Scan barcode
smuttymcbookface's review against another edition
3.5
The writing and relationships from Sarah J Maas are, as always, enthralling. I love that she always keeps you guessing about who will end up with who, and why little scenes were thrown in for seemingly no reason.
My biggest gripes about this book were:
- Everything just seemed to work out. Sure there were intricate plans and such, but ultimately they just mucked around with them last minute because why not
- Lysandra's big scenewhere she murdered Arobynn could have happened at any time. She slept beside him so often. And I get that it was conveniently timed for Aelin, but it seemed so anticlimatic.
- The power of the characters seemed to be dependent on how exciting it would be for them to be weak. Aelin alone? Able to kill valgs like nothing. Rowan AND Aedion AND Lorcan? Struggling to kill Valgs. But suddenlyLysandra gets her shifting powers and she's able to clear what these three struggled with? Similarly, the "I have no power left" then "Whoops, destroyed all of this" happened too frequently as well.
- Not all plots are equal. I found myself bored reading some of the chapters, just waiting to get back. I also hated that I was kept with cliffhangers within the same book until I got back to plots.
My biggest gripes about this book were:
- Everything just seemed to work out. Sure there were intricate plans and such, but ultimately they just mucked around with them last minute because why not
- Lysandra's big scene
- The power of the characters seemed to be dependent on how exciting it would be for them to be weak. Aelin alone? Able to kill valgs like nothing. Rowan AND Aedion AND Lorcan? Struggling to kill Valgs. But suddenly
- Not all plots are equal. I found myself bored reading some of the chapters, just waiting to get back. I also hated that I was kept with cliffhangers within the same book until I got back to plots.
erineluebbers's review against another edition
adventurous
tense
medium-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? A mix
- Strong character development? Yes
- Loveable characters? Yes
- Diverse cast of characters? Yes
- Flaws of characters a main focus? It's complicated
4.0
er_inreads's review against another edition
5.0
this book was the turning point for my absolute inhaling of the rest of the series. I read this book in 2 days and absolutely loved every damn second. Lorcan and his blinded love, chaol and nessryns love hate relationship with aelin, aedion and aelins reintroduction. Manon. If I had to read one over again and only that one, it would be this one. LYSANDRA. I never thought I’d could ever love her. She’s now one of my absolute favourite characters, ever. I wanted to strangle Darrow though
eveeisenhower's review against another edition
adventurous
dark
emotional
hopeful
mysterious
tense
fast-paced
5.0
hanahf's review against another edition
adventurous
emotional
tense
medium-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? A mix
- Strong character development? Yes
- Loveable characters? Yes
- Diverse cast of characters? Yes
- Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes
4.0
aw_reads's review against another edition
4.0
Queen of Shadows is a much needed tonal shift following HOF. This is the book that genuinely showcases Aelin’s skills in achieving her goals in grand fashion. Her upbringing as an assassin aids her well in her quest to not only obtain the next Wyrdkey but to also execute her much awaited revenge plot against Arobynn.
Throughout the first part of the book, Aelin devises a trap for Arobynn and in the midst of it all, she also plans the rescue of her cousin, Aedion. The rescue has a bit of a heist aura to it that was really entertaining. I wish it had been drawn out a little more, but at least we finally got to experience Aelin and Aedion’s reunion, which is one of the more touching moments of the series so far.
While I thoroughly enjoyed her cleverness and proficiency in navigating the seedy underworld of Rifthold, the readers aren’t necessarily privy to Aelin’s thoughts and subsequent actions. We mostly experience the aftermath of Aelin’s plotting (like all the other secondary characters), so much so that at a certain point it feels like Aelin’s pulling all these tricks out of her hat, and we as the audience, weren’t even aware we were at a magic show. I appreciate a good surprise, but when there are so many, it feels as if the character is invincible.
On another note, a subtle triumph of this book is Aelin’s complete acceptance of her name and identity. Not only does she refer to herself as Aelin, she also wishes now to be addressed as such, which is telling enough of how much her motivations have changed since book one.
I generally enjoyed the direction of Aelin’s character arc, but there were still some questionable moments in her development, mainly in her handling of Dorian. Though she claims to be good friends with the prince, her hasty decision to execute him upon learning of his Valg-induced predicament says otherwise. She doesn’t even try to think of ways to save him until someone else tells her there may be a way. I’ve never been in love with Aelin, but this was the first time that I have actively disliked her. And in many instances, I found myself agreeing with Chaol’s observations of her poor choices.
Which brings me to my next point: I am deeply unappreciative of Chaol’s character assassination. I understand that his lapse in judgement and poor behavior in this book is a part of his larger character arc, but it’s also obvious that Maas felt the need to completely destroy him as a love interest for Aelin now that she has Rowan. It’s such a manipulative way of shifting readers’ affections and I’m not here for it. In fact, even though I disliked how Chaol treated Aelin, I couldn’t allow myself to fully hate him for it. We’ve gotten to personally know Chaol from the past three books and up until QOS, he’s never been a mean person. And so his sudden maliciousness towards Aelin feels contrived.
Chaol isn’t a bad character, at least not to me. He may be dull, but he’s also flawed. And even though he’s handling the changes in his life ungracefully in this book, I can’t fault him for stumbling to cope and gradually realize the new circumstances of his lifestyle.
Aelin and Chaol’s fallout (unsurprisingly) gives life to Aelin and Rowan’s romantic relationship. QOS did manage to soften my severe dislike toward Rowan but I still don’t love him as a character, mostly because I find him boring. His and Aelin’s interactions in this book helped paint Rowan in a much more favorable light as a sympathetic, humorous, and affectionate creature if he so chooses. I’m still not invested in their romance, because it feels forced on some level, but at least I understand and support the healing nature of their connection.
One of the best things about this book, I think, is the generous number of female characters. No longer is Aelin the sole bearer of female empowerment. In QOS we are introduced to Lysandra, a crafty and compassionate courtesan; Nesryn, a skilled archer and loyal friend to Chaol; and Elide, a brave and resourceful young lady that happens to be physically handicapped. All these characters are such wonderful portraits of strength and versatility, and each have intriguing stories to tell. The only character that deserves more depth is Nesryn, only because she mostly serves as a romantic placeholder for Chaol.
Manon continues to be my favorite of the bunch, however, and her chapters are always some of the most enjoyable. She and Asterin shine in this book as Manon begins to question her position and purpose in life, and Asterin challenges Manon to see a new truth and consider the possibility of walking a different path separate from the Valg and Matron Blackbeak.
I may disagree with some of the character and plot choices in QOS, but I believe this may be my favorite book of the series. I really enjoyed Aelin’s revisit to her assassin roots, and the tone of the book proves to be much more exciting and plot driven than the first three books. It feels like the story is finally moving forward and the characters are as well. I’m still no fan of Maas’s writing style, but I could look past it well enough in this book. The ending is bombastic and entertaining, and the rest of the book is just as fast-paced and thrilling throughout.
Throughout the first part of the book, Aelin devises a trap for Arobynn and in the midst of it all, she also plans the rescue of her cousin, Aedion. The rescue has a bit of a heist aura to it that was really entertaining. I wish it had been drawn out a little more, but at least we finally got to experience Aelin and Aedion’s reunion, which is one of the more touching moments of the series so far.
While I thoroughly enjoyed her cleverness and proficiency in navigating the seedy underworld of Rifthold, the readers aren’t necessarily privy to Aelin’s thoughts and subsequent actions. We mostly experience the aftermath of Aelin’s plotting (like all the other secondary characters), so much so that at a certain point it feels like Aelin’s pulling all these tricks out of her hat, and we as the audience, weren’t even aware we were at a magic show. I appreciate a good surprise, but when there are so many, it feels as if the character is invincible.
On another note, a subtle triumph of this book is Aelin’s complete acceptance of her name and identity. Not only does she refer to herself as Aelin, she also wishes now to be addressed as such, which is telling enough of how much her motivations have changed since book one.
I generally enjoyed the direction of Aelin’s character arc, but there were still some questionable moments in her development, mainly in her handling of Dorian. Though she claims to be good friends with the prince, her hasty decision to execute him upon learning of his Valg-induced predicament says otherwise. She doesn’t even try to think of ways to save him until someone else tells her there may be a way. I’ve never been in love with Aelin, but this was the first time that I have actively disliked her. And in many instances, I found myself agreeing with Chaol’s observations of her poor choices.
Which brings me to my next point: I am deeply unappreciative of Chaol’s character assassination. I understand that his lapse in judgement and poor behavior in this book is a part of his larger character arc, but it’s also obvious that Maas felt the need to completely destroy him as a love interest for Aelin now that she has Rowan. It’s such a manipulative way of shifting readers’ affections and I’m not here for it. In fact, even though I disliked how Chaol treated Aelin, I couldn’t allow myself to fully hate him for it. We’ve gotten to personally know Chaol from the past three books and up until QOS, he’s never been a mean person. And so his sudden maliciousness towards Aelin feels contrived.
Chaol isn’t a bad character, at least not to me. He may be dull, but he’s also flawed. And even though he’s handling the changes in his life ungracefully in this book, I can’t fault him for stumbling to cope and gradually realize the new circumstances of his lifestyle.
Aelin and Chaol’s fallout (unsurprisingly) gives life to Aelin and Rowan’s romantic relationship. QOS did manage to soften my severe dislike toward Rowan but I still don’t love him as a character, mostly because I find him boring. His and Aelin’s interactions in this book helped paint Rowan in a much more favorable light as a sympathetic, humorous, and affectionate creature if he so chooses. I’m still not invested in their romance, because it feels forced on some level, but at least I understand and support the healing nature of their connection.
One of the best things about this book, I think, is the generous number of female characters. No longer is Aelin the sole bearer of female empowerment. In QOS we are introduced to Lysandra, a crafty and compassionate courtesan; Nesryn, a skilled archer and loyal friend to Chaol; and Elide, a brave and resourceful young lady that happens to be physically handicapped. All these characters are such wonderful portraits of strength and versatility, and each have intriguing stories to tell. The only character that deserves more depth is Nesryn, only because she mostly serves as a romantic placeholder for Chaol.
Manon continues to be my favorite of the bunch, however, and her chapters are always some of the most enjoyable. She and Asterin shine in this book as Manon begins to question her position and purpose in life, and Asterin challenges Manon to see a new truth and consider the possibility of walking a different path separate from the Valg and Matron Blackbeak.
I may disagree with some of the character and plot choices in QOS, but I believe this may be my favorite book of the series. I really enjoyed Aelin’s revisit to her assassin roots, and the tone of the book proves to be much more exciting and plot driven than the first three books. It feels like the story is finally moving forward and the characters are as well. I’m still no fan of Maas’s writing style, but I could look past it well enough in this book. The ending is bombastic and entertaining, and the rest of the book is just as fast-paced and thrilling throughout.
tayyerey's review against another edition
adventurous
dark
mysterious
medium-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? A mix
- Strong character development? Yes
- Loveable characters? Yes
- Diverse cast of characters? Yes
- Flaws of characters a main focus? It's complicated
5.0
jesschevarie's review against another edition
adventurous
challenging
dark
emotional
hopeful
tense
fast-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? A mix
- Strong character development? Yes
- Loveable characters? It's complicated
- Diverse cast of characters? Yes
- Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes
5.0