Scan barcode
raoulduke613's review against another edition
3.0
Read 1-56. Need to do the full order starting with chapter 73 at some point soon.
13shapeshifters's review against another edition
challenging
emotional
reflective
sad
slow-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? Character
- Strong character development? No
- Loveable characters? It's complicated
- Diverse cast of characters? It's complicated
- Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes
5.0
sjstuart's review against another edition
challenging
- Loveable characters? No
- Diverse cast of characters? No
- Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes
3.0
Final review, after a second, full-length, fully "hopscotching" read:
I understand why this is often lauded as a great book. The novelty and experimental style are intriguing. The multi-layered structure is impressive. The references and philosophy could keep me occupied for ages.
But I don't think it's a particularly good book. It takes so much work to read that I only rarely succeeded in immersing myself in its schizophrenic flow. The characters are all insufferable, and I can't say I enjoyed the experience.
Earlier, provisional review:
I have finished one version of this book, but can't yet say what I think of it.
All I can tell for now is that it was only partially comprehensible (that is mostly a bad thing) but that parts of it are nagging at my brain, and won't quite let go (that's probably a good sign).
There's not much point in describing what the book is "about". The few stepping stones that could be called a plot are almost completely submerged under the meandering stream-of-consciousness writing that blends description, interior monologue, and fragmentary conversations. It's the kind of book that rewards a re-reading because you'll get twice as much out of it the second time around -- as long as you don't mind that you've only gone from 20% to 40% comprehension.
Conveniently, the book gives explicit instructions for that re-read. One pass is to be linear, through the first half of the book or so. (That's what I have just completed.) Another pass is to hop around in a prescribed order, interleaving various "expendable" chapters between the chapters in the first half.
I'm hoping that the extra chapters will add some structure and fill in some gaps in the action. But this doesn't seem like that kind of book. It seems more likely that it will just add another layer of confusion, stepping the digressions up another notch.
I'm quite ambivalent about my second dive into this one: both eager and apprehensive.
I understand why this is often lauded as a great book. The novelty and experimental style are intriguing. The multi-layered structure is impressive. The references and philosophy could keep me occupied for ages.
But I don't think it's a particularly good book. It takes so much work to read that I only rarely succeeded in immersing myself in its schizophrenic flow. The characters are all insufferable, and I can't say I enjoyed the experience.
Earlier, provisional review:
I have finished one version of this book, but can't yet say what I think of it.
All I can tell for now is that it was only partially comprehensible (that is mostly a bad thing) but that parts of it are nagging at my brain, and won't quite let go (that's probably a good sign).
There's not much point in describing what the book is "about". The few stepping stones that could be called a plot are almost completely submerged under the meandering stream-of-consciousness writing that blends description, interior monologue, and fragmentary conversations. It's the kind of book that rewards a re-reading because you'll get twice as much out of it the second time around -- as long as you don't mind that you've only gone from 20% to 40% comprehension.
Conveniently, the book gives explicit instructions for that re-read. One pass is to be linear, through the first half of the book or so. (That's what I have just completed.) Another pass is to hop around in a prescribed order, interleaving various "expendable" chapters between the chapters in the first half.
I'm hoping that the extra chapters will add some structure and fill in some gaps in the action. But this doesn't seem like that kind of book. It seems more likely that it will just add another layer of confusion, stepping the digressions up another notch.
I'm quite ambivalent about my second dive into this one: both eager and apprehensive.
zuly's review against another edition
slow-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? Character
- Strong character development? No
- Loveable characters? No
- Diverse cast of characters? No
- Flaws of characters a main focus? No
1.0
acmarinho3's review against another edition
4.0
Uau. Que livro inesperado. Quando o autor nos desafia com dois métodos de leitura decidi escolher, como é óbvio, o mais complexo. Ler saltando de capítulo em capítulo, mais à frente e mais atrás. Na verdade, não fiquei fã com esta opção, porque estou habituada a ir sempre no mesmo ritmo, página a página, por ordem. Senti que ia perdendo o foco ou que me desinteressava do livro mais rapidamente. No entanto, tirando isso, achei uma obra linda! Julio Cortázar é um mestre da prosa poética. Escreve frases tão bonitas e ricas que ficamos com vontade de ficar a saboreá-las e relê-las ad eternum.
polyanna_nas's review against another edition
dnf @15%
Ich wollte das Buch mögen. Ich find das Konzept total toll und hab mich lange darauf gefreut, es zu lesen. Aber es ist ganz viel Geschwafel und viele Anspielungen und Referenzen, die über meinen Kopf hinweggehen. Ich kann einigen Überlegungen nicht folgen und das machen auch die gelegentlich wirklich hübsch formulierten Sätze nicht wett. Schade. Aber im Moment hab ich keinen Kopf für Bücher, die mir keinen Spaß machen. Vielleicht zu einem anderen Zeitpunkt nochmal.
Ich wollte das Buch mögen. Ich find das Konzept total toll und hab mich lange darauf gefreut, es zu lesen. Aber es ist ganz viel Geschwafel und viele Anspielungen und Referenzen, die über meinen Kopf hinweggehen. Ich kann einigen Überlegungen nicht folgen und das machen auch die gelegentlich wirklich hübsch formulierten Sätze nicht wett. Schade. Aber im Moment hab ich keinen Kopf für Bücher, die mir keinen Spaß machen. Vielleicht zu einem anderen Zeitpunkt nochmal.
Content Warnings
Moderate: Alcohol
Minor: Racism and Rape
kristine_m_e's review against another edition
challenging
dark
slow-paced
- Strong character development? No
- Loveable characters? No
- Diverse cast of characters? No
- Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes
2.5
suicidylan_epub's review against another edition
5.0
CORTÁZAR ESCRIBIENDO EN BOLAS CORTÁZAR ESCRIBIENDO EN BOLAS