Numair Salmalín is King Jon's wizard and he and Daine are in constant demand throughout the kingdom throwing off magical attacks. Jonathan of Conté, king of Tortall, and his Queen Thayet have large cameo roles; Jon makes good use of the Dominion Jewel in this war (see Lioness Rampant) while Thayet goes to battle with her Riders. Sir Alanna as the King's Champion, Sir Raoul of the King's Own, Buri of the Queen's Riders are all fighting. Onua, Daine's first Tortallan friend, also fights at the king's side. Lord Imrah is the ruler of the beseiged fief of Legann.
Queen Barzha of the Stone Tree nation and her mate Hebakh are free of Orzone's cage due to Daine, but Queen Jachull of the Mortal Fear nation and most of the stormwings have allied with Orzone. Lucky for Daine and Numair that these stormwings provide some much-needed aid to repay the debt. Lord Rikash Moonsword serves Barzha and is friendly with Daine. From Rikash we learn how the stormwings, half-metal, half-human immortal birds, were created.
Orzone was the emperor of Carthak and a very powerful mage. Skills he uses to more quickly learn how to use his stormwing power. Yup, ol' Orzone got transformed into a stormwing at the end of Emperor Mage! He's determined to take down Daine and Numarin. Skinners are a nasty creation that destroys absolutely anything they touch. Darkings are cute little creatures; we'll encounter them again in Trickster's Queen. In this story, we meet Gold-streak, Jelly, Leaf, and Inkblot.
Inar Hadensra is an incredibly powerful mage, partly through the plucking out of an eye and the insertion of a huge, magic ruby; he's also an ally of Orzone. Uusoae is the Queen of Chaos. She has allied herself with Orzone and is breaking the rules laid down by Mother Flame and Father Universe.
The Cover and Title
It's another faded-out Russian lacquer box style with leafy pillars on either side of the cover, centaurs flanking the title at the top, and a narrow plaque at the bottom for the author's name. All framing a blanketed Daine clutching her badger's tooth with Kitten and her many-greats-grandfather, Diamondflame, surrounding her with Badger cuddling in at the bottom right.
The title is where most of the action takes place, in The Realms of the Gods.
My Take
Oh, I do adore Tamora Pierce's stories! Great characters with fantastic adventures that emphasize kindness and consideration for others.
In this installment, the war is pressing hard on Tortall until kindness turns the tide. And the focus of all this kindness is Daine.
I found it odd that the gods saw Daine's kindnesses as meddling. That they thought her actions created trouble and disorder. I don't see that. I'm also thinking I'd better read through the Protector of the Small series because the choices the gods give Daine here don't seem to match up with what I read in the Daughter of the Lioness series. So, now I'm curious…
I did enjoy Daine's response to Numarin's proposal of marriage! Hee-hee…
The Story
The barriers mages put in place to keep the immortals in another plane collapses one night — the final blow by the old emperor mage, Orzone. When the emperor's mages opened the gates between realms some years ago, the barrier attempted to compensate, but it weakened. Now there is nothing to protect mortals from giants, stormwings, griffins, basilisks, tauroses, Coldfangs, ogres, hurroks, centaurs, winged horses, or unicorns.
Stormwing Orzone has quickly learned to use his stormwing magic and now has spies everywhere. The kingdom can't continue to fight against Orzone and his allies forever, especially when the enemy seems to know what they're doing before they do! But its his Skinners that tilt the action, for it encourages Daine's parents to help their daughter, leading to a great many adventures in the realms of the gods and unexpected alliances.
Alliances that will tip the balance in a number of unexpected directions. And that will cause the Gods to force an unwelcome, irrevocable decision about Daine.
The Characters
Veralidaine "Daine" Sarrasri is gifted with the wild magic which enables her to speak to and shapeshift into any animal. With the kingdom of Tortall under attack, Daine is asking all her animal friends to help in its defense. She also meets her dad, the god of the hunt Weiryn when he and her mother, Sarra Beneksri, the Green Lady, rescue her and Numarin from the Skinners.
Rattail from the Long Lake Pack shows up to help Daine in the Divine Realms. Even Tkaa the basilisk and Kitten, a.k.a., Skysong, the baby dragon have duties in saving the kingdom. Diamondflame is Kitten's many-times great-grandfather while Wingstar is her grandmother and, luckily, both are feeling quite indebted to Daine for her care of Skysong.
Badger is joined by Broad Foot, a duckmole, in aiding Daine and Numarin to get to the Dragonlands across the Sea of Sand. Queenclaw is a house cat goddess with all of a cat's characteristics! In some of her dreams, Daine watches the gods fight the Chaos Queen: the Black God; the Great Mother Goddess, Sir Alanna's personal contact; Kidunka, the world snake and lord of the Banjiku tribes; Wave Walker; Thief; Smith; the K'miri gods of storms and fire; and, Mithros. Gainel is the Dream God.
Numair Salmalín is King Jon's wizard and he and Daine are in constant demand throughout the kingdom throwing off magical attacks. Jonathan of Conté, king of Tortall, and his Queen Thayet have large cameo roles; Jon makes good use of the Dominion Jewel in this war (see Lioness Rampant) while Thayet goes to battle with her Riders. Sir Alanna as the King's Champion, Sir Raoul of the King's Own, Buri of the Queen's Riders are all fighting. Onua, Daine's first Tortallan friend, also fights at the king's side. Lord Imrah is the ruler of the beseiged fief of Legann.
Queen Barzha of the Stone Tree nation and her mate Hebakh are free of Orzone's cage due to Daine, but Queen Jachull of the Mortal Fear nation and most of the stormwings have allied with Orzone. Lucky for Daine and Numair that these stormwings provide some much-needed aid to repay the debt. Lord Rikash Moonsword serves Barzha and is friendly with Daine. From Rikash we learn how the stormwings, half-metal, half-human immortal birds, were created.
Orzone was the emperor of Carthak and a very powerful mage. Skills he uses to more quickly learn how to use his stormwing power. Yup, ol' Orzone got transformed into a stormwing at the end of Emperor Mage! He's determined to take down Daine and Numarin. Skinners are a nasty creation that destroys absolutely anything they touch. Darkings are cute little creatures; we'll encounter them again in Trickster's Queen. In this story, we meet Gold-streak, Jelly, Leaf, and Inkblot.
Inar Hadensra is an incredibly powerful mage, partly through the plucking out of an eye and the insertion of a huge, magic ruby; he's also an ally of Orzone. Uusoae is the Queen of Chaos. She has allied herself with Orzone and is breaking the rules laid down by Mother Flame and Father Universe.
The Cover and Title
It's another faded-out Russian lacquer box style with leafy pillars on either side of the cover, centaurs flanking the title at the top, and a narrow plaque at the bottom for the author's name. All framing a blanketed Daine clutching her badger's tooth with Kitten and her many-greats-grandfather, Diamondflame, surrounding her with Badger cuddling in at the bottom right.
The title is where most of the action takes place, in The Realms of the Gods.
iorangi's review against another edition
adventurous
emotional
funny
fast-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? Character
- Strong character development? Yes
- Loveable characters? Yes
- Diverse cast of characters? Yes
- Flaws of characters a main focus? It's complicated
4.0
annashiv's review against another edition
2.0
Maybe 2.5 stars.
Something went very wrong with this one. I only enjoyed the all too brief moments between Daine and Numair. There was hardly any real use of Daine's gift, and the story is poor overall. It just felt very off. I think the overall plot would have been better stretched over a few more books.
It also needed an editor. All through this series, I've spotted simple spelling/grammar mistakes and with this one, an editor for the plotting and pacing would have really helped. I assume they wanted to get it out on a deadline but they should have delayed it to really give this series an ending it deserved.
Ultimately I just had to power through the last 80 pages or so only paying half attention. There are too many characters, very few stakes that felt important. Somehow I was just led to not care about what happened to anyone in the final battle, which is strange cause I've loved them in the previous books already. I think I'll just prefer to pretend this doesn't exist for the most part. If I ever pick up the series again, future self, don't read this one. Not worth it. Just be content with the ending of the third and make up your own stuff.
Something went very wrong with this one. I only enjoyed the all too brief moments between Daine and Numair. There was hardly any real use of Daine's gift, and the story is poor overall. It just felt very off. I think the overall plot would have been better stretched over a few more books.
It also needed an editor. All through this series, I've spotted simple spelling/grammar mistakes and with this one, an editor for the plotting and pacing would have really helped. I assume they wanted to get it out on a deadline but they should have delayed it to really give this series an ending it deserved.
Ultimately I just had to power through the last 80 pages or so only paying half attention. There are too many characters, very few stakes that felt important. Somehow I was just led to not care about what happened to anyone in the final battle, which is strange cause I've loved them in the previous books already. I think I'll just prefer to pretend this doesn't exist for the most part. If I ever pick up the series again, future self, don't read this one. Not worth it. Just be content with the ending of the third and make up your own stuff.
_aoibheann_'s review against another edition
adventurous
emotional
hopeful
fast-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? A mix
- Strong character development? Yes
- Loveable characters? Yes
- Diverse cast of characters? Yes
- Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes
1.0
lizlang15's review against another edition
adventurous
medium-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? Plot
- Strong character development? Yes
- Loveable characters? Yes
- Diverse cast of characters? Yes
- Flaws of characters a main focus? No
4.0
jenhurst's review against another edition
4.0
I still really enjoyed this series, but after rereading them as an adult, they aren’t my favourites. As a kid I loved that Daine could talk to animals but as an adult it seemed a little too childish to me. Daine just isn’t my favourite protagonist of Tamora Pierce’s for me anymore and even as a kid Numair as the love interest is weird to me.
sgreen2307's review against another edition
5.0
Amazing...loved how she was able to see her parents again after everything she'd been through. Her and NUmair finally get together which is awesome.