Scan barcode
carlajo713's review
2.0
Please see review of the first book for an in depth description of how awful these books are..... I won't expand further. But come on... Jill gives away her entire Beanie Baby collection to her niece because she lied about still having them. Because, she didn't want her snotty fingers touching her collection... And if she didn't she couldn't be Lizzie's aunt anymore? Great lesson learned for a 5 year old.... I won't even point out that the werewolf and vampire met with Jill in a meeting, then 2 chapters later she "meets" them for the first time again.... Irritating. Frustrating. Poorly written. Well wait, I guess I did expand a little.
irene_wolvercote's review against another edition
2.0
My biggest problem with this book is the sister, Kathy, and Jill's lack of emotional response.
kaixxx's review against another edition
3.0
Another cute quirky book, a great series if you just want a light read. Jill has got her hands full as she investigates a murder, the theft of two trophies and a missing cat. The plot was a bit predictable but it was still a good light read. With more funny antics from her family, though I think her sister Kathy is annoying with how manipulative she is towards Jill. A good read though if you just want a light witch book. xxx
asmaa_arqawi's review against another edition
adventurous
funny
lighthearted
medium-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? A mix
- Strong character development? No
- Loveable characters? It's complicated
- Diverse cast of characters? No
- Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes
2.0
brokensporty's review against another edition
4.0
I still think this series is adorable and everything a pre-teen girl needs to pass time and foster an early love for reading much like Nancy Drew did for me and generations before me.
The first book provided background for the series and this second book builds upon that while a new mystery is solved. The early part of this book line-up summarized the first book.
The same main characters are still unnecessarily annoying and not endearing at all. Nothing will convince me that a grown woman (sister or not) would put up with the level of meddling that Kathy inflicts on Jill.
I still recommend this series for anyone who has a short amount of time and wants a light read.
The first book provided background for the series and this second book builds upon that while a new mystery is solved. The early part of this book line-up summarized the first book.
The same main characters are still unnecessarily annoying and not endearing at all. Nothing will convince me that a grown woman (sister or not) would put up with the level of meddling that Kathy inflicts on Jill.
I still recommend this series for anyone who has a short amount of time and wants a light read.
thehodgenator's review against another edition
4.0
This sequel was such a fun listen.
Jill is back - with the zany Mrs. V, her sister Cathy, her new-found witchy fam, and all the complications with balancing a PI firm, family, and learning new spells.
There was a lot happening in this one - crimes to solve, spells to learn so tests could be passed, her sister, and more. One thing that makes this different from other cozy listens is that Jill is working on case after case after case, so it's interesting to listen to the different types of cases she stumbles on, and how she consistently seems to show up the local police.
One thing I do not enjoy is her sister Cathy. I cannot tell you how many times she made me so annoyed with her character. It's to the point that I'm ready for Jill to move to Candlefield and just be around her new witchy family because Cathy really over-steps her bounds too many times.
With that said, I love all the other characters - returning and new. They are so fun, but I think my favorite is grandma. Man, she does not hold back at all. Her expectations are high, and you either meet them or she flames you (but not literally). This leads to many comical moments. I had to stop myself from laughing while I was listening at the gym.
Really looking forward to the next one. Here's to more in Candlefield and less of Cathy.
Jill is back - with the zany Mrs. V, her sister Cathy, her new-found witchy fam, and all the complications with balancing a PI firm, family, and learning new spells.
There was a lot happening in this one - crimes to solve, spells to learn so tests could be passed, her sister, and more. One thing that makes this different from other cozy listens is that Jill is working on case after case after case, so it's interesting to listen to the different types of cases she stumbles on, and how she consistently seems to show up the local police.
One thing I do not enjoy is her sister Cathy. I cannot tell you how many times she made me so annoyed with her character. It's to the point that I'm ready for Jill to move to Candlefield and just be around her new witchy family because Cathy really over-steps her bounds too many times.
With that said, I love all the other characters - returning and new. They are so fun, but I think my favorite is grandma. Man, she does not hold back at all. Her expectations are high, and you either meet them or she flames you (but not literally). This leads to many comical moments. I had to stop myself from laughing while I was listening at the gym.
Really looking forward to the next one. Here's to more in Candlefield and less of Cathy.
krypto6661's review against another edition
4.0
Good but
Okay I think this story is funny and interesting. The magic is described in a neat way and I’m even okay with the standard trope of a “DarkOne”. My issue is Kathy, her sister. Jill is obviously neurodivergent, and Kathy emotionally and mentally abuses her. It takes zero dollars to be nice to someone you claim to love.
Okay I think this story is funny and interesting. The magic is described in a neat way and I’m even okay with the standard trope of a “DarkOne”. My issue is Kathy, her sister. Jill is obviously neurodivergent, and Kathy emotionally and mentally abuses her. It takes zero dollars to be nice to someone you claim to love.
pglt1177's review against another edition
4.0
book 2 and I am already in love wiyh Drake and Jack. ans Jill is snarky which I love
jackfishbooks's review against another edition
funny
lighthearted
medium-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? Character
- Strong character development? No
- Loveable characters? It's complicated
- Diverse cast of characters? No
- Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes
3.0