anthroxagorus's review
5.0
I would've liked this more if it wasn't so similar to Creature of the Night (which is doing so much better with the idea of alternate Batman/Bruce Wayne path...) but it's great to see Batman doing detective work, and seeing Selina as a part of his daily world.
marisacarpico's review
3.0
Heavy-handed, but decent. I guess King's storytelling just doesn't bother me as much as it used to. Or he's gotten better. Either way. Still, his form is somewhat less fitting for the typical Batman stories.
etienne02's review
5.0
The details is all wrong... This is not superfriends part 3 at all...
That being said, this one was good, kind of a otherside origin story of what Bruce Wayne could have become featuring a very trouble young kid! I loved it!
That being said, this one was good, kind of a otherside origin story of what Bruce Wayne could have become featuring a very trouble young kid! I loved it!
samhain's review
4.0
Huuum Goodreads, you might want to update this, what I just read had nothing to do with a cute story featuring Bruce and Diana... There's nothing like going into a Batman story expecting it to be a cute filler, and then getting hit by all the feels and all the darkness and horror that is fucking Gotham. How am I supposed to sleep now that this kid's face in the last panels is seared into my brain? King, if you return to the cuteness, I promise I'll never again say it's boring!
Kidding, I loved it. I mean, it was really dark and fucked up, but the anti-parallels were super interesting, and all that guilt falling onto Bruce (although it's not his fault, we all know the guy won't sleep for a very long time after this) as he tried his hardest to save both that kid and his past self, man I can't believe some people saw it as just Gordon asking Bruce to help someone with a similar past as him. It was so much more, and even though I know it's just a filler, a part of me will still be bitter if this is never brought up again. I want to see the aftermath, I want to watch as Bruce tries to heal the kid and has to live with the knowledge that both Batman (with the Joker) and actual Bruce somehow created monsters. For all I talk about wanting Bruce to be happy and safe, Batman is never more interesting, and complex, and relatable, than when he's at the bottom of the pit.
Kidding, I loved it. I mean, it was really dark and fucked up, but the anti-parallels were super interesting, and all that guilt falling onto Bruce (although it's not his fault, we all know the guy won't sleep for a very long time after this) as he tried his hardest to save both that kid and his past self, man I can't believe some people saw it as just Gordon asking Bruce to help someone with a similar past as him. It was so much more, and even though I know it's just a filler, a part of me will still be bitter if this is never brought up again. I want to see the aftermath, I want to watch as Bruce tries to heal the kid and has to live with the knowledge that both Batman (with the Joker) and actual Bruce somehow created monsters. For all I talk about wanting Bruce to be happy and safe, Batman is never more interesting, and complex, and relatable, than when he's at the bottom of the pit.
More...