Scan barcode
kylalouis's review
4.0
Interesting, fictional portrayal of two families, one black, one white during Hurricane Katrina. The writing was descriptive and vivid and juxtaposition of the two families captured the tragedy of Katrina. I kept waiting for a bit more of a climax.
minvanwin's review
4.0
City of Refuge is Tom Piazza's passionate love letter to New Orleans. This story about how Hurricane Katrina affected two families--one white and middle class, one poor and black--is at turns heart- and gut-wrenching. Large chunks of the book read like narrative non-fiction: descriptions of the city, the levees, the damage, and media attention during the storm and its immediate aftermath, and diatribes about an ineffective and disorganized government response. The main white character seems largely autobiographical while the rest of the characters feel like composite portraits based on thousands of victims and evacuees. Certainly not a perfect book, but definitely worth reading.
hurricaneflora's review
dark
emotional
reflective
sad
slow-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? Character
- Strong character development? Yes
- Loveable characters? Yes
- Diverse cast of characters? Yes
- Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes
5.0
serenaac's review
5.0
Tom Piazza's own experience of being evacuated from New Orleans must have played a significant role in his writing of City of Refuge. The horror, the grief, the devastation, the hollowness, and a range of other emotions following the 2005 disaster, known as Hurricane Katrina, rips through readers' hearts and puts them through the wringer alongside SJ, Craig, and their families.
"A block away water bubbling and churning from a submerged, ruptured gas line. Below him, amid a cataract of smashed weatherboard, face-down in the water, a man, unmoving; his white T-shirt had ridden up his back almost all the way to his shoulder. A black dog swam by. Not twenty feet away, the sole of a sneaker stuck out of the water, held up by an ankle attached to an invisible leg, waving slightly, probably snagged on something below the surface. . ." (Page 139)
SJ and his family live in the Lower Ninth Ward, which was the hardest hit by the hurricane's storm surge, while Craig and his family live in a different section of New Orleans. On the surface, both of these families are different from their skin color to where they live and from their education to their jobs, but what they have in common is a deep connection to the city, its culture, and their homes. Beyond the moral outrage of New Orleanians against the government, insurance companies, and others, which readers will surely have seen on the news or in the papers and magazines, Piazza's novel weaves a tale of surprising resilience -- a common trait in humanity -- a will to survive.
"One day he saw something he had seen every day for a month and a half, a loose hinge on the closet door. He went downstairs to Aaron's utility room, rummaged around and found a Phillips head screwdriver and an assortment of screws and simply replaced the screw that was in the hinge with a larger one. That would hold it until he could really fix the hinge.
That was how you came back, if you came back." (Page 285)
Each of these families has their own personal struggles and dynamics, which Piazza deftly navigates in alternating story lines weaving a tense atmosphere before, during, and after the hurricane. Piazza's characters are deep with their own backgrounds, personalities, and demons, and SJ is a prime example. As a Vietnam War veteran, he's already had enough to deal with before Hurricane Katrina. In a way -- like so many other veterans -- he never made it back from the war completely and has been going through the motions of life.
"Aaron would get him to go out for walks. Aaron, who had also been in Vietnam, knew a fair amount about the traumatic syndrome that SJ was struggling with, and exercise and talking through things could be important. Some days they would walk and SJ was silent, some days he would talk for a while, and then get silent. Often he had violent fantasies that would crumble apart into debilitating grief. 'I don't want to be angry like this A,' SJ said. 'I spent long enough dealing with it. I never thought I'd have to be back in this.'" (Page 273)
Piazza's comparisons of PTSD among Vietnam War veterans and the PTSD of New Orleanians is a valid comparison, and City of Refuge brings with it an emotional tsunami that readers cannot ignore. One of the best books I've read this year, and an excellent selection for book clubs because of the range of social and political issues it illuminates.
"A block away water bubbling and churning from a submerged, ruptured gas line. Below him, amid a cataract of smashed weatherboard, face-down in the water, a man, unmoving; his white T-shirt had ridden up his back almost all the way to his shoulder. A black dog swam by. Not twenty feet away, the sole of a sneaker stuck out of the water, held up by an ankle attached to an invisible leg, waving slightly, probably snagged on something below the surface. . ." (Page 139)
SJ and his family live in the Lower Ninth Ward, which was the hardest hit by the hurricane's storm surge, while Craig and his family live in a different section of New Orleans. On the surface, both of these families are different from their skin color to where they live and from their education to their jobs, but what they have in common is a deep connection to the city, its culture, and their homes. Beyond the moral outrage of New Orleanians against the government, insurance companies, and others, which readers will surely have seen on the news or in the papers and magazines, Piazza's novel weaves a tale of surprising resilience -- a common trait in humanity -- a will to survive.
"One day he saw something he had seen every day for a month and a half, a loose hinge on the closet door. He went downstairs to Aaron's utility room, rummaged around and found a Phillips head screwdriver and an assortment of screws and simply replaced the screw that was in the hinge with a larger one. That would hold it until he could really fix the hinge.
That was how you came back, if you came back." (Page 285)
Each of these families has their own personal struggles and dynamics, which Piazza deftly navigates in alternating story lines weaving a tense atmosphere before, during, and after the hurricane. Piazza's characters are deep with their own backgrounds, personalities, and demons, and SJ is a prime example. As a Vietnam War veteran, he's already had enough to deal with before Hurricane Katrina. In a way -- like so many other veterans -- he never made it back from the war completely and has been going through the motions of life.
"Aaron would get him to go out for walks. Aaron, who had also been in Vietnam, knew a fair amount about the traumatic syndrome that SJ was struggling with, and exercise and talking through things could be important. Some days they would walk and SJ was silent, some days he would talk for a while, and then get silent. Often he had violent fantasies that would crumble apart into debilitating grief. 'I don't want to be angry like this A,' SJ said. 'I spent long enough dealing with it. I never thought I'd have to be back in this.'" (Page 273)
Piazza's comparisons of PTSD among Vietnam War veterans and the PTSD of New Orleanians is a valid comparison, and City of Refuge brings with it an emotional tsunami that readers cannot ignore. One of the best books I've read this year, and an excellent selection for book clubs because of the range of social and political issues it illuminates.
kfan's review
4.0
Loved this. So, so sad. but so good. People need to be nice to each other.
I would have preferred if he had stayed down on the ground with the families 100% of the time, but the times when he goes up to give the birds eye view didn't take me out of the story too much. This is a good book.
I would have preferred if he had stayed down on the ground with the families 100% of the time, but the times when he goes up to give the birds eye view didn't take me out of the story too much. This is a good book.
engpunk77's review
3.0
3.5. The beginning and ending were rough, but the middle (when Hurricane Katrina arrives) kept me hungry for more. It ended up being a good choice as prep for my first New Orleans visit; this book worships the city, its people, and its culture. I just wasn’t at all attached to the characters. But I do hAve new understanding of some NOLA residents’ choices not to evacuate and a much deeper appreciation for what actually happened to people who stayed and those who evacuated.
tacoshark's review
5.0
This is just an incredible book. The characters are so beautifully drawn, and the city of New Orleans is so vivid. The storm just breaks your heart, and the aftermath, which is actually most of the book, is even more tragic. I think everyone should read this book.
cnyreader's review
5.0
While this is a work of fiction, this is the true story of so many who endured Hurricane Katrina and dealt with the aftermath in their beloved New Orleans. I've read more than a couple books on this topic, and the skill with which Piazza balances the storm of emotions, brings the reader to the reality of the experience as much as we are able, is remarkable. It's not about race, it's not about politics, it's just about survival and the city that they call home.