lelex's review against another edition
5.0
I love love love sci fi that's intense and dense where I have no idea what the fck it's saying but also that I relate to on a weirdly human level. This was one of those pieces. This felt kind of like Becky Chambers but in a more moral conundrum science jargon kind of way. Plus it was wlw which is my science fiction jam.
"Maybe that’s who Simms is. The moment. A place where Laporte never has to think, never has a chance to reflect, never has to be anything other than laughter and kill-joy. But that’s a selfish way to go at it, isn’t it? Simms is her own woman, impatient, profane, ferocious, and Laporte shouldn’t make an icon of her. She’s not a lion, not a war-god, not some kind of oblivion Laporte can curl up inside."
"Care for those you kill. Mourn them. They are human too, and no less afraid."
"But Simms’ voice said: I know how to live with this. I know how to love it."
"Like weaponized poetry, except that deep down your poem always says we have to live. They have to die."
"You don’t remember love as a series of acts. You just know: I love her. So it is here. They fought, and it was good. (And damn, yes, she loves Simms, that much has been apparent for a while, but it’s maybe not the kind of love that anyone does anything about, maybe not the kind it’s wise to voice or touch.)"
"Captain Simms takes the chance to drill her new pilots to exhaustion and they begin to loathe her so profoundly they’d all eat a knife just to hear one word of her approval."
"This happens after the intervention, after Simms teaches Laporte to be a monster (or lets her realize she already was), after they manage the biggest coup of the war—the capture of the Agincourt. Before they fall into the sun, though."
"But Simms and Laporte, they flew each other home. Home to die in this empty searing room with the bolted-down frame chairs and the bottle caps and their cells rotting inside them.
Or maybe it’s just that Simms hated harder than anyone else, hesitated the least. And Laporte, well—she’s never hesitated at all."
"Maybe that’s who Simms is. The moment. A place where Laporte never has to think, never has a chance to reflect, never has to be anything other than laughter and kill-joy. But that’s a selfish way to go at it, isn’t it? Simms is her own woman, impatient, profane, ferocious, and Laporte shouldn’t make an icon of her. She’s not a lion, not a war-god, not some kind of oblivion Laporte can curl up inside."
"Care for those you kill. Mourn them. They are human too, and no less afraid."
"But Simms’ voice said: I know how to live with this. I know how to love it."
"Like weaponized poetry, except that deep down your poem always says we have to live. They have to die."
"You don’t remember love as a series of acts. You just know: I love her. So it is here. They fought, and it was good. (And damn, yes, she loves Simms, that much has been apparent for a while, but it’s maybe not the kind of love that anyone does anything about, maybe not the kind it’s wise to voice or touch.)"
"Captain Simms takes the chance to drill her new pilots to exhaustion and they begin to loathe her so profoundly they’d all eat a knife just to hear one word of her approval."
"This happens after the intervention, after Simms teaches Laporte to be a monster (or lets her realize she already was), after they manage the biggest coup of the war—the capture of the Agincourt. Before they fall into the sun, though."
"But Simms and Laporte, they flew each other home. Home to die in this empty searing room with the bolted-down frame chairs and the bottle caps and their cells rotting inside them.
Or maybe it’s just that Simms hated harder than anyone else, hesitated the least. And Laporte, well—she’s never hesitated at all."
osirismind's review against another edition
I only read Seth Dickinson's story in this issue and it was really good!
selemei's review against another edition
5.0
I'm honored to be a part of this issue alongside my longtime inspiration, Ursula K. LeGuin. I thought Seth Dickinson's story was visceral and fascinating. Thoraiya Dyer's had an interesting mood to it and was very mysterious. Mary Rosenblum's story painted an interesting vision of a post-apocalyptic West, and I really cared about the characters. Ursula LeGuin's story was an interesting thought experiment with some really great language and mood.
oceans's review against another edition
4.0
i just read morrigan in the sunglare, and yeah the quiet yearning and the humanity of it all hurt3
nonesensed's review against another edition
4.0
The concept of "sedoretu", a four person marriage of a culture in Le Guin's vast universe of alien planets, fascinated me from my first introduction to it. Adding in the fact that some people aren't attracted to other genders, or their own gender, makes it twice as interesting.
A short summary for a short story: Enno is a traveling spiritual Evening woman who visits many farms to share teachings. At Danro farm she meets the Morning woman Shahes and falls in love. But while both want to marry they'd need two men, a Morning and an Evening man; a complication seeing as Shahes has little interest in men and has already promissed a marriage to another woman.
The language in this story is beautiful. It's focused on the emotions of the characters, and while there is description of the world too it lets you fill in a lot of the details; a way of environment description that's always worked much better for me than pages upon pages of architecture, flora and fauna.
It would have been a five star story for me if it hadn't had such an open ending. Open endings can be great, but I felt the build-up in this story didn't get the pay-off I was looking for. Still a very interesting story though! Definitely worth the read.
A short summary for a short story: Enno is a traveling spiritual Evening woman who visits many farms to share teachings. At Danro farm she meets the Morning woman Shahes and falls in love. But while both want to marry they'd need two men, a Morning and an Evening man; a complication seeing as Shahes has little interest in men and has already promissed a marriage to another woman.
The language in this story is beautiful. It's focused on the emotions of the characters, and while there is description of the world too it lets you fill in a lot of the details; a way of environment description that's always worked much better for me than pages upon pages of architecture, flora and fauna.
It would have been a five star story for me if it hadn't had such an open ending. Open endings can be great, but I felt the build-up in this story didn't get the pay-off I was looking for. Still a very interesting story though! Definitely worth the read.
More...