Reviews

Witchbane by Amy Sumida

jj7twin's review against another edition

Go to review page

4.0

Still not a Polyamorus romance.

Book five out of the original 9 books and Seren has one boyfriend. Not three like she could have if she'd get with the program just one. I definitely don't like this series as much as The Godhunter books. I can see how others would but this series is too heavy on the serious tones and less on the humor aside from Killian's quips with Seren. Maybe its just these fairies are too serious. Also still not a fan of human looking Raza being bronze rather than midnight black like Tyrese Gibson. Feels like a choice when most of the main men in your stories are not a darker brown in the human world. Look up "hot dark skinned black men shirtless" if you don't know how to describe nipple color and once you're done drooling, write him into a story. Very excited for the next book in the GH series. With this series I'm honestly just reading to see how it goes. Its an okay journey and I want to see where it goes but if I stopped now I also wouldn't be upset.

caromalfe's review against another edition

Go to review page

5.0

Perfect

It was perfect, as the others before it, but it was a little bittersweet regarding the romance business. It it so well written that util Seren doesn’t explain her reasons to make the choices that she make, you as a reader cannot decide who to cheer for. The suitors for once and the family for other. To be human or Fay?

ndfootballgrl33's review against another edition

Go to review page

3.0

Meh

So far, this has been my least favorite book in this series. I still enjoy the overall story, but I just felt that Seren didn't really do much in this book other than focus on the whole "who should I love" dilemma. I may be in the minority here, but I am not a fan of Raza. The only thing I do like about him is that he doesn't try to keep Seren from making her own decisions. I DO like Killian, however, and look forward to seeing where that goes.

I will say that I really hate the way that the Tiernan situation has panned out in this book. IMO, Seren deserved it considering Danu has saved her ass many times now. Not to mention, she acts like an indignant child more often than not.

Additionally, these books could all do with a bit more editing, and would benefit from some POV back and forth. I read a review a while back were someone said that this author tells us what is happening rather than "showing" us, and I feel that that individual was spot on. If we had some of the story from someone else's POV, it would really help keep it from being so one-sided. Especially when it comes to the guys.

jadeshea's review

Go to review page

4.0

Seren is now after her uncle and his evil wife. They've crossed too many lines, and now they are in the Human Realm trying to mess things up there.

But, when Seren's adopted father ends up being taken things get even more complicated for Seren. Add in the fact that her boyfriend is also giving her problems, and she has no idea how to deal with all of this. But, King Raza makes an appearance and is there for her, but so is a new friend she made along the way.

This one was a great addition to this series, and I really liked it. I totally hate Seren's boyfriend though, he about drove me up the wall in this one. And I'm not sure I would forgive him if I was here.

But, the book was good, and it had a lot of drama, but also some sadness for Seren as well.

And while I'm kind of hoping this one turns out to be reverse-harem, it's looking like it won't turn out that way.

Now, I must impatiently wait for more.

bee995's review

Go to review page

5.0

Yes Raza, Boo Tiernan, Killian?

This book doing disappoint at all. I'm loving the crazy relatives and the drama Seren has to put up with all the time. Seen feels a little immature at times but then she isn't that old really and has had her whole life thrown upside down so I'm starting to forgive her on that.

SPOILERS
#
#
#
#
#
#
Thank Danu that Raza is finally a thing! I love him so much, and while I did like Tiernan I've completely gone off him.. I also really love Killian though and I'm hoping that Seven gives him a chance. I actually think him and Raza have a lot in common and would like each other if they tried! Super excited for the next!

misseli's review

Go to review page

5.0

I really really love these books.

I have officially become Team Raza, which shouldn’t be that big of a surprise. He is romantic and all about Seren.

Idk what it is but Tiernan is a complete dick so I highly hope they don’t get back together.
More...