menniemenace's review against another edition
4.0
Yay, science!
I really like Sam Kean. He's the first science writer I've read. I love his books. This may be my least favorite one, though. It's still good, Just not the best.
I enjoy the poetic quality of this book. It's pretty romantic. I also feel so future-y reading about space colonization (let's take a moment to remember that imperialism sucks) and environmental engineering. I liked the puns and history stuff.
This book also has some WWII stuff. Can any book ever not get into the A-bomb? This is a challenge I'm planning to do; find a non-fiction that does not mention WWII at all in any of its facets.
I really like Sam Kean. He's the first science writer I've read. I love his books. This may be my least favorite one, though. It's still good, Just not the best.
I enjoy the poetic quality of this book. It's pretty romantic. I also feel so future-y reading about space colonization (let's take a moment to remember that imperialism sucks) and environmental engineering. I liked the puns and history stuff.
This book also has some WWII stuff. Can any book ever not get into the A-bomb? This is a challenge I'm planning to do; find a non-fiction that does not mention WWII at all in any of its facets.
airclay3's review against another edition
4.0
Scientifically, this book is 5 stars! I learned so much and I love the way the science was explained, especially because it felt accessible even to me who isn’t a chemist or physicist and yet has a science background!
Personally, as a woman in science and engineering, this book was 2 stars. The only time women were mentioned was as wives (and the fact that I can’t remember any particular examples really demonstrates no scientific principle discussed in this book was told from the woman inventor/ discoverer/ scientist. I didn’t notice the gender gap as much when I was younger. It’s mainly been since starting grad school that I have started to feel more annoyed and upset about it, and this book has really set me off, much like the American Chemical Society “Chemists with Disabilities” posters hanging at my university which only portray men.
I think there were a lot of commas missing.
Personally, as a woman in science and engineering, this book was 2 stars. The only time women were mentioned was as wives (and the fact that I can’t remember any particular examples really demonstrates no scientific principle discussed in this book was told from the woman inventor/ discoverer/ scientist. I didn’t notice the gender gap as much when I was younger. It’s mainly been since starting grad school that I have started to feel more annoyed and upset about it, and this book has really set me off, much like the American Chemical Society “Chemists with Disabilities” posters hanging at my university which only portray men.
I think there were a lot of commas missing.
smitch29's review against another edition
informative
5.0
I was surprised by how much I enjoyed this. The narration was solid, and the story itself was well written. I got this audiobook on a whim and it paid off. I am not especially interested in chemistry or our atmosphere, and yet I enjoyed the lessons and history and trivia that was well balanced in this book. I'm sure I'll listen to this story again sometime, and I will probably check out more from this author.
kblincoln's review against another edition
5.0
I'm a hardcore Sam Kean fan-girl, so you'll be hard pressed to find any criticism in this latest installment of science-for-the-masses, this time about Air: or more accurately, the history of humans isolating gasses and using them as tools.
It's just that he writes the scientists as utterly human, and that he sneaks in some snarky humor here and there, and then ends up with actually quite weighty observations about the relationship of humans to the natural world.
"Like Caesar's last breath, that history surrounds you every second: every time the wind comes clattering through the trees, or a hot-air balloon soars overhead, or an unaccountable smell of lavender or peppermint or even flatulence wrinkles your nose, you're awash in it. Put your hand in front of your mouth again and feel it: we can capture the world in a single breath."
And Sam Kean does love breadth of history. He takes us through the creation of the earth's atmosphere, atomic testing on bikini atoll, and the scientists who vied for isolating gasses.
Here's a peek at the quiet humor in his description of Rayleigh and Ramsay discovering Argon:
"...so they exposed it to oxygen, hydrogen, and carbon dioxide. Nothing happened. They tried feistier compounds like sulfur, phosphorus, and potassium. All duds. They tried chlorine and acids and other horrors. It didn't blink."
But the weightiest conclusion, and politically timely as I write this in the first year of a presidency completely against environmental regulations and climate-change deniers to boot, is that in regards to human effect on climate change.
"For me, climate engineering-- taking deliberate steps to cool our atmosphere-- seems like the only realistic solution...given that laziness and shortsightedness have dominated our behavior in the past, I don't see why they won't dominate our behavior in the future as well. I don't mean to sound gloomy about human beings-- some of my best friends are people. But we have our flaws, and trying to deal with climate change exposes the worst of them. In contrast, coming up with a technological fix for the problem, while not easy, exploits what humans do well-- rally around a cause when things get desperate, then start building shit."
So for historical looks at the ways human societies-- and individual scientist personalities-- shape the way humans do science, coupled with some practical and humorous observations, you really can't beat Sam Kean. This book is no exception. Open your eyes to the air and go read this book.
It's just that he writes the scientists as utterly human, and that he sneaks in some snarky humor here and there, and then ends up with actually quite weighty observations about the relationship of humans to the natural world.
"Like Caesar's last breath, that history surrounds you every second: every time the wind comes clattering through the trees, or a hot-air balloon soars overhead, or an unaccountable smell of lavender or peppermint or even flatulence wrinkles your nose, you're awash in it. Put your hand in front of your mouth again and feel it: we can capture the world in a single breath."
And Sam Kean does love breadth of history. He takes us through the creation of the earth's atmosphere, atomic testing on bikini atoll, and the scientists who vied for isolating gasses.
Here's a peek at the quiet humor in his description of Rayleigh and Ramsay discovering Argon:
"...so they exposed it to oxygen, hydrogen, and carbon dioxide. Nothing happened. They tried feistier compounds like sulfur, phosphorus, and potassium. All duds. They tried chlorine and acids and other horrors. It didn't blink."
But the weightiest conclusion, and politically timely as I write this in the first year of a presidency completely against environmental regulations and climate-change deniers to boot, is that in regards to human effect on climate change.
"For me, climate engineering-- taking deliberate steps to cool our atmosphere-- seems like the only realistic solution...given that laziness and shortsightedness have dominated our behavior in the past, I don't see why they won't dominate our behavior in the future as well. I don't mean to sound gloomy about human beings-- some of my best friends are people. But we have our flaws, and trying to deal with climate change exposes the worst of them. In contrast, coming up with a technological fix for the problem, while not easy, exploits what humans do well-- rally around a cause when things get desperate, then start building shit."
So for historical looks at the ways human societies-- and individual scientist personalities-- shape the way humans do science, coupled with some practical and humorous observations, you really can't beat Sam Kean. This book is no exception. Open your eyes to the air and go read this book.
rlse's review against another edition
5.0
Read during Greatest Week Ever: Branson!
The last Sam Kean I read was [b:The Disappearing Spoon: And Other True Tales of Madness, Love, and the History of the World from the Periodic Table of the Elements|7247854|The Disappearing Spoon And Other True Tales of Madness, Love, and the History of the World from the Periodic Table of the Elements|Sam Kean|https://images.gr-assets.com/books/1438018063s/7247854.jpg|8246153] which was very nugget worthy, but I didn’t remember being as biting and hilarious as this book. Not far into starting this, I decided to re-borrow the library ebook as the kindle edition because I didn’t want to miss out on being able to come back to the notes and highlights of the funny prose. My apologies to all my GWE 2018 friends who kept getting knowledge bombed with tidbits from this book as I worked through it!
The last Sam Kean I read was [b:The Disappearing Spoon: And Other True Tales of Madness, Love, and the History of the World from the Periodic Table of the Elements|7247854|The Disappearing Spoon And Other True Tales of Madness, Love, and the History of the World from the Periodic Table of the Elements|Sam Kean|https://images.gr-assets.com/books/1438018063s/7247854.jpg|8246153] which was very nugget worthy, but I didn’t remember being as biting and hilarious as this book. Not far into starting this, I decided to re-borrow the library ebook as the kindle edition because I didn’t want to miss out on being able to come back to the notes and highlights of the funny prose. My apologies to all my GWE 2018 friends who kept getting knowledge bombed with tidbits from this book as I worked through it!
spinnerroweok's review against another edition
4.0
An interesting investigation into our atmosphere.
kahawa's review against another edition
4.0
This was great, better than I expected. Sam Kean is a surprisingly clever and witty author. Lots of science and history.
wynter's review against another edition
5.0
When I picked up Sam Kean's new book on air, I knew I was going to learn about the molecular structure of air and the permanence of these molecules in the history of our planet. What I didn't expect was a thorough study of everything that can possibly relate to the element. I learned about weather-making, atomic bomb testing, first balloon flights, radioactivity of bananas, Roswell incident, life on other planets, and much more. I'm a complete nerd for trivia, and now I'm just bursting to unleash all I absorbed from this book onto unsuspecting public. Good stuff!