Reviews

Great American Whatever by Tim Federle

annemariewellswriter's review against another edition

4.0

If Perks of Being a Wallflower was the new Catcher in the Rye, then The Great American Whatever is the new Perks of Being a Wallflower.

weewaa13's review against another edition

challenging dark emotional funny hopeful reflective sad medium-paced

• Plot- or character-driven? Character
• Strong character development? Yes
• Loveable characters? It's complicated
• Diverse cast of characters? Yes
• Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes

3.75

The style of Quinn’s inner monologue really irked me for the first little bit, but I eventually grew to like (or at least tolerate) it. As someone who enjoys writing screenplays and made short films, I could kind of relate to those parts, and it was sometimes fun when a scene would cut to screenplay format. While it took me a significant amount of time to get into it, it does feel worth the read by the end. 

crystal_reading's review against another edition

I enjoyed this book for the most part. There is humor and I did end up caring about Quinn even though I got a bit annoyed with him sometimes. He's gay, but that is not what the book is about. It's about grieving and trying to start living again. It's about friendship and family.

piperclover's review against another edition

I had high hopes that this was going to be a bit of a wild card and end up being really good even though I wasn't super intrigued to buy the synopsis but I was wrong.  I'm completely uninterested and anyone or anything that's happening even though I find this setup to be interesting with Quinn's sister being dead and him completely refusing to acknowledge any of his emotional baggage because of it. I like Geoff as a friend too and they're dynamic seems sweet and fun.  

But beyond that I don't only enjoy the characterization of Quinn being a quirky, "fabulous" gay film buff.  Maybe that changes throughout the book as he grows as a character but I'm just not enjoying his quirky side comments and his refusal to ask for clarification in any situation. 

finalgirlfall's review against another edition

3.0

it took a while for the humor in this book to grow on me, and the whole "loss of a family member" thing was...not too well done.

scrollsofdragons's review against another edition

4.0

3.5. Quinn was so adorable, and his friend and just everyone. Just really liked it but could think of a few things to give it that little bit more.

federo999's review against another edition

2.0

I wasn't sure what I thought about this book at first. I needed to think about it for a while. It really wasn't memorable, but some of the dialogue was good.

marymanor's review against another edition

3.0

Continuing to read to find books to recommend for 10th grade independent reading. This is one I will highlight.

chelseamh98's review against another edition

5.0

The Great American Whatever has been one of the best books I've read in a while. This book had me laughing from page one and by page three all I kept saying was I love this book. The characters felt so real it felt like I knew them, they all had their own part to the story. This book just needs to be read by teenagers everywhere. It's probably going to be one of my all time favourite books.

wandereaderr's review against another edition

5.0

“I don’t consider myself to be precious, necessarily, but give me air-conditioning or give me death.”

What a great opener, amirite? Tim Federle’s first YA novel The Great American Whatever literally has the exact voice that I want my own writing to have.

Our protagonist, Quinn Roberts, is still dealing with the aftershocks of his sister’s death six months prior to the start of the novel.

“Our little community has basically written us an ongoing blank check of worried looks and faux concern—which is what happens when your big sister gets killed in a car wreck right outside the school on the day before Christmas break.
Oh. Spoiler alert.”

Quinn’s voice is so sarcastic and comical—it kept me entertained the entire novel, and while some people go overboard with the snide tone, Federle kept it interesting. I saw so much of myself in Quinn especially since I was struggling with my sexuality when I was sixteen, too. Federle deals with Quinn’s sexuality in such a funny and realistic way.

“You know when we were little,” I say, “and I used to put your sister’s ballet tutus on my head, before we knew it was kind of strange for boys to do that?”
Geoff puts his palm up to my face and stands. “Quinn, is this about you being gay? I literally don’t care at all.”
Um, what? “Um.” He knows? Wait, Geoff knows. Wait, did something tell him? Wait, I’ve never told anyone.

One of the most endearing and also frustrating things about Quinn is that he’s so wrapped up in his own head he literally does not realize that the world is still spinning. And eventually that catches up to him. His character arc is actually incredible and the ending scene of the novel is golden.

“Sorry. Just: Have I just been, like, some anonymous kid to potentially fuck around with just so you could get even with Evan?”
Amir takes my hand and puts it on his lap. He is completely hard. “Does this,” he says, “feel anonymous to you?”

The romance in the novel is a delightful surprise. The jacket flap makes the romance out to be some major playing point in the book, and while it is pretty important, it kind of takes a backseat to everything else that’s going in Quinn’s life and I think that’s even more important—especially to the YA audience. Teens need to learn to make themselves happy rather than believing that finding a boyfriend/girlfriend will bring them all the happiness in the world. I really enjoyed this aspect of The Great American Whatever. It’s not preachy at all and Quinn learns an important lesson. It’s true for queer people as well as heterosexual people. Age truly does matter—at least when you’re a teenager. Amir is in college, and Quinn is in high school. So much in your brain changes between the ages of fifteen and twenty, even eighteen. So to have Quinn learn of power imbalances so early was an extremely pleasant thing to come across in this book.

“My bad,” Geoff says, resting his elbows on the counter. “I thought all gay dudes were, like, obsessed with foreign films.” He is teasing.
“Geoff, keep your voice down.” I look around again. “Relax.”
“You relax, you big queen,” he says. I gasp again. He is totally poking fun at me. He is totally the best.

Quinn’s relationship with his best friend, Geoff, is definitely a highlight in this novel. Geoff is so good for Quinn and vice versa. And when Quinn finds out about a certain secret that Geoff had been keeping from him, well, it turns into Quinn realizing that he needs to get his head out of his ass and start paying attention. Their friendship is so fun and hilarious. They have some great banter and it was so fun to read. And I really like how the friendship was more highlighted than the romance.

The Great American Whatever is just absolutely incredible. I applaud Tim Federle for giving LGBTQIA+ readers something to enjoy and hopefully learn from. We need more writers like him—fearless and bold and funny as all hell.

“And when I look up to smile at that, at my beautiful mom crunching away, I also see, out of the corner of my eye, the pillowcase fall from the urn. It lands quietly on the floor. I leave it there and I pick up the last page, and I finish what I started.”