alexperc_92's review against another edition
5.0
one of the best graphic novels I've read! The art is majestic!
mx_madster's review against another edition
5.0
If you like Fae, Angels, Demons, and fabulous art, read this. As soon as possible. I'll be buying a copy.
morgan_haybook's review against another edition
4.0
I was really impressed with the way each story fit together. Usually I don't enjoy books with collaborators. It was a fun book to read. Fantastic art.
misssusan's review against another edition
4.0
i liked this! except the ending; didn't think much of it. idk, the whole ~dark~ twist ending has gotten so popular it's just boring and predictable now, like
hahaha man it's not like i'm even mad about it happening, it's more i'm offended that they went for something so boring
anydoodles
i was fond of the adam and eve story. ngl gave the book a look for how many of the daughters of eve on the page spread were white. i mean really? after the angel wanted to tell me elizabeth the first was the greatest of all eve's daughters? like dang, SOMEONE'S drunk the anglocentric koolaid. but y'know, other than that it was a good time
looked up the authors after i finished and man, i'm not surprised willingham wrote 'the story within the story'. the bar setup was totally him, he's got this massive thing for writing asshole dudes who are proud of their assholedom. someone could prob write a pretty good essay on willngham's masculinity stuff but it's going to have to be someone with enough love in their hearts left to reread his work
i liked chaya surah and the guardian. angels in love! awwww
also rebecca guay is super impressive, like i assumed a different person illustrated each chapter? turns out no! apparently she's the kind of talent that can turn out five distinct art styles in one book. 3.5 stars
Spoiler
of course he kills the angel; what else was he going to do? don't know how to finish a story? death always works! foolish people will think this makes the story edgy and deep and mature!hahaha man it's not like i'm even mad about it happening, it's more i'm offended that they went for something so boring
anydoodles
i was fond of the adam and eve story. ngl gave the book a look for how many of the daughters of eve on the page spread were white. i mean really? after the angel wanted to tell me elizabeth the first was the greatest of all eve's daughters? like dang, SOMEONE'S drunk the anglocentric koolaid. but y'know, other than that it was a good time
looked up the authors after i finished and man, i'm not surprised willingham wrote 'the story within the story'. the bar setup was totally him, he's got this massive thing for writing asshole dudes who are proud of their assholedom. someone could prob write a pretty good essay on willngham's masculinity stuff but it's going to have to be someone with enough love in their hearts left to reread his work
i liked chaya surah and the guardian. angels in love! awwww
also rebecca guay is super impressive, like i assumed a different person illustrated each chapter? turns out no! apparently she's the kind of talent that can turn out five distinct art styles in one book. 3.5 stars
meanoldmom's review against another edition
3.0
Very beautiful and creative, but didn't flow real well for me.
potatomcgee's review against another edition
3.0
I love the way this book contrasted mythology and the artwork is stunning. Each story uses slightly different styles to illustrate the different narrator/author. Some of the stories dragged a bit and the ending was sudden and not fully fleshed out, I didn't think. Still, a gorgeous read that will definitely appeal to fans of mythology and fantasy.
lyctororiole's review
dark
mysterious
reflective
fast-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? Plot
- Strong character development? No
- Loveable characters? It's complicated
- Diverse cast of characters? It's complicated
3.25
vernip's review against another edition
4.0
Really a 3.5 stars so I'm rounding up.
Really good anthology about the winged dudes with halos, but sadly this was made before the "biblically accurate angels" memes became all the rage on the 'Net, so we don't get any of those mindbending creations.
Really good anthology about the winged dudes with halos, but sadly this was made before the "biblically accurate angels" memes became all the rage on the 'Net, so we don't get any of those mindbending creations.